3 ms·
I think the tribal aversion of engineers to marketing is coming out in force here. Being authentic is wonderful. Of course, we know authenticity is prized by
by patio11 17y ago
I think the tribal aversion of engineers to marketing is coming out in force here.
Being authentic is wonderful. Of course, we know authenticity is prized by this community (and many others). So if we get up on a soapbox and say "Be authentic!", are we being authentic or are we marketing?
I think the answer is "both".
The prior post rubbed me wrong not because it was "Give people what they want!" and not because it was introspective, but because it seemed to glorify pageviews for the sake of pageviews, as opposed to there being some strategy to actually create value. If folks had perceived value creation, they probably wouldn't have cared if titles were optimized for their interests.
I'm not particularly enthusiastic about personal promotion via scaring people into thinking Facebook exists to out gay people, but at the bottom of that post, there was a brief aside about how you should take the hint if people retitle your post when tweeting it. That is a SOLID piece of concrete, actionable advice about writing good titles, which is a core competency for marketing It also provides value to all parties. There is a reason I don't title my blog posts "Something I thought today."
I think if people perceived the posts as "creating more value than they captured", they would have no problem whatsoever with optimizing the execution of them.
- maxklein 17y agoRead the first article - I think there is more actionable and useful stuff in there that people just starting out can use. But I think I overshot my targets and my attempt at exposure is leading to a backlash. I'll just stop talking now and go off and write my next article, which will be more 'me'.
- RyanMcGreal 17y agoHonestly, I'm not quite sure where all the controversy is coming from. If I'm going to take the time to write an article for my blog, I'm generally going to write something that I think would be interesting enough to be worth reading for other people as well as worth writing for myself. Otherwise I'm merely indulging myself, and that tends to make for unbearably bad writing. Likewise, when I think of a title, I try to come up with something that will attract people's interest so they read the article. Is that "social engineering"? If not, how is it different from what you did? Is the issue here intent - the intent to create something interesting/useful vs. the intent to capture pageviews per se - or is it merely the tone of your subsequent introspection, which admittedly was nakedly gloating about having achieved your objective of attracting readers and twitter followers? Finally, what is the latter if not a reasonable proxy you used to measure the former?
- physcab 17y agoI think arguing about what you did is right or wrong misses the point. You're free to say whatever you want on your own blog. For the record though, I had no idea who you were before reading your previous two posts, but after reading your third, I'm left with a negative impression of your writing and probably will not be coming back and will probably associate that with your HN username as well.
- Murkin 17y agoHow is a blog post different than websites in this respect. 90% of the posts here speak about improving conversion (A/B testing and such) instead of adding features. How much value that adds ? _ZERO_. But you accept that. Now explain to me how that is different than iterating/engineering your blog posts ?
- steveklabnik 17y agoImproving conversion rates may very well add value. 'Value' != 'features', it's entirely possible that a site has a bad conversion rate because it's confusing or hard to use. A/B testing helps to improve this, which is certainly 'more value' in my mind.
- Murkin 17y agoSo does a well written and targeted blog post. Website owners do it for money. Bloggers and Twitterers do it for fame. I would personally love to see more posts on Good writing, Audience targeting and Engagement.
- ryanelkins 17y agoPeople want to learn how to manipulate others, not how they themselves were manipulated. The fact that this article which basically just says "I don't try to manipulate you!" has been sitting at the top for a while validates this. When people are done being offended maybe they will realize that there is something to learn from it, whether you agree with it or not. It would be interesting to see how this would have played out if the target of this "hack" had been someone other than the HN community themselves.