3 ms·
I am a former homemaker, military wife and homeschooling mom who just didn't want to die a slow torturous death. While I do have about six years of college, som
by Mz 11y ago
I am a former homemaker, military wife and homeschooling mom who just didn't want to die a slow torturous death. While I do have about six years of college, some of it the equivalent of graduate work, I have limited formal study in biology. So I likely brought mental models from other realms where I have training. I do have a technical certificate that makes me a "Certified Life and Health Insurance Specialist" (or did at one time) and my former employer paid for that. It was part of training for my job where I reviewed accident claims. So I read medical records as part of my job for over five years. Although I was an accident specialist, I sometimes read records on patients with diabetes because of the tendency for people with diabetes to wind up needing a foot amputation. It was not uncommon for them to try to get that paid as an accident claim based on having hit the foot in question against something prior to the amputation. This sometimes had to be reviewed by a former surgeon to make the final decision as to whether we would pay the claim -- whether the amputation was necessitated by trauma or due to advanced deterioration from diabetes.
Still, I am at a serious disadvantage in trying to talk about ion channels and what not in terms that a biologist would typically use.
I did not know this:
Essentially, CFTR is an ion channel that evolved as a 'broken' ABC transporter that leaks when in open conformation.
That is interesting to me. CF is basically a salt-wasting condition. There are various forms of defect in the CFTR, but knowing that it basically leaks may explain why it is basically a salt wasting condition.
(e.g. one class is thought to result in the CFTR degrading quickly, don't know if it functions normally while in place).
If you are interested, I can share my research notes where I spent some time digging up information. I was taking a particular supplement at the time and if I missed a single dose, I drastically and promptly deteriorated. So I was looking to understand why that might be. In the process of digging around, I found that most genetic disorders boil down to being a defect in a particular protein. The CFTR channel is a protein that gets folded a particular way and inserted into the cell membrane in order to handle trafficking into and out of the cell of specific ions.
So one of the things I found was that there are two conditions that cause higher misfolds of proteins within the cell: Derangement of PH level and derangement of salt level. You see both of these things happening with CF.
It is well established that people with CF gradually become increasingly too acid. This is almost never treated. It is not treated as medically significant, even though if you have diabetes and get sudden onset acidosis, they hospitalize you promptly because you can be dead within 72 hours if they can't reverse it. So they know acidosis is deadly. They know CF is deadly. They know CF promotes gradual onset acidosis. No one sees this as related. I decided it must be related and reversing the acidity of my tissues was a cornerstone of my approach.
Initially, I took about $300/month worth of supplements. I thought I would always need to do that. It was a daily battle to try to keep symptoms under control. I gradually became less symptomatic. I stabilized.
So I have concluded that there is a vicious positive feedback loop where the more acid you get, the more you see protein misfolds and the more you see protein misfolds, the more acid you get. I believe this is why it is a degenerative, progressive condition. And if you can accommodate the defect in the cell membrane, which is both a bottleneck on some things and an open flood gate on others at the same time, if you can find a way around that, you can stop and reverse the process.
Presumably this will work differently depending on the specific defect in the CFTR. There are variations of CF that are the equivalent of albinism in terms of simply not producing a CFTR channel to begin with. I imagine that will be much more resistant to management via the process I use.
There are a lot of other things in the back of my mind that are relevant to this discussion, but I am somewhat pressed for time and I am not sure I could make clear what the relevance is.
I do not "eat plenty of fat without apparent harm." I got very picky about WHAT I eat and I believe the high levels of specific things that I ate for a time amounts to redressing a serious and lifelong deficit. I do not count calories or anything like that. I pay close attention to chemical makeup of foods and how that interacts with my condition.
But most people with CF are prescribed a high salt, high fat, high calorie diet. In practice, this means they are actively encouraged by medical professionals to eat a junk food diet. I went the other way. I pay very close attention to the quality of my food, not the quantity. I went looking for good quality fats and salts and other foods. I think the current practice of prescribing a junk food diet because it is high in fat and salt without caring that it is low in quality is part of what is killing people with CF.
I don't know if that does anything to cast light on the question of fats and diabetes per se. I don't think fats per se are terribly important to the process behind diabetes. I think acidosis and infection are likely more related and you see both of those at high rates in people with CF. There are also studies that clearly link inflammation and diabetes. As I said in the comment that started this subthread, I believe that likely points to infection as an underlying cause of diabetes.
Addendum: I should add that as I have gotten healthier, my appetite has shrunk. I eat a great deal less than I used to eat. Redressing the lifelong deficits dramatically reduced my need for a very high calorie diet. I probably still eat a bit more than average, but I eat a lot less than I used to.
- Mz 11y ago2nd addendum: I will add that I carefully avoid peanut oil, having found it to be extremely inflammatory. Anytime I have it, there is just hell to pay. So I will say that if people are consuming fats that promote inflammation, that would be relevant -- but not because they are fats per se, but because they have a chemical makeup that promotes the inflammation that promotes chemical derangement and infection.
- hga 11y agoWikipedia: "Essentially, CFTR is an ion channel that evolved as a 'broken' ABC transporter that leaks when in open conformation." You: "That is interesting to me. CF is basically a salt-wasting condition. There are various forms of defect in the CFTR, but knowing that it basically leaks may explain why it is basically a salt wasting condition." Errr, that was referring to normal CFTR. The class of proteins it belongs to normally require ATP, the ready energy source in cells, to actively transport stuff, e.g. use up one molecule of ATP to transport one molecule of whatever. CFTR is 'broken' in that it looks a whole lot like one of these proteins, but instead of ATP being used to transport a molecule, i.e. against an osmotic gradient, the ATP just "opens its door" (or the reverse, I didn't check), and then ions and water go whichever way the gradient favors. I.e. if there's lots more water in the cell than outside the cell, it goes out. So one of the things I found was that there are two conditions that cause higher misfolds of proteins within the cell: Derangement of PH level and derangement of salt level. You see both of these things happening with CF. Ah, I see where there's usefulness here, given the variety of CFTR mutations (and note that one person might have two different mutations, one contributed from each parent, or arising from very early stage embryo mutations). There will be mutations that as you describe, where if you can adjust the conditions under which the protein is created and initially folds, and or preforms afterwards, you get a more favorable outcome. As for acid, well, it depends on where the acid is. Acidosis is a condition outside the cell, per the Merck Manual "Acidosis is excessive blood acidity caused by an overabundance of acid in the blood or a loss of bicarbonate from the blood (metabolic acidosis), or by a buildup of carbon dioxide in the blood that results from poor lung function or slow breathing (respiratory acidosis)." So to refine your hypothesis, once the protein is in the cell membrane, a greater concentration of hydronium ions (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydronium https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydronium) outside will damage it. And if the outside is more acid than the cell, they'll flow in through the channel, where they can donate a proton (bare hydrogen atom), doing mischief to CFTR or even the cell. So I have concluded that there is a vicious positive feedback loop where the more acid you get, the more you see protein misfolds and the more you see protein misfolds, the more acid you get. I believe this is why it is a degenerative, progressive condition. That would only happen if your as blood gets more acid, it stays more acid, but short of requiring intervention. Note also that proteins tend to? often? have have a life cycle, they get produced, work for a while, often get zapped one way or another, and then get recycled. That mutation class I mentioned of premature degradation implies this is true for CTFR; the cell would fail to keep up production sufficient to counter that. Note also there should be a signaling mechanism that tells the cell to produce more or less of CTFR, I'm assuming that even if the signal is "I really need more!", the cell has a limit to how much it can produce, and still survive, it can't under-produce other vital stuff too much ... and that also might have an effect. Sounds like there's cumulative damage elsewhere that can't be reversed in this way, e.g. the stated pancreas scarring that causes Type 1 diabetes, or the classic clubbed fingers per the Wikipedia picture. But most people with CF are prescribed a high salt, high fat, high calorie diet. This means they are actively encouraged by medical professionals to eat a junk food diet. I went the other way. I pay very close attention to the quality of my food, not the quantity. I went looking for good quality fats and salts and other foods. I think the current practice of prescribing a junk food diet because it is high in fat and salt without caring that it is low in quality is part of what is killing people with CF. Well, salt is salt, and it might help to increase the saltiness of your blood (not sure how much that's possible or practical), you'll end up with more salt inside the cells (or that sounds likely, but there are surely other proteins that also can transport salt in and out), and outside the cell, the former probably not so good, the latter perhaps in balance for the best for many people. More later if you wish when you have time, on this HN topic, or you're welcome to email me (see the address in my account info).