3 ms·
So how is the vexing situation resolved? Either the onboard computer must be able to manage 100% of all situations, or the human driver must have an option to t
by snowwrestler 11y ago
So how is the vexing situation resolved? Either the onboard computer must be able to manage 100% of all situations, or the human driver must have an option to take control to resolve it themselves.
You can't have a car that makes human control impossible, and then gets itself into vexing situations. You'll be stuck there forever.
- bloaf 11y agoIs it impossible for a human to get a car permanently stuck? *edit: put another way, is it possible for a human driver to extricate a car from any situation?
- snowwrestler 11y agoWell the parent refers only to certain situations--those in which the robocar gets vexed and chooses to slow down or stop. I would expect humans to be able to resolve those types of situations, since we rarely find humans sitting in perfectly working cars on the side of the road just because they are vexed.
- bloaf 11y agoAh, I see that you are referring to a scenario in which the vexation and stopping are not both products of some external stimulus (e.g. [1]) or malfunction but something else altogether. For example, parents who pull their perfectly working car to the side of the road to discipline their vexatious children. It certainly seems possible that a self-driving car might occasionally get itself into a situation requiring a reboot, but that seems like an awfully low price to pay for the convenience of autonomous driving. [1] http://extras.mnginteractive.com/live/media/site36/2007/0811/20070811_055248_op12bridge.jpg http://extras.mnginteractive.com/live/media/site36/2007/0811...
- jessaustin 11y agoFor nearly every mistake that human drivers make, a good way to prevent it is to slow down. Not every situation must be navigated at maximum speed. Robocars will be better drivers than humans, but slower will still be safer. I'm not talking about cars parked in the lane indefinitely because they're confused by some dirt obscuring the center line. If that had been a thing the Google cars would already have fixed it.
- IanCal 11y ago> For nearly every mistake that human drivers make, a good way to prevent it is to slow down. This is an important point, one where the comparison to aircraft doesn't work. Aircraft and the Apollo missions couldn't have a failsafe that just says "I think something is wrong, come to a gentle stop".
- Fradow 11y agoWhy assume it is the "on-board" human (if there is even one) that has to resolve the situation? It could be a remote pilot (sort-of call center, except the people are trained to remotely drive cars, much like drones are piloted right now). Then, the situation (and the remote pilot reaction) are sent to the engineering team, analysed and the software is improved. Rinse and repeat until the need to solve situations is reduced to zero.