5 ms·
Many programmers talk about Ada Lovelace, who was certainly awesome, but should be talking about Margaret Hamilton. Before anyone heard of Dijkstra's work, Hami
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
Many programmers talk about Ada Lovelace, who was certainly awesome, but should be talking about Margaret Hamilton. Before anyone heard of Dijkstra's work, Hamilton was straight up inventing everything from real, software engineering to properly handling fault-tolerance and human interfaces. Here's what she was doing (see Apollo Beginnings rather than USL):
http://htius.com/Articles/r12ham.pdf http://htius.com/Articles/r12ham.pdf
Her Wikipedia page gives her due credit and shows just how much she and her team pulled off:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Margaret_Hamilton_%28scientist%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Margaret_Hamilton_%28scientist...
Also note the size of that printout of her program. Try to think about how many people make one like that which doesn't fail in the field even when parts of its environment and hardware are failing. Also while using low-level code with little to no tool support on 60's era, embedded hardware rather than a JVM, etc. Margaret Hamilton was the first in the field of high-assurance programming that I've seen. A lot of firsts.
So, I give her credit where possible. The industry should even more as she wasn't a theoretical programmer like Ada Lovelace: she engineered actual software, co-invented many of the best practices for it, deployed them successfully in production, and then made a tool that automated much of that from requirement specs to correct code.
While programmers and industry ignore her, at least NASA gave her positive mention as the founder of software engineering and ultra-reliable software along with the biggest check they ever cut to an innovator:
https://www.nasa.gov/home/hqnews/2003/sep/HQ_03281_Hamilton_Honor.html https://www.nasa.gov/home/hqnews/2003/sep/HQ_03281_Hamilton_...
Where would our systems and tools be if more attention was put into her methods, even just principles, than informal use of C? ;)
- jkot 11y agoTo be fair hardware failure tolerance comes from Antonin Svoboda. He worked on that from 1951.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoI thought I said "fault tolerance" rather than "hardware fault tolerance" to reduce confusion. I failed: inherently confusing I guess haha. To be clear, I was mainly referring to her use of the asynchronous, priority-based model. That combined with self-checking/adaptation and human-in-the-loop, priority displays. Most of what I read mention those specifically as her contributions. Do correct me if she didn't invent any of these or was merely the first wise enough to apply them to production systems. I like keeping the facts straight so right people get credit for building better parts of our field. :) Thanks for the Svoboda reference as I didn't know about him. His is our vanilla approach for reliability so he deserves credit. Might look up his papers.
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoAnother woman computer science first seldom celebrated is Kateryna Yushchenko, who invented a high-level programming language with pointers in 1955, 3 years before FORTRAN: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kateryna_Yushchenko_%28scientist%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kateryna_Yushchenko_%28scienti... Sadly, being behind the Iron Curtain was likely a primary reason for her relegation to obscurity.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoI didn't know about her either. Thanks for the reference. The Wikipedia page on the language looks like it was hit with some nationalist propaganda: claims credit for all kinds of concepts without backing it up. Her page looks legit, though. I'd like to see English versions of her original work and subsequent papers. I also like that they tried the automatic programming with algebraic methods. Their approach might be interesting. A few correct-by-construction software and hardware approaches developed here took that approach. DDD toolkit for hardware comes to mind. Hmm, we need more info on her to see just how much credit she's missing and give it to her.
- s_q_b 11y agoMeet USN Rear Admiral Grace Hopper: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grace_Hopper https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grace_Hopper Inventor of the compiler, early advocate of machine-independent computer languages, creator of COBOL, originator of the verb debugging.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoAnother great example. I've given her plenty of praise as well. I've always credited her as inventing English-language programming and compilers. Are there any before her mid-1950's work? And that actually worked? ;) So, Hopper is the first, great programmer that women bring us. Helps lay the foundation for all HLL programming. Hamilton took it to the next step to true engineering practice. Kind of set the bar high. So, she's my main mascot. Hopper's is great, though. Should probably present them all as a group with their contributions to foundations.
- 11y ago
- davidw 11y ago> but should be talking about No reason not to talk about both of them!
- nickpsecurity 11y agoI agree. As I told another, I essentially meant that as they're both great. Just more emphasis on the one that invented our field and put it into production nearly flawlessly. A lot more inspiring than even the heavy-hitters from academia because she didn't build "toy" systems. ;)
- brlewis 11y agoAda Lovelace's story is a jumping-off point to talk about other achievements of women in science, technology, engineering and mathematics. http://findingada.com/ http://findingada.com/ You're quite right that Margaret Hamilton's achievements should be talked about more. P.S. Happy Ada Lovelace Day!
- nickpsecurity 11y agoI see you're point there. Her story did kind of become a meme about women in science in general. I surely don't mind it but think Hamilton's accomplishments are more empowering. And not just to women: anyone trying to deal with the mess that is software. "P.S. Happy Ada Lovelace Day!" Back at ya!
- kevin_thibedeau 11y ago> Hamilton received a check for $37,200 Should have been $32,768.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoI'll admit I was slow enough to check if AGS had a 32,768Hz oscillator: crystals are a common usage of that number. Then, I realized I was overthinking it, it's HN, and you're probably a programmer. How would you interpret that number? Confirmation with the calculator leads to my final, hopefully-correct answer. "Should have been $32,768." No, it should be $37,200 because Ms Hamilton only accepts unsigned integers on her checks. Insists you pay her rather than the other way around. :P
- robotresearcher 11y ago> Also note the size of that printout of her program. That print out is not the source code. I'm pretty sure it's a listing of test results. The Apollo computers couldn't store that much in either (the equivalent of) RAM or ROM.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- vilhelm_s 11y agoHamilton herself says otherwise: > "In this picture, I am standing next to listings of the actual Apollo Guidance Computer (AGC) source code," Hamilton says in an email. "To clarify, there are no other kinds of printouts, like debugging printouts, or logs, or what have you, in the picture." It's just her and her code. http://www.vox.com/2015/5/30/8689481/margaret-hamilton-apollo-software http://www.vox.com/2015/5/30/8689481/margaret-hamilton-apoll...
- nickpsecurity 11y agoI knew I read it was the code somewhere but lacked a link past Wikipedia. Thanks for that one! Original claim stays and remains at elite level it was. :)
- no1ne 11y agoAlso before the picture lies this statement - Here's an amazing picture of her next to the code she and her colleagues wrote for the Apollo 11 guidance computer that made the moon landing possible:
- robotresearcher 11y agoIf she says so of course I'll concede the point. I don't really understand how it can be true, since the recorded specs of the AGC were 4K RAM and 64K ROM. That's only a few pages of text even in assembly code.
- vilhelm_s 11y ago