3 ms·
Prohibition: A Cautionary Tale
- moron4hire 17y agoHe's not really saying anything new here. We get a too-long overview of the history of the Volstead Act, and then one paragraph cautioning Congress to remember the lessons of Prohibition. There isn't even a hint as to what issue he is referring to. Is it health care, finance, marijuana, carbon dioxide? If he meant all of them, he should have said all of them.
- njl 17y agoHealth care. He points out that prohibition destroyed the seventh largest industry in the country at the time it was passed, and did nothing but breed criminality and disrespect for law. He then implies that the coming massive government intervention in health care will wreak cataclysmic and unexpected levels of havoc with the 15% of our economy that the health care industry represents. His argument is best when cast as a pointed reminder that the government is made of fallible human beings who can't be trusted to understand all the implications of the incredibly complicated system they are attempting to administer, and less when cast as some sort of direct analogy.
- endlessvoid94 17y agoTotally thought this was about MJ. You are, of course, absolutely correct. I fear most of the population will not get it. Or maybe I'm stupid...
- spamizbad 17y agoI wasn't aware the government was going to ban healthcare, forcing us to see a mob doctor. I know politics isn't OT on HN but sure we can have a discussion that doesn't involve hyperbole. edit: Also, was his reference to eugenicists some sort of passive-aggressive dig against people who are pro-choice and want abortions covered in the health bill? If so, all the more reason this is an awful article.
- madair 17y agoYeah, it does seem like he's got an axe to grind, but he never lets on what it is. I think it's too optimistic to think he's alluding to marijuana laws, he seemed more forward thinking than that. Banking industry reforms?
- stuaxo 17y agoI'm sorry, but this is still going on in 2010 right now and to have no mention of it is completely ridiculous - 'Taking a drink became a sign of defiance against the arrogant minority who had deprived people of their "right" to enjoy themselves.' Substitute E, K, Coke, Weed, LSD, 2CB or whatever and were bang up to date.
- dtf 17y agoI got the feeling that was the subtext. But maybe I'm reading subtleties which aren't there. It's all a bit ambiguous - the last paragraph, the conclusion, doesn't really tie in.