3 ms·
The word "privacy" doesn't have to occur in the fourth amendment for its meaning to be clear about protecting privacy.
by nitrogen 11y ago
The word "privacy" doesn't have to occur in the fourth amendment for its meaning to be clear about protecting privacy.
- themartorana 11y agoI imagine if it did, we'd still be having a similar discussion. Without certain events by the court that reset or reaffirm interpretations, Constitutional "wandering" can run amok (see Interstate Commerce Clause and the War on Drugs). District of Columbia v. Heller comes to mind, where the court confirmed a particular reading of the Second Amendment. In 50 years they'll probably have to reaffirm it again. Or they could go a different way... I can easily imagine a bizzaro world where the Fourth Amendment does contain the word privacy, and the court has had to reaffirm or reinterpret what "privacy" means in context over and over. PS - best comment of the night, nitrogen.
- rayiner 11y agoThe comment I was responding to implied the Supreme Court "interpreted" the Constitution to undermine privacy rights. But in fact the opposite has happened: it has inserted privacy rights into the document far beyond what is in the text. As to your point: the 4th amendment clearly does protect a narrow form of privacy: freedom from government trespass to property. But look at the text: it's clearly a targeted, specific, protection. In contrast, look at the broad language of the first amendment: freedom of the press, freedom of assembly, freedom of speech. The framers used broad language when that's what they meant. And it's not like private communication is such a novel concept they had no reason to even contemplate it. People tend to think of the cloud and encryption as sui generis but the underlying concepts are not. People in 1776 communicated extensively about sensitive matters by letter and in person. Heck, sometimes they even wrote coded messages! They trusted sensitive business and financial information to accountants, lawyers, merchants, bankers, etc. And if you think about it, if there was some sphere of private communication that the framers intended to protect even from the reach of a warrant, they could have done so even without the existence of encryption! Instead of saying that the government can search your "papers" with a warrant, the 4th amendment could say that the government can never search your papers. Again, it's not like the idea of private communication was novel to them.
- curryst 11y agoThis is really a blend of the fourth and fifth amendments. The fourth amendment protects you from the government randomly seizing your phone, but the right to not incriminate yourself under the fifth amendment is what is used to justify not being able to compel someone to unlock/decrypt their device.
- tptacek 11y ago4A can't be at play here, because we're talking about searches accompanied by warrants. That leaves 5A. But 5A isn't absolute either. You can be compelled to produce all sorts of evidence against yourself. And even the basic privilege of not incriminating yourself has a public safety exception.