40 ms·
"As the Ninth Circuit put it in a case interpreting technical assistance in a different context, private companies' obligations to assist the government have “n
by zaroth 11y ago
"As the Ninth Circuit put it in a case interpreting technical assistance in a different context, private companies' obligations to assist the government have “not extended to circumstances in which there is a complete disruption of a service they offer to a customer as part of their business.”
It wasn't the case with Lavabit; there is obviously some point at which businesses are expected to properly architect their encryption solutions in order to comply with lawful search warrants. Would have been nice for the article to raise that counter-point and maybe try to address where exactly the line is drawn?
The point is Lavabit wasn't an 'All Writs' issue, if you get a search warrant against the company for data held by the company (e.g. the unencrypted iCloud backup) then it's a completely different expectation of compliance.
Does this or the WaPo article address if Apple possessed an iCloud backup of the device?
- schoen 11y ago> there is obviously some point at which businesses are expected to properly architect their encryption solutions in order to comply with lawful search warrants What do you mean by that? That they aren't allowed to provide end-to-end encryption that they can't decrypt? (I know that's not exactly what Lavabit did.)
- malandrew 11y agoAt least one big difference is ownership. With lavabit, the company owned the code and infrastructure that was used in a "crime". With an iOS device, Apple has sold the device to an individual who is now responsible for that device. That's a huge difference. The government has been using third-party doctrine as a weak link to exploit to get stuff it wants. Apple essentially removed themselves from the situation so that they are no longer a third-party responsible for the desired data.