4 ms·
There is a case for open borders, in a perfect world. On the other hand, the destination country does not get any equity in the source country, as deferment. I
by mc32 11y ago
There is a case for open borders, in a perfect world. On the other hand, the destination country does not get any equity in the source country, as deferment. Immigrants take up resources (housing, educational, etc.) and send money out (remittances).
Let's say you're running a great country with a great economy, Singapore. And, suddenly in a gesture of humanity, you open borders, and you have 5 million people stream in, maybe ten. How good is Singapore going to be as a destination with that kind of migratory assault on resources, infrastructure, culture, economy etc? Do they get dividends on the source country which squandered its opportunities (say Indonesia with vast natural resources).
And what's the incentive for the people/gov't in the other countries to shape up? Remember, at the turn of the 20th century[1], lots of poor countries were on par with now developed nations and many developed and rich nations were backwaters (Norway, Sweden) and many powerhouses were very agricultural (the US, Japan, China, Russia) and kind of backward.
I think one could just as well make a case for, wait for it, the great bogey-concept, imperialism.
Why not have Singapore control Indonesia, bring in expertise, a culture of success, government and eradicate corruption gov't malfeasance and bring prosperity to Indonesia, for example?
I mean, what's the difference between Indonesians going to Singapore to become like Singaporeans and adopt some of their culture, versus Singapore having dominion over Indonesia and instilling some of their culture, success, economic prowess, etch, thus becoming a bit Singaporean?
[1]http://ourworldindata.org/data/growth-and-distribution-of-prosperity/gdp-growth-over-the-last-centuries/ http://ourworldindata.org/data/growth-and-distribution-of-pr...
graphs show disparity in the 2 - 3x in the early 20th cent.
- em3rgent0rdr 11y ago>> "Let's say you're running a great country with a great economy, Singapore. And, suddenly in a gesture of humanity, you open borders, and you have 5 million people stream in, maybe ten. How good is Singapore going to be as a destination with that kind of migratory assault on resources, infrastructure, culture, economy etc?" Well some of the concerns you are raising here are offset by simple economics. As more people arrive, due to fixed supply of land and limited ability to import resources, prices of everything will gradually increase, up to a point where the next potential immigrant would no longer be interested in immigrating.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoBut at this point hasn't the previously great economy been destroyed?
- Asbostos 11y agoNo. The people already there can afford it because they have a job and get paid in the local currency. It's just like what's happened in New York or San Francisco. Don't go there if you're unemployed or it'll be very difficult to survive. Those places allow free immigration from the rest of the US but they've reached capacity and stopped growing much. Of course this assumes immigrants aren't given social welfare.
- TeMPOraL 11y ago> Of course this assumes immigrants aren't given social welfare. Yeah, that is the key point I was implicitly not assuming. Thanks.
- weddpros 11y ago_ up to a point where the next potential immigrant would no longer be interested in immigrating_ Do you really think economic immigrants can already afford the current prices? Do they move to the USA because it's cheap? or because it's rich? "Simple economics" don't work well here...
- s73v3r 11y agoAnd now you've got a bunch of other problems, many of them being inflicted on your citizens.
- Asbostos 11y agoImperialism can be fantastic, but in much the same way a one-party political system can be fantastic. Only if it happens to be run well. There's no safety valve in case the powerful group goes off the rails oppressing the weaker one. People seem to prefer living in a bad life as long as they feel their in-group members are responsible for it. For example, India has a democracy and the people keep voting for the corrupt parties that maintain it as a poor country full of suffering. They don't mind because it's themselves causing the problems. In contrast, China doesn't have a democracy but is perhaps treating its people better than India. Yet many Chinese still don't like the authoritarianism. I think it's just a sense of being in control that people want, even if they can't handle it competently.
- LoSboccacc 11y agoyup, as ideal as a single world government can be, none of our system scale that well to cope with a government with global power