4 ms·
A scientist's first instinct is "get more funding". This cannot help but bias their conclusions.
by gaius 11y ago
A scientist's first instinct is "get more funding". This cannot help but bias their conclusions.
- andyjohnson0 11y agoUnnecessarily cynical. Its a problem that science funding makes scientist's careers so precarious, but nobody goes into science for the money.
- cageface 11y agoMaybe nobody goes into science for the money, but if you don't focus on the money you won't stay in science very long.
- dagw 11y ago"Get more funding" isn't the difference between making a little money vs. making a lot of money. It's the difference between making a little money and not having a job.
- coherentpony 11y agoDepends on the scientist's position. Tenure-track and tenured faculty in the US typically have 9 months of their salary covered by the institution employing them. Only the remaining three months need be covered by grants (or teaching).
- scott_s 11y agoBut going from tenure track to tenure in most research universities does require getting grants.
- dalke 11y agoDo you expect to see any differences in the quality of science of those few scientist who are self-funded? (I heard a lecture once from a researcher who was on Wall Street, made millions, then switched to femtosecond lasers. He worked out of a university, and funded his own lab. So such people do exist.) If there are differences, are they measurable?
- dagw 11y agoThe problem is that there is massive selection bias. If you're one of the very top researchers in your field you are much more likely to A) produce world class research and B) never have much problems with funding. Conversely many of those funding their own research are doing so because they cannot get any other funding, which may be an indicator that they aren't very good.
- bildung 11y ago> Conversely many of those funding their own research are doing so because they cannot get any other funding, which may be an indicator that they aren't very good. ... at selling. In my experience the skill sets needed for aquiring funds and those for doing research don't have much in common.
- nmrm2 11y ago> because they cannot get any other funding Really? I seriously question that "because". If I had FU money I would definitely start my own lab and pay for research out of pocket. Science is fantastically fun if you don't have to care about funding (and by extension tenure) and only publish because it's nice to get feedback from your peers (rather than because you need X papers to get your next grant and keep your job). Conversely, writing grants is a total bore. A "because" I would be more willing to buy: if you made that kind of money for yourself, odds are you spent your prime years achieving that and therefore haven't dedicated the time to science that's necessary to be at the top of your field.
- yiyus 11y agoThat's not true. Funding is important, but once you have it you stop looking for more. I've been working in research for years, both in companies and universities, and I have always been involved in long-term projects, so I have never had to worry about funding. Of course, other colleagues are not so lucky, and getting funding is an important part of their day-to-day jobs, specially once you reach higher positions. But it is a necessity, not an instinct.
- wsxcde 11y agoThat's an oversimplification at best. Right now, NSF grant funding rates are so low that scientists feel they need to submit 6 good grants to get one funded, so they are forced to spend most of their time allocated to research writing grants. But if this environment went away, most of these people would love nothing more than to do the actual science. I think a couple of bigger issues are (i) we reward the first person/group to reach a conclusion, so there's incentive to be sloppy and get your name on the research first and sort out the (hopefully minor) problems later and (ii) there's an expectation from the general public that scientists have to be "productive" all the time. Productive is of course defined as producing new and exciting results, rather than carefully verifying old results, or trying to fill the gaps in previous work. See how much pressure there is on scientists to do "transformative" rather than "incremental" research. I don't think we as a society have a solution to these problems even outside of science. To pick a familiar example for HN, programmers who write overly-complicated messy code are often rewarded over those who write simpler, cleaner and well-architected code because the former looks like more work. Similarly, there's little interest in writing test benches or documentation in open source projects, because there's little reward or incentive for these things. OpenSSL pre-heartbleed era is a perfect example of all the wrong incentive systems working together to produce a steaming pile of bullshit that everyone involved in the field kept claiming as being the most secure solution out there.