3 ms·
Yeah, there is a lot of FUD on this one. Its really not a constitutional convention but more a gathering that will send proposed amendments back to the state l
by protomyth 11y ago
Yeah, there is a lot of FUD on this one. Its really not a constitutional convention but more a gathering that will send proposed amendments back to the state legislatures. It is not a rewrite of the Cobstitution.
- dragonwriter 11y agoUh, a gathering that sends proposed amendments to state legislatures is a Constitutional convention. (And the first Constitutional convention was gathered to do just that for the Articles of Confederation, it just ended up sending back a recommendation to trash the whole thing and start over. The concern that one called to do draft amendments for the Constitution might do likewise has always been one of the reasons people fear calling one, and have generally preferred running specific amendments through the Congress even when its difficult to calling a convention with direction to address a particular concern.)
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoI don't know. If the convention had to get it past the states, then they couldn't do anything too crazy, even if they totally rewrote it.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> I don't know. If the convention had to get it past the states, then they couldn't do anything too crazy, even if they totally rewrote it. Again, the Constitution itself is an example of why this may not be reliable: The original Constitutional Convention was called to propose revisions to the Article of Confederation, which required such changes to be adopted unanimously by the state legislatures. When it ended up proposing throwing the whole thing out and starting over, the new Constitution it proposed also had a different standard for passage -- requiring only nine of the states to ratify the new Constitution before it went into effect. People are afraid of a Constitutional Convention arbitrarily rewriting the rules independently of the governing authority because that's exactly what the only one we've had did.
- zaroth 11y agoThe topics under discussion back in 1787 were fairly foundational, but we have no shortage of hot topics which would surely end up 'needing' to be addressed in a convention. It's amusing to think with congress as gridlocked as ever, the idea you could touch the constitution with a 10-ft. pole. And of course that's the point, it should take something fairly amazing and universal to get any kind of change through. Diversely conflicting viewpoints are good for some things.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- protomyth 11y agoTrue, but people think total rewrite when they think convention and this is just amendments coming from a different direction.