6 ms·
The Happiest People
- gr366 17y agoIt is a lovely country well worth the visit and they deserve a lot of credit for their environmental conservation. But it's not as though they've done away with poverty. I've seen families living in shacks in Quepos just down the hill from sprawling expat mansions in Manuel Antonio. (Though even those families did seem pretty happy).
- abhiyerra 17y agoPoverty doesn't necessarily have to correlate with happiness (even though the West seems to think so). Sure they can't afford a lot of things and struggle, but some of the happiest people I've seen in India are the poor.
- alanthonyc 17y agoSeven of the most fun days of my life were spent on a vacation in Costa Rica.
- wallflower 17y agoI'd like to ask. Was it latitude or attitude? Or just being free? A perfect confluence of circumstance?
- 3pt14159 17y agoGuys, dig into the quoted research and you'll find they cherry picked data. For example, the USA with the question: "Suppose the top of the ladder represents the best possible life for you and the bottom of the ladder the worst possible life. Where on this ladder do you feel you personally stand at the present time?" has a response of 7.3 whereas Costa Rica has 6.9. Beware of newsprints offering statistics.
- rauljara 17y agoWhile I agree that you should question statistics, particularly those appearing in op-ed columns, I don't see how this statistic contradicts the thrust of the article at all. The self measures regarding happiness all still apply. It seems to me that this particular question seems to have to do more with being able to imagine a better life. That is, despite their happiness, Costa Ricans are able to imagine things getting even better. Despite our unhappiness, we in the U.S. have slightly more trouble imagining our lot improving. Even if you disagree with my interpretation, you have to admit that it is incredibly open to interpretation, even more so than the question, 'are you happy?' I'd say the more direct measure would be the obvious one to quote.
- 3pt14159 17y agoTo me, "are you happy" seems more temporal. Whereas, "do you have the best possible life" seems more lasting. If someone calls me up in the middle of Jan on a cold week here in Toronto, say -25C, I'm not a happy man, but I still think I have the best life possible.
- mixmax 17y ago"Maybe Costa Rican contentment has something to do with the chance to explore dazzling beaches on both sides of the country .... and it’s surely easier to be happy while basking in sunshine and greenery than while shivering up north and suffering nature deficit disorder." Denmark, which comes in at number two in the happinsess index has beaches that are emtpy 10 months of the year because of the cold. Right now I'm looking out the window at a frozen sea. And I guess this ought to make Iran a very happy country too. I think we can conclude two things from this article: The author likes Costa Rica, and he doesn't understand that correlation doesn't equal causation - like many of his peers in journalism.
- carbocation 17y agoGiven the points you've selected, it's hard to say that the author even cares to distinguish correlated data from anecdote.
- DaniFong 17y agoCorrelation might not imply causation, but nothing implies causation. The best we've got is a pile of correlations, a few anecdotes, and a lot of imagination.
- jey 17y agoYou can infer a lot about the underlying causal processes from the "pile of correlations". Humans do this all the time. If flipping a light switch correlates highly with the lamp's state switching from "on" to "off" and vice-versa, and in every observed instance the light-switch was flipped before the light changed state, wouldn't you assign a higher probability to the causal model "flipping the switch causes lamp to change state" than "lamp changing state causes switch to flip"? In other words, we can do a lot better than to just say that "lamp changing state and switch-flipping are highly correlated". http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/causation-probabilistic/ http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/causation-probabilistic/ (Sorry for being pedantic.)
- hugh_ 17y ago
- petercooper 17y agoIt's all well and good getting rid of your army when you have a superpower (with whom you have a free trade agreement) just up the street and which would be unlikely to let an invasion slip under its nose. It's even better when your country has hardly anything worth invading for..
- sgman 17y agoYou just described 90% of the countries in the area. However, Costa Rica is the only one that has implemented this. The author's point still stands.
- petercooper 17y agoGoing on the CIA World Fact Book figures as stated at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_military_expenditures http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_military_e..., Haiti, Bermuda, Guatemala, and Trinidad and Tobago spend less of their GDP on military expenditure than Costa Rica. And Mexico, Jamaica, Honduras, Nicargua, Barbados and the Bahamas all come in at only 0.5% or 0.6% of GDP compared to Costa Rica's 0.4%. With some minor exceptions (Belize needs a deterrent for historical reasons), almost the whole of central America is poorly armed and barely militarized due to the long arms of Uncle Sam. Whether or not these countries have boasted about complete demilitarization or not is just a formality when they spend so little on what they do have.
- akkartik 17y agoBook recommendation: the geography of bliss (http://www.amazon.com/Geography-Bliss-Grumps-Search-Happiest/dp/0446580260 http://www.amazon.com/Geography-Bliss-Grumps-Search-Happiest...) Among other things it includes a now-interesting perspective on Iceland.
- 10ren 17y agoOrson Scott Card has this idea of "edge" nations and "centre" nations. It's to do with whose culture wins, not to do with whose military wins. Basically, when an "edge" invades a "center" (or vice versa), the result looks like the centre nation. So, the Mongols invaded China... and adopted Chinese style government. I think the Romans were amongst the strongest centre nations, as we're still copying them (pythons: "what have the Romans ever done for us?") e.g. democracy, bureaucracy, even details like a senate. Though fallen, the Empire survives. heads beat arms
- eru 17y agoYou may be right in general. Though: Democracy from the Romans? They used to have a Republic, but it was not a Democracy. Much of the `Roman' stuff comes from the Greek. And they also got a lot from elsewhere, too. I do find myself agreeing with your assessment of China and Mongolia more.
- willwagner 17y agoOf all the places I've gone, there are two places I've visited where I found the people to be remarkably friendly and happy: Costa Rica and Thailand. I'm sure part of it was that I spent time in both places on vacation, but in both, I was on a rented motorcycle with my wife, visiting both touristy areas and places off the beaten path. My wife and I have a dream of starting an international hacker house someday for companies/individuals that want some isolation and focus during crunch mode but also want some exotic locale, and both Costa Rica and Thailand are on our short list.
- tezza 17y agoThe New Economics Forum was searching for a press hit, it is a shame NY Times is confirming this truthiness[1] As evidence see :: http://heavylifting.blogspot.com/2006/07/on-happy-planet-index.html http://heavylifting.blogspot.com/2006/07/on-happy-planet-ind... and especially the comment from the NEF itself sam.thompson@neweconomics.org "However, I thought your piece was thoughtful and interesting, so I just wanted to make one point, which is that we don't claim that the index measures happiness (we emphasise several times, in fact, that it doesn't). Rather, we claim that it measures well-being efficiency: that is, the relative 'price paid' for experienced well-being by countries as a function of their resource consumption." "To an extent we asked for this kind of (mis)interpretation by using the word 'happy' in the title of the report - we have wondered, with hindsight, whether this was such a good idea. The trade off is that we got a huge (and 95% positive) press hit - and that's all part of the game too.." ---------- [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Truthiness http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Truthiness