6 ms·
You can't really prescribe one macronutrient ratio for everyone. Someone who is morbidly obese might do best on a diet almost completely absent in carbohydrate
by CuriouslyC 11y ago
You can't really prescribe one macronutrient ratio for everyone. Someone who is morbidly obese might do best on a diet almost completely absent in carbohydrates, while someone who is lean will do better on a diet that is relatively high in carbohydrates. Additionally, activity level makes a big difference in optimal carbohydrate intake.
For instance, I'm _very_ lean and active, and I thrive on a diet that is almost fat free (I get my essential fats from eggs and fish oil).
- ihsw 11y agoYeah I know exactly what you mean, at that point I'm hoping people will research nutrition and exercise enough to find out what is optimal for them. You are correct, given a person's current health and activity level, their nutrient requirements can vary greatly.
- noondip 11y agoYou can get both essential ω-3 and ω-6 short chain polyunsaturated fatty acids from flaxseed, without the baggage of eggs (high cholesterol) and fish oil (high levels of persistent organic pollutants).
- gorena 11y agohttp://examine.com/faq/will-eating-eggs-increase-my-cholesterol/ http://examine.com/faq/will-eating-eggs-increase-my-choleste...
- noondip 11y agoMany of the studies referenced on that site are funded or carried out by egg lobbying groups. One study literally compares eggs' effects on cholesterol levels compared to a diet of sausage and cheese. It's important to be critical of biased research! This is not good science.
- saosebastiao 11y agoAnd a tiny glimpse at your post history shows that you are a rabid advocate of a vegan diet. Not exactly unbiased yourself.
- noondip 11y agoPlease reply to my comment based on its scientific merit without resorting to an ad hominem attack.
- saosebastiao 11y agoThere was no scientific merit in your comment. You mentioned that some studies out of a list of many that disagreed with your opinion had potential for bias in their conclusions due to external motives. I merely pointed out the same potential for bias in your conclusions.
- noondip 11y agoI don't have a financial incentive to promote healthy food, whereas the studies I've criticized do have a serious conflict of interest. It isn't difficult to see the difference.
- saosebastiao 11y agoYou're right...there is a substantial difference. Financial motives generally tend to be much weaker than religious or philosophical motives because financial stakes are much easier to trade, liquidate, or abandon. If the evidence ever becomes overwhelming that eggs are bad for you, proponents of egg consumption can easily become a proponents of kale consumption. Veganism, being a fundamentalist philosophical extension of more pragmatic vegetarian diets, does not share the same strength of motive; evidence to the contrary is a refutation of the validity of the entire belief system. It will always be much harder to move away from a belief system than it is to move away from money.
- CuriouslyC 11y agoBecause my diet is so low fat, I actually want the cholesterol. Low fat/high fiber diets basically shut down the genes responsible for endogenous cholesterol synthesis (via SREBP2), I'm pretty sure if I didn't eat lots of eggs my testosterone would be in the toilet (among other things). Additionally, eggs are very high in arachidonic acid, which is the thing your body actually needs (linoleic acid is only essential as a precursor to arachidonic acid production), and the eggs I buy also contain very high levels of vitamin D, vitamin E and iodine. As for the fish oil, I buy a high quality supplement that claims to be extremely high purity (though of course this being supplements, that could mean anything). The rational for fish oil over flax is that it contains EPA/DHA, which are the fatty acids that are actually responsible for most of the beneficial effects; your body is pretty poor at metabolizing alpha-linolenic acid to EPA/DHA.
- noondip 11y agoIf you're concerned with the metabolization of shorter chain omega-3’s found in flaxseeds, you can take an algae-based DHA supplement and still avoid toxic industrial pollutants found in fish oil. Still, flaxseed is amazing stuff.
- logfromblammo 11y agoFor a vegan diet, I'd prefer chia seed over flaxseed. Its greatest advantage is that the seed does not need to be milled (exposing the oils inside to light and oxygen) to be digested. Second, it has more of that mucilaginous fiber coating than flax, making beverages such as chia fresca possible. Third, I just like the flavor better. The disadvantage is cost per kg. Chia still costs more than flax. But one need not pick just one or the other; they're both excellent foods. Non-vegans can go lower on the food chain than fish oil by eating krill oil. Krill are only one step up from algae. In theory, krill-based foods could be farmed more sustainably than fish, but in practice, most of the wild krill catch is fed to fish farms. If krill were more popular as a direct-to-human food, there might be more financial incentive to farm it rather than catch it wild.
- jobu 11y agoFlaxseed oil contains mostly the omega-3 called alpha-linolenic acid (ALA), whereas fish oil has a more balanced profile of omega-3s, specifically EPA and DHA. Many people can convert ALA into other omega-3s just fine, but some people have deficiencies in diet or genetics (e.g. MTHFR mutation) that prevent efficient conversion.
- logfromblammo 11y agoAlso, flaxseed oil goes rancid rather quickly in comparison to other oils, and polymerizes into semisolid or solid forms. This process begins as soon as the seed hull is cracked. If you're trying to change the diet of an entire city, it is probably better to promote unmilled chia seed and whole oily fish or krill. Unlike flax seed, chia seed can be digested without milling. There's also something to be said for algae and algae oil, but it isn't likely to be useful until someone works out how to change its flavor to be more palatable.