5 ms·
As a Tesla enthusiast, would you buy a Tesla that wasn't capable of breaking the speed limit? Perhaps one that couldn't ever under any circumstances move faste
by sandworm101 11y ago
As a Tesla enthusiast, would you buy a Tesla that wasn't capable of breaking the speed limit? Perhaps one that couldn't ever under any circumstances move faster than 70mph? That doesn't require fancy tech. It could be done today in an instant.
That's where I see the real sticking point for automation. Driving isn't about getting from A to B, nor is safety the top priority. If it were, there wouldn't be such a thing as a V-8 (or whatever the electric equivalent is). I find it very ironic that a performance car like the Tesla might promote "the path to full car automation". You think the gun debate is tricky? Try telling people they cannot do 51 in a 50 anymore.
- alexland 11y agoIt's a temporary problem though. Speed limits are set to try and keep people safe, by enforcing a maximum speed. Once computers drive the cars, the speed limit can be cranked up because reaction time goes up drastically and distracted drivers are nonexistent. I expect to see lots of changes in driving laws once automation takes over for exactly this reason.
- Leszek 11y agoIt's more likely to be cranked down though, because that's more efficient and people might be less frustrated with slow driving if they can kill time on their phones during the drive.
- sandworm101 11y agoKill time? Regardless of who is driving, time spend sitting the car is time spend away from family/pets/work/food/bathrooms and everything else important.
- iopq 11y agoDon't worry, Tesla model S comes with a bathroom, a car office, a mini kitchen and a petting zoo
- sandworm101 11y agoSo Telsa is branching out into RVs? I guess that would be the logical synergy of telsa performance cars and tesla wall-mounted battery packs.
- ecdavis 11y agoThe improvements in traffic flow gained through full automation may even offset the decreased speed limits.
- sandworm101 11y agoOr full automation might increase the number of vehicles and exacerbate the problem. (On the assumption that the vastly reduced cost of fielding driveless vehicles could result in many more commercial vehicles on the road.)
- rev_bird 11y agoBut automation can also increase vehicle density: "Stop and go" traffic is way more efficient when it's not groggy humans doing the stopping and going.
- sandworm101 11y agoI'm not sure about that. Keeping the cars closer together would suggest more abrupt acceleration and braking to such to avoid space being created as the car ahead accelerates from a stop. Given these accelerations will not be initiated by the driver, they will come as a surprise and thus be more jarring. I imagine that might result in autodrives that accelerate/brake more slowly, leaving greater distances between cars in stop=and-go environs. And I cannot see autodrives leaving much less room between cars while in steady motion or stopped. Humans are pretty good at tailgating.
- michaelmior 11y agoI think the key is that computer controlled vehicles could synchronize their stopping and starting. You wouldn't have to wait for the few feet moved by the car in front to bubble down the line as drivers notice the extra space. Instead, all stopped cars could coordinate to advance simultaneously.
- 11y ago
- TeMPOraL 11y agos/kill time/do something useful/, like reading books, working, having fun, sleeping. Time spent driving where a "self-driving" alternative is available is absolutely wasted.
- Asbostos 11y agoThat won't work for all the people who'll suffer car sickness when they spend time focusing on their phone while in a vehicle. Intermittent messaging is OK for most people but have you tried reading a book as a passenger? We might find that most people have to look out the windows so often that they can't get much productive work done.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoI used to have car sickness as a kid. I recall some of it being caused by vibrations made by the engine. The smell of gasoline was also vomit-inducing for me. Both of those issues are solved by electric cars.
- edejong 11y agoSome problems are less temporary. The required energy over distance goes up as well, thus limiting your action radius. Furthermore, the amount of road noise produced rises as well, which is another important limiting factor in high-density areas.
- sandworm101 11y ago"Once computers drive the cars, the speed limit can be cranked up because reaction time goes up drastically and distracted drivers are nonexistent." That doesn't mesh with areas where robots have already taken over. The robots moving freight around shipping terminals don't move any faster than humans driving trucks. The robots I see delivering drugs in hospitals don't move faster than the nurses. Speed limits aren't just about the cars. Noise and pedestrian safety are big factors. There is no technology yet that can allow a robot to see around blind corners. They may have a 1/4second faster reaction time, but that won't mean they could be trusted move much faster towards a crosswalk that might see a bike cross at any second.
- rev_bird 11y agoThe hospital robots seem like the closest analogue for now, as it's automation being held back by needing to coexist with inferior-performing humans. If it were only robots in the hallway, it'd likely go a lot faster, no? Just like if it were only computers driving the cars, following distances could be greatly reduced because they can react faster.
- sandworm101 11y agoIf it were only robots in the hallways, it wouldn't be a hospital. They did try giving the machines their own pathways. That's what pneumatic tubes were: a fast lane for robotic delivery. Frankly, for a hospital, pneumatic tubes would seem the far more elegant solution. I guess it boils down to perspective. The hospital robot is in no hurry. His life is no better or worse if he is faster or slower. But a human inside a robot-driven car does care. He doesn't see the overall traffic efficiencies, and even if he did he wouldn't take much notice. All he cares about is getting to the destination asap. So it is a different speed decision than the robot.
- Omniusaspirer 11y agoThe hospital I'm employed at utilizes both pneumatic tubes and robots. Robots roam the basement and employee only areas shuttling around food carts, linen carts, and trash. The pneumatic tube system reaches everywhere in the hospital and sends drugs, lab specimens, and basically anything else small enough to fit in the container.
- jacquesm 11y ago> Speed limits are set to try and keep people safe, by enforcing a maximum speed. That's one reason. Then there's the money printing aspect of it and the environmental aspect of it.
- angst_ridden 11y agoDon't forget the occasional "keeping cyclists and pedestrians alive" aspect.
- jacquesm 11y agoI thought that was covered by 'keep people safe'.
- melling 11y agoI doubt if the speed will increase in 25 mph residential areas.
- dclowd9901 11y agoWho cares about speeding when you have all the time in the world.
- sethherr 11y agoAgreed. Speed, particularly on sub 1 hour drives, is mostly about competitiveness. If you're no longer competing with other divers, because you have a robot that is, what will that extra 10mph do for you? Particularly when you can work in your car. Or watch a movie in your car. Or have sex.
- sandworm101 11y agoWhy assume that the robots won't compete? Cars today are marketed based on their potential for speed. With that out of the picture, why shouldn't we expect manufacturers to compete to have the "fastest" autodrive systems?
- ju-st 11y agoI want this. A rollercoaster like experience on the autobahn, nice :D
- TeMPOraL 11y ago> Driving isn't about getting from A to B, nor is safety the top priority. Yeah, this is a huge problem with drivers today. 99% of driving is absolutely about getting from A to B in as safe way as possible; anything else is reckless endangering of the lives of others. But people grow up dreaming about fast cars and freedom and adrenaline, then they get their licenses and can't confront the boring reality. That's the very reason we need self-driving cars on public roads. Driving for fun needs to be separated out and put somewhere else.
- sandworm101 11y agoSo my friends and I riding motocycles through the mountains on a sunny afternoon are reckless endangerment? How about sightseeing buses? Or bicyclists riding purely to stay in shape? Or people learning how to drive? Or cops paroling neighborhoods? Or ice cream vans? There are lots of perfectly reasonable uses of roads that have little to do with A-to-B. The elimination of "fun" in the name of safety is a very uphill battle.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoI said 99%, not 100%. Most of the driving is commuting. But fair enough, there is some wiggle room there; still: > So my friends and I riding motocycles through the mountains on a sunny afternoon are reckless endangerment? If you're breaking the law then yes, you're reckless, period. If not, then enjoy it all you want. > How about sightseeing buses? They're driving A-B-C-D in a sightseeing-optimal way within the limits of law and safety. > Or bicyclists riding purely to stay in shape? They aren't doing it next to cars, are they? There are dedicated areas for riding bikes for sports. > Or cops paroling neighborhoods? A-to-B driving, with lots of As and Bs. Also, there are two of them, one is doing the driving, the other is doing the patrolling. > Or ice cream vans? A-to-B, with lots of As and Bs. Public roads are not the place for having fun. You can enjoy driving on them however much you want as long as it doesn't affect the safety of others.
- sandworm101 11y agoBreaking the law /= recklessness. You are probably thinking of negligence per se, something less than recklessness. And I wonder why you assume that a bunch of motorcycles driving through the mountains would be breaking any laws. I know a group of lesbian harley riders who never go faster than 50 who would take issue with any assumption that riding a bike suggests illegality. For them it is about being seen and showing pride. I did a ride for burn victims a few years back. The kid riding on my bike was all smiles even though I doubt we broke 30 the entire way. He just liked the wind, a bit like my dog when she hangs her head out the window. Riding for fun does not mean riding for speed.
- puranjay 11y agoHave you ever ridden a horse? They're mad fun to ride. That's why there's a whole industry for racing and riding them. But they're inconvenient for getting from point A to point B. Which is why they've been replaced by cars. I suspect the same will happen with cars. I love my fast cars, but apart from that once a month weekend drive, I really don't get to flex its muscles. I'd much rather relax in my car on my way to work every day. Then I could buy a more powerful car which I could take out to the race track on weekends.
- 300bps 11y agoI don't think inability to speed will be as much of a problem with automation. People speed regularly today because other than getting to a destination, driving is so unproductive. If you're able to do what you want while driving (read, watch videos, communicate, etc) people won't be in as much of a hurry.