4 ms·
I got nailed in a lower comment for suggesting that Betteridge's law applies here (I know I know.. Betteridge's law isn't hard and fast and it's SO over/passe)
by brm 11y ago
I got nailed in a lower comment for suggesting that Betteridge's law applies here (I know I know.. Betteridge's law isn't hard and fast and it's SO over/passe), but we live in an age where bullshit reigns and I'm willing to double down...
This is from the Telegraph, a paper who at this point basically reprints press releases on science and history with sensational titles (Not that they're the only guilty ones). Other major sources of this specific spin on the article are the Daily Mail and the New York Post (SfGate takes a slightly less sensational approach to the new evidence).
Clearly your crap detector should be tingling when you see these sources as the main sources and then bang! you find it: There's a new History Channel show premiering soon about this very escape - Alcatraz: Search for the Truth.
Gee I wonder why this is making the rounds? Will it end just like any other search for history show in the annals of television: "inconclusive evidence: the mystery is still out there and we'll keep searching we promise"
This is a different form of PG's Submarine PR hit http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html and frankly it makes me mad/sad that its so high up on a site like HN.
Feel free to continue downvoting me into oblivion and I'll continue shouting into the void.
- mindcrime 11y agofrankly it makes me mad/sad that its so high up on a site like HN I don't get that mindset. Who cares if it's a "quality" story or not, so long as it sparks an interesting discussion? And the thing about the HN crowd is, even the most banal articles can, and often do, spark a really interesting discussion. I would argue that upvoting this isn't upvoting this specific link or this specific story...it's just upvoting the general topic.
- rickdale 11y agoActually that History channel show already premiered. That's where the article gets the information. The show was decent for what its worth. It gives some pretty good evidence that those boys survived the escape and has the US Marshals on it and stuff. At least worth fast forwarding through