3 ms·
The statistical hypothesis in the OP seems sound...for those of you who've had to pitch studies like these and apply for funding (on any topic)...does the insti
by danso 11y ago
The statistical hypothesis in the OP seems sound...for those of you who've had to pitch studies like these and apply for funding (on any topic)...does the institutional reluctance to fund these studies scale disproportionately to the proposed cost per participant and total possible participants?
i.e. is it easier to convince the university/funder to do a study that could potentially connect with 6,000 students at just $5 a piece, versus a study that, at most, could reach 600 students at $50 a piece?
edit: My guess is -- yes, that it is easier to convince people, even at the university level, with nicer sounding numbers even if competing proposals add up to the same cost, even if the cheaper/broader-sounding proposal is scientifically less valid, because in general, people have difficulty with numerical reasoning. I mean, the OP felt the need (and may have been asked to by the WaPo editor) to describe cross-multiplication, something we all were supposed to have learned in elementary school:
> But even if the response rate is not 100 percent, it allows us to place a lower bound on how many students have been assaulted. For example, if 90 percent of students respond to the survey, and 20 percent of them say they have been assaulted, we can infer that at least 90 percent x 20 percent = 18 percent of students have been assaulted, even if none of the students who failed to respond were.
- akiselev 11y agoMy experience is in biology/medical research not the social sciences, and I worked with a well known PI, so grain of salt and all that, but I have rarely found the operational specifics of the grant application to matter because the people at the NSF/NIH are rarely qualified to evaluate experiments and their scientific calidity on that level. Assuming we're not talking absurd cost differences (like a $200 thousand exploratory experiment vs a $10 million pre-clinical trial), then being able to hype the potential benefits of your research, having good political standing in your university/field, and having a well known name involved is far more important. Grants are sort of like college admissions at Harvard or Yale. There are about five to ten times too many qualified applicants than there are available opportunities and as a result the "best of the best" group, whose members are practically indistinguishable from each other, essentially becomes a random lottery pool for the available spots.
- Someone 11y ago"is it easier to convince the university/funder to do a study that could potentially connect with 6,000 students at just $5 a piece, versus a study that, at most, could reach 600 students at $50 a piece?" My guess would be that people would be more inclined to ask whether it couldn't be 600 students at $25 a piece for the same effect, than they would whether it couldn't be 6000 students for $2.50 a piece. Certainly, in the limit there will be some truth in that. You don't need to offer a single student $30.000 for 15 minutes of work to be virtually assured that (s)he will bite; $10,000 will do just as well.