8 ms·
After 8 years and $128M raised, the clock is ticking for men's retailer Bonobos
- ucaetano 11y ago“Call me crazy, but I’m hoping we can build something standalone,” “The e-commerce business is really challenging, and we feel like with this online-offline equation we’ve really unlocked something that can scale,” “I have a long vision for the company, one that could take decades to unfold, and I didn’t think that my running the company day-to-day was necessarily optimal to getting there.” So after 8 years unable to scale, they now want to scale by building brick-and-mortar stores where you can try a product that you can only buy online? Am I missing something here?
- bonesinger 11y agoI agree, I think its weird. I went into one of their stores and the employee was working with someone else. Since I can't buy anything, I just walked out. I did end up buying their clothes on their website and the cost was pretty good after coupons. The clothes themselves are awesome and fit me perfectly. I also like their website, especially the filter they have, it's very responsive.
- jraines 11y agoI walked into their store in Manhattan (unaware it was this model) because I'd heard of them, and knew from their ads that their pitch is about how great the fit is. The salesperson was busy with a customer who was confused (and a bit rudely angry) that he couldn't just buy something now. He walked out, and so did I. To continue this sample of one anecdata: my shopping usually goes: "hey, there's a store that sells pants -> I could use some pants -> let's get this over with"
- DanBC 11y agoAnd also: -> I better buy two or three pairs if I like them, because in 4 months they're going to stop selling these and they are a comfy fit.
- AndrewKemendo 11y ago"hey, there's a store that sells pants -> I could use some pants -> let's get this over with" Interesting because mine is "I could use some pants -> where is a store that sells pants? -> let's get this over with" I wonder how different your or my experiences are compared to the population.
- jraines 11y agoMine would be the same as yours except that I live in Manhattan and often walk around Midtown / Union Square where there are tons of clothing retailers.
- saosebastiao 11y agoIt is a genius move. Their real estate leases and operations are surprisingly cheap when it comes to brick and mortar because the footprint is so small. And they have completely eliminated the most dangerous and costly aspect of B&M: inventory management. The more stores you have, the more fractured your inventory is. Every location adds incremental safety stock. Safety stock in fashion, where each color/size combo is a unique sku, tends to be at least an order of magnitude greater than the mean forecasted sales...much higher for the high end stores where an out of stock situation is a major hit to your brand image. Pure e-commerce fashion companies have a huge advantage in inventory management because they aggregate their inventory in a single warehouse instead of spreading it out amongst hundreds of retail stores. But they have struggled because of concerns about fit. People tend to fall into two categories when it comes to buying clothes online: 1) Buy it anyway, try it on, and return everything that doesn't fit, and 2) Don't buy at all. #1 is extremely costly because reverse logistics is extremely costly (personal experience is 3-10x more expensive than equivalent forward logistics). #2 is a no-revenue situation. Bonobos is doing something risky, sure...but it is novel and, in my opinion, has a lot of merit. They let people find what fits, and then they can buy as little or as much as they want, in any color, fabric, or print combination that they want online...and they have eliminated the reverse logistics and reduced inventory working capital by several orders of magnitude. And sure, they can't be everyone's target market. Nobody has ever succeeded at that in fashion. But what they do have for a target market is extremely powerful: Professional men. And they happen to go back for more every time because they love the product.
- ucaetano 11y ago"But what they do have for a target market is extremely powerful: Fiercely loyal professional men who go back for more every time because they love the product." Wow, so it's even worse than I thought: not even their target market scales!
- saosebastiao 11y agoI flash edited to clarify...but you are wrong about it not scaling. Gucci, a brand out of range for 99.99% of the world population, has a brand value estimated at $12B. Their total market value is well beyond that. Professional men, by contrast, are an incredibly large market segment, and with margins that aren't much different from the high overhead high end retailers.
- antr 11y agoBonobos really struggled to raise their D round... and I really mean struggle. They managed to find "dumb" money from a Mexican fund, as all well known funds had passed on the investment. I'm not saying Bonobos is a bad company, but when you run out of growth, and are desperate for cash, accessing capital is really hard... Having raised $128m, and finding yourself in an extremely competitive sector with players with superb operations (Inditex, H&M), and well known players gone bust (American Apparel), I believe Bonobos is having real trouble in justifying a startup/tech-like valuation. If they IPO, or anyone buys them, Bonobos’ investors should expected a genuine market valuation based on fundamentals.
- meatysnapper 11y agoWait till Massimo Dutti expands into the US. Everybody who is one price level above Zara will be destroyed.
- goodJobWalrus 11y agoWhy? Massimo Dutti is in Canada, but it doesn't look like anyone of American brands in that space was "destroyed".
- Thimothy 11y agoFor the amusement value, Massimo Dutti is owned by Inditex, parent company of Zara.
- subpixel 11y agoI remember when they launched, their 'special sauce' was supposed to be how they made pants fit men correctly, but the photos made their pants look awkward and ill-fitting. To wit: http://articles.chicagotribune.com/2008-06-01/features/0805290003_1_pants-bonobos-fit http://articles.chicagotribune.com/2008-06-01/features/08052... Odd how that first impression has stuck with me and prevented me from paying any further attention to the brand.
- andzt 11y agoTBH, I still haven't had great luck with their pants. They just don't fit well, even trying several different configuration options. On the other hand, their dress shirts are very high quality and fit (me) extremely well. They get me every time there is a sale on their dress shirts (like today). I think the real difficulty with these business models is that the sizing numbers vary WILDLY across retailers, so there's a lack of consumer confidence when shopping - even with free shipping and returns. A 34x34 pant is not the same at J Crew, Banana or Bonobos. There are several other measures that impact the fit dramatically, of which the average consumer is not aware.
- craigching 11y ago> their dress shirts are very high quality and fit (me) extremely well Yep, I'll back that up. I haven't tried any pants, but all the shirts I've bought from Bonobos fit me really well. I'm not a "slim fit" guy, so I really appreciate their shirts.
- zeveb 11y ago> I think the real difficulty with these business models is that the sizing numbers vary WILDLY across retailers You're right, and the crazy thing is that men's[1] sizes should be completely bog-standard: they're supposed to be lengths in inches. There's no reason why I wear anything from a 29" to a 32" long pair of trousers, depending on the manufacturer. I'm well aware that ready-to-wear will never fit as well as tailored; that's fine. But there's no good reason for lengths to vary so wildly. [1] Women's clothing is different, because women's proportions have a much higher variance than men's.
- sageabilly 11y agoTheir menswear collection looks to be trying to compete with Banana Republic and JCrew, at least price wise. I took a look at their "experimental" women's line, AYR, and it's just... I mean maybe I'm not their target demographic but for $125 I can purchase some incredible pants at Nordstrom and actually try them on in the store, not to mention have a great customer service experience and get them tailored in-house. Their women's line suffers from overly high prices for what the pieces are (simple stuff that I can buy at Ann Taylor or Loft or Nordstrom or JCrew or Banana Republic depending on my mood and what color I want it in), and the extremely narrow offering of sizes is straight up ridiculous at this point. I'm not going to drop $150 on any clothing I buy online sight-unseen unless it's a brand I already know and trust. And yes, I can return it if I don't like it or if it doesn't fit but if I'm spending $500-1000 on clothes at a time (and at Bonobos that's two pants and two shirts plus a blazer) I don't want to go through that hassle, I want everything to be perfect the first time. I imagine that for most men their desired shopping experience is even more geared towards "I want to purchase the most adequate pair of pants the very first time and minimize the time I need to spend shopping." I do have a few friends who live to shop but the vast majority of my friends, male and female alike, just want to buy things they like and have them work the first time around with a minimum of fuss. Plus, if I'm going to spend that much money on clothes that I have never purchased before (and I consider $200-400 per outfit to be a significant outlay of money for clothes, which perhaps makes me an outlier) I want an experience to go with it. I want to see what I'm getting before I pay for it, and I would like the option to consult with a salesperson about the clothing. Their men's Americano and French Cuff dress shirts are in the same price range as the least expensive shirts from an awesome independent men's store close to my house (in the DC suburbs) and every time I've been in there to shop with my husband he's treated like a king by the staff, as is every other customer that comes through there regardless of how much they spend. Again, when I shop there I know damn well that whatever I buy is going to be the absolute top quality that it can be because the owner cares about his customers and doesn't sell anything he wouldn't buy or wear himself.
- andzt 11y agoBonobos is carried in some Nordstrom stores, not sure about AYR. I'm actually thinking of giving their pants a second shot once the Nordstrom by me re-opens and I can try enough pairs on to find ones that fit well - if the store carries them. Link: http://shop.nordstrom.com/c/bonobos-clothing http://shop.nordstrom.com/c/bonobos-clothing
- grandalf 11y agoThe biggest problem with buying clothes, in my opinion, is that most are low quality. Pants and shirts should be guaranteed to withstand hundreds of machine washes without shrinking or falling apart. Textiles are very very cheap. Men's pants styles have changed very little in 100 years. It's unconscionable that they should cost more than $25-$30 a pair. When you walk into a Bonobos brick and mortar location, there are lots of accessories (ties, belts, etc.) which are higher margin items that are more trend-driven, which is good for the business's bottom line, but I don't know any guys who really want to go "all in" and look like a Bonobos spokesperson. A man needs well-made, well-fitting staple garments that he can reliably reorder when he needs more (which should be rarely). The fashion and flourishes are fun, as are luxury materials like cashmere and silk, but they are not the core of a man's wardrobe. Not everyone aspires to have a super expensive watch and fancy tie. Most of us just want well-made pants that won't be ready for donation to the goodwill the following year. I thought this was what Bonobos was building, but it seems to have branched out into what feels like a copy of Ralph Lauren, with the same kind of aspirational "gentleman" aesthetic.
- meatysnapper 11y ago"It's unconscionable that they should cost more than $25-$30 a pair." Exactly. I want all my clothes to be made by small children in sweatshops. I don't want my money to go to businesses that rely on paying normal wages.
- steckerbrett 11y agoI doubt any of the higher price of clothes goes towards them not being made in sweatshops.
- draw_down 11y agoYes, "unconscionable" was quite the interesting word choice there.
- tdees40 11y agoThis was said a little obnoxiously, but he has a point. Making pants in China takes about three labor hours[1]. Given that about 50% of the cost of pants is the retail/wholesale markup, that leaves $15 to pay for materials, shipping, and labor. It's hard to squeeze a living wage out of that. [1] https://books.google.com/books?id=unXGqA4st54C&pg=RA2-PT56&lpg=RA2-PT56&dq=pants+labor+textile&source=bl&ots=ajCD9oHDhp&sig=e8VARoY8dfQ2dfxx3XMNASn1x7M&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0CB0Q6AEwAGoVChMI_67Q0bfCyAIVgls-Ch0mAg3o#v=onepage&q=pants%20labor%20textile&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=unXGqA4st54C&pg=RA2-PT56&l...
- ruddct 11y agoIt's a brand I've never understood at a valuation that seems completely insane. Generic designs that are more expensive (relative to the fast fashion bunch) and more difficult to buy (relative to comparable B&M chains). Serious question: Does anyone know/is anyone a Bonobos enthusiast? I'm legitimately curious about their demographic, and what appeals to them about Bonobos that doesn't about JCrew/Club Monaco/Zara/Uniqlo/etc.
- avn2109 11y agoI only wear Bonobos pants. If you have a tall athletic build and do a lot of heavy squats and therefore have a gigantic butt/thighs, they make the one model of pants on earth that fits you off the rack. Pants from Jcrew/Zara/H&M are definitely more fashionable but they don't come in my length, and if they fit my quads then they billow around my ankles. Confusingly, Bonobos shirts/sports coats are cut for guys with very slender upper bodies, non-broad shoulders, and do not come in adequately tall sizes, and Jcrew's tall line of shirts fits an athletic build much better.
- rory 11y agoMost of my pants are from Bonobos because they have easy-to-find 35 36 slim-fits which can be hard to find. Their denim is of decent quality, and they used to have a ton of big sales. I wouldn't go as far as to call myself an 'enthusiast' though.
- pumblechook 11y agoWhen Bonobos first came on the scene, it was difficult to find a pair of men's pants with a decent fit at a decent price. I don't consider myself a Bonobos enthusiast, but I can say that putting on a pair of Bonobos pants after years of billowing tent pants was revelatory insofar as a pair of men's pants can be. It is worth noting that I bought these at a heavy clearance discount ($20 to the normal ~$90). But now, it isn't difficult to find well fitting men's clothes. Since buying that first pair of Bonobos, I've found clothes that fit just as well, for similar quality and much lower prices.
- wil421 11y agoH&M/Zara have horrible quality compared to Bonobos/Banana Republic. I've bought clothes that barely lasted after one wash similar to the woman's clothes from Forever 21. Bonobos has better quality, slightly slimmer and more modern fit than Banana Republic. The quality has also been better as far as chinos goes. Also I like Bonobos' attention to detail, the pockets have nice patterns and better buttons. They also fit better in the right places and seem more movable. As far as their shirts are concerned I can find more flashy or newer type designs/patterns that are still office friendly. Plus most of the button down shirts dont have that huge blousey look at the bottom when I tuck them in. For my body its hard to find shirts with broad shoulders but a small waist.
- Liuser 11y agoWanted to be the “Zappos of pants”. I’m a frequent shopper of Bonobos and Zappos. One glaring flaw is their shipping speeds. I felt in its earlier days, Zappos really paved the way for fast and convenient shipping. Order a pair of shoes, and you get it on your front porch in 1-2 days. I rarely shop at clothing stores now. I like to have clothes and shoes delivered so that I may try them at my leisure in the comfort of my own home and debate whether to keep the purchase for a couple of days. Bonobos shipment takes approximately 5 business days if you live in Northern CA (which is where I am at.) Returns also take awhile. Approximately 2 weeks from when I initially ship the item, to when I receive the return on my CC. You can’t be the “Zappos of pants”, if your shipping speeds take 5 business days. Their customer experience is one of the best I’ve ever experienced. They are really polite and really responsive. Additionally, if you visit one of their brick and mortar shops, and you order through their reps at the store, you will get a sizable discount. Grab that person’s card, and try to make future orders through that person for discounts in the future.
- sotojuan 11y agoBetween Uniqlo, J. Crew (which has sales all the time), H&M, and other cheaper-but-pretty-much-the-same stores, I don't know what Bonobos offers. The regular person will buy from the stores above. The person that spends a ton of money on clothes will buy actual designer clothes made.
- avn2109 11y agoIt's the fit. If you have an athletic build they are a godsend.
- mrfogg 11y agoI like their shirts a lot (much better fit than J-Crew and Banana, much higher quality than H&M), but it's still difficult to justify a $100 shirt from Bonobos when I can get a very similar shirt from Uniqlo for $30. The pants I can understand, though as someone who primarily wears slim/skinny jeans, I'm not their pants demographic. I'd imagine that there is a large market for properly-fitted pants though, as most stuff from Banana Republic and Jcrew are billowing and terrible. But overall, I find it hard for frequently-worn shirts and pants to last more than a couple years anyway, between wear+tear and style changes. Paying 200% more for a product that is only slightly nicer (but not 'you will own this for years to come' quality, such as a nice boot) and difficult to buy/return is a hard sell. If someone truly has the money to blow, it's better off going to smaller designer ultra-high-quality (or fashionable) brands.
- tsunamifury 11y agoMeanwhile the ultra-highend designer, Brunello Cuccinelli, achieved a very successful multi-billion IPO valuation by focusing on hand made clothing, ethical sourcing, hands on sales, and superior quality. Sometimes markets aren't just about driving down price and cheap supply chains. Providing a product an order of magnitude better than currently provided by competition, and charging a lot for it, can also lead to success. I also sense that a great deal of profit will come from matching consumers values of quality and ethics over price for the coming generation of consumers.
- iamleppert 11y ago128M for the same service my local tailor provides me. I'd give money to my local tailor in a heartbeat before this company.
- encoderer 11y agoI'm a tall guy with an athletic build. The bonobos "tailored slim" cut shirts are the best off-the-rack fit I've found. I recently tried Trumaker for made-to-measure shirts and was totally underwhelmed. The tailored slim shirts from bonobos were a much slimmer cut than what I got from Trumaker. I don't love their chinos but I think I just dislike chinos. They are boxy.
- shturturp 11y agoAh, I've had good luck with Trumaker actually. First shirt wasn't slim enough but was able to get it adjusted, and shirts since have been great. Did take some time to get it right though.
- encoderer 11y agoMy adjustment came back still too baggy. I was pretty disappointed. Really wanted it to be awesome.
- rtgr 11y agoThey're struggling because they typically hire young, professionally immature employees that treat any new process as an encroachment on their fiefdom. When I worked there getting anything done across departments required buy in from the executive team that had to force people to do their jobs. The zappos comparison doesn't really work anymore. They dropped free 2-3 day shipping because they were losing so much money and phone support has gone downhill.
- shturturp 11y agoHa! So many haters and misconceptions, and general cynicism. Something about menswear makes guys go a little nuts these days. And the general assumption that every factory in Asia is a sweatshop is frankly racist / xenophobic. What I love about Bonobos is that as a startup fan and participant, they've been way more candid on most things around their business than they needed to be. Andy's articles on Medium have been fascinating. But, as usual today, most people make snap judgments about one particular thing based on their singular experience without thinking about the broader implications and opportunities. I'd guess those commenters aren't very good at VC investing?