5 ms·
Basically there are three reasons to IPO, one you are "forced" into it because the number of individual investors has crossed a predefined threshold of 499, sec
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
Basically there are three reasons to IPO, one you are "forced" into it because the number of individual investors has crossed a predefined threshold of 499, second you are scaling the business and this gives you access to the public markets for capital, or third you are running low on cash on hand and nobody is willing to lead a new round with your current structure.
Given the wailing and gnashing of teeth this time last year [1] when Square raised $150M on a $6B valuation, it is entirely possible this is their last change to raise capital. If it doesn't work, and they can't cross the line into operationally cash flow positive they will become one of the larger unicorns to die this season. I really hope it isn't the case because I love their product and their service, but the S-1 doesn't paint a picture of hope. Doing some back of the envelope calculations I can't see any scale where they are profitable given their current fee structure.
[1] http://www.theverge.com/2014/10/6/6918211/square-funding-singapore-struggle-valuation http://www.theverge.com/2014/10/6/6918211/square-funding-sin...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mikeyouse 11y agoA somewhat off-topic FYI, but the JOBS Act increased the private holder cap from 500 to 2,000 shareholders as long as no more than 499 of them are accredited. https://www.cooley.com/jobs-act-what-does-it-mean https://www.cooley.com/jobs-act-what-does-it-mean
- mkehrt 11y agoThat's, uh, pretty weird actually. It means you have to know whether your RSU'd employees are accredited investors to know whether you have to go public?
- mikeyouse 11y agoNah, there's a line that takes care of that; > The new rule excludes from these calculations people who obtained equity under the company's equity compensation plans and investors who purchased securities pursuant to the crowdfunding exemption discussed in this alert.
- prostoalex 11y agoThat's the reason for the R in RSU. It's not an actual SU until liquidation event.
- yuranlu 11y agoMinor nitpick: it's actually the U that makes it not actually stock. Owning Restricted Stock counts as being a shareholder, but Restricted Stock Units aren't Restricted Stock.
- mattkopecki 11y ago> Doing some back of the envelope calculations I can't see any scale where they are profitable given their current fee structure. “We lose money on every sale, but make it up on volume”
- themartorana 11y agoThat's some funny math right there.
- DarthMader 11y agoWelcome to Silicon Valley
- robryan 11y agoSo they keep their current fee structure as long as possible to build volume then switch over to something that will make money when there is no way to further raise funds?
- abalone 11y ago> I can't see any scale where they are profitable What are your calculations? Square, Stripe et al are making massive margins on debit card transactions right now. Thanks to recent regulations (the Durbin amendment), the average debit interchange fee is 0.89% all included.[1] Square charges 2.75%. That means they're netting around 1.5-2% on debit transactions. That's huge for a payment processor. Sure, they have higher costs for credit cards, and their easier sign-up probably means more losses from seller-side fraud. But if they can control fraud then 2.75% is still a healthy gross margin even on credit transactions. And it's crazy big margin for debit. [1] http://www.federalreserve.gov/paymentsystems/regii-average-interchange-fee.htm http://www.federalreserve.gov/paymentsystems/regii-average-i...
- untog 11y agoWhat percentage of their transactions are debit transactions, though?
- exw 11y ago> Doing some back of the envelope calculations I can't see any scale where they are profitable given their current fee structure. Here is a more optimistic analysis from Re/Code: http://recode.net/2015/10/14/squares-ipo-filing-its-complicated/ http://recode.net/2015/10/14/squares-ipo-filing-its-complica... that looks at the numbers minus the Starbucks deal and concludes that their core business is healthy and has a path to profitability.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoThanks for that, this comment is worrisome from the article "While Square will be a much smaller business from a revenue standpoint after the Starbucks deal lapses, it will be a faster-growing one with a much better shot at profitability." So what is their target valuation when they go public? If they were going for $1 - $2B valuation? I think the world might buy that, but since their last round was at $6B, their investors would probably be pushing for $10B (because if you recall the Box IPO you remember that none of the late stage investors want to take a down round into the public markets) and that is like "Square 10 years from now" valuations. So lets watch this one closely and see if they can get commitments for all their shares on the road show. And if not, we'll probably see a giant recapitalization or maybe a firesale to PayPal or something.
- exw 11y agoAgreed, that is the biggest challenge for them, and the First Data IPO (which is probably the best comp for them) has been challenging. OTOH Square is on pace to hit $1B revenue / year and growing quickly vs. anybody else in the processing space, but it will all come down to how the market thinks about their business and their ability to cross the chasm from very small merchants (which makes up the majority of their business and they have locked up because other processors / ISOs cannot compete with their customer acquisition costs) into the next tier of small businesses... Along those lines, great article from Bill Gurley about revenue multiples: http://abovethecrowd.com/2011/05/24/all-revenue-is-not-created-equal-the-keys-to-the-10x-revenue-club/ http://abovethecrowd.com/2011/05/24/all-revenue-is-not-creat...
- nkurz 11y agoDoing some back of the envelope calculations I can't see any scale where they are profitable given their current fee structure. Could you explain? I'm sure you have much more experience reading such numbers[1] than I do, but at a glance they look viable if they can grow to something around double their size. Ignoring Starbucks and doubling the amounts for 1H 2015 to make it annual, they'll have about $1000M of revenue from transactions, and will pay about $600M of transaction costs. They'll have about $500M of operating costs for 2015 and $100M of various other costs. If in 201X they were to be double this size, they'd have $2000M of revenue, and $1200M of transaction costs. If they can keep their operating and other costs below $800M, they'll be profitable. Of their expenses, "Transaction and advance losses" will probably scale linearly, but all the rest plausible to be significantly sublinear. Is this simplistic scenario clearly impossible for some reason? [1] https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1512673/000119312515343733/d937622ds1.htm https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1512673/000119312515...