2 ms·
I disagree; I think sandworm nailed an essential issue. At the top of this subthread, Zikes claimed that Google's cars are a "proven technology." Not even Goog
by snowwrestler 11y ago
I disagree; I think sandworm nailed an essential issue.
At the top of this subthread, Zikes claimed that Google's cars are a "proven technology." Not even Google claims that now, and legality is indeed part of that.
Driverless elevators are an example of an actual proven technology. There's no human operator standing by to jump on the manual brake in case the automation fails. And if a driverless elevator does fail and causes harm, the elevator's manufacturer can be sued for damages.
Now, the idea of a "driverless" elevator seems like a silly name for just a regular elevator, but I chose that for a reason. Elevators used to have drivers, and people are already drawing the comparisons to cars:
http://www.npr.org/2015/07/31/427990392/remembering-when-driverless-elevators-drew-skepticism http://www.npr.org/2015/07/31/427990392/remembering-when-dri...
Is Google willing to assume the same type of liability for their self-driving cars? Certainly not right now, so it's hard to call their technology fully proven.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoI agree with you here. Also, the example of "driverless elevator" is excellent; I'll be remembering it for consideration in further discussion about self-driving technologies. Thanks for bringing this up. Also, wtf is with downvoting in both Tesla threads today? Especially 'sandworm101 is taking a heavy hit for bringing up reasonable counterpoints (with most I disagree, but it doesn't change they're reasonable).
- Lewton 11y agoHis points really are not reasonable at all. He's completely ignoring that humans are generally pretty bad at driving cars and implying that AI driven cars need to be perfect before they should be replacing humans. If we banned human driving today and replaced it with the current tech (which probably isn't near being ready for actual use), we would still be far better off than we are now.
- snowwrestler 11y agoWhere's the evidence to support this sentiment? I see it all the time and it looks to me that people just take it on faith that computers will be better. I mean, here on HN, discussions of computing products like phones and operating systems are full of complaints large and small about problems, shortcomings, etc. Are there any programmers here who think their product is bug-free and safely survives all edge cases? There just seems to be a huge mismatch between how people think about computers they use today, and computers they expect to drive their car in the near future. But it all comes out of the same companies and software development processes. I also don't think people know the stats on car safety. The injury rate is 75 per 100 million miles traveled. About 35,000 people died from vehicle accidents in 2013. That sounds like a lot, but more people died from the flu, or from falls, than died from cars. I won't deny that vehicle travel is dangerous, but the question is why we think computers would be better at it than humans, who are already pretty darn good at it.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoHumans aren't pretty good at it, and we know the problems we have are exactly the parts where machines are already stronger than us. We also have some good deployments of automated technology, notably in air travel, which is flying on decades old technology anyway. > I mean, here on HN, discussions of computing products like phones and operating systems are full of complaints large and small about problems, shortcomings, etc. Are there any programmers here who think their product is bug-free and safely survives all edge cases? The problems with phones and operating systems are often not because of engineers, but because of businessmen. Especially phones and webdev - you can often trace the problems back to decision made in order to increase sales or save money. Most phone vendors ship shitty UIs and buggy devices not because they have bad engineers.
- icebraining 11y agoWhen the current elevator models were being tested, they probably had someone ready to press the STOP button if they went awry. Yet they were still the exact same driverless elevators you're talking about, just in a test environment. And so are Google cars currently.