3 ms·
> The main outcome will be that more engineers will be needed to do more work https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window https://en.wikipedia.o
by JoshTriplett 11y ago
> The main outcome will be that more engineers will be needed to do more work
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window
Artificially creating additional work by imposing additional requirements does not necessarily improve the situation just because it employs people to do that work, whether you personally like those requirements or not.
- jamesblonde 11y agoThis is a good thing, IMO. It's like having a shoddy builder who builds a poorly insulated house and then screams - hey, your house will be more expensive if I build it properly. But the builder has plenty of profits with which to take the hit. Consumers are already trading off their data for services (like Facebook). If the costs were so high that Facebook or Google needed to pass on real costs to consumers, there might be an issue. But the costs won't be that high. It's just a bit more work to build it right.
- madez 11y agoIn contrast to the parable you are citing, the only thing broken in this case is the privacy of european citizens. The ruling to declare "Safe" Harbor invalid is not breaking anything but a step to fix a system that is systematically violating constitutional rights. In the light of US companies not effectively safeguarding european data against access by US authorities, judgements are needed to rectify the situation.
- jeremysmyth 11y agoThe parable of the broken window weighs what is seen (the payment to the glazier) with what is not seen (the missed payments to other things that could've been purchased had the window not been broken). In the case of safe harbour, the window was already broken. Data being passed from Europe to the US was not being handled correctly, despite the promises inherent in Safe Harbor. If protections had already been in place (i.e. if data service providers were actually adhering to the promises of safe harbour) then service providers have already fixed the window. Those that were safeguarding data correctly have no further engineering work to do (although there might be further regulatory/compliance effort to prove it depending on how individual nations implement the stopgap safeguard laws to replace Safe Harbor). The only engineering work required to "fix the window" is work that should already have been done according to the safe harbour agreements, and threads like this prove how broken Safe Harbor was to begin with.