3 ms·
>That said, I'm fine if people want that info anyways, but 23&Me would need to add a disclaimer that says "Your genetic test results and the risks attributed to
by SilasX 11y ago
>That said, I'm fine if people want that info anyways, but 23&Me would need to add a disclaimer that says "Your genetic test results and the risks attributed to them may or may not be accurate."
But they FDA doesn't allow it, even under this condition.
I think it's ridiculous that the FDA considers this okay:
A) "1,2,3-methyl dethyl has been proven in clinical research to make your life suck less. (This statement not evaluated by the FDA blah blah blah)"
But not this:
B) "You have genes X, Y, and Z. The current state of published researched indicates an elevated risk for skin cancer for this genotype."
Was anyone seriously claiming that 23andme was misrepresenting the state of the research? Were they providing or enabling any treatment based on this research without further review by a doctor?
- refurb 11y agoYou are correct, the FDA doesn't allow it. "1,2,3-methyl dethyl has been proven in clinical research to make your life suck less. (This statement not evaluated by the FDA blah blah blah)" I'm assuming you saw that on a dietary supplement? That would never fly for an approved drug. Take a look at the FDA website to see what kind of promotion they crack down on. There was a ADD drug company that had an ad with a kid studying and the slogan "He can finally get his homework done". The FDA came down hard on them and said "where is the clinical trial showing that academic performance improves?". As other posters have stated, 23&Me got busted, submitted a 510(k) (approval of medical device) and then when the FDA came back with questions, they failed to reply. You can find it all in the numerous FDA warning letters.[1] [1]http://www.fda.gov/ICECI/EnforcementActions/WarningLetters/2013/ucm376296.htm http://www.fda.gov/ICECI/EnforcementActions/WarningLetters/2...