23 ms·
If You're Not Paranoid, You're Crazy
- radiorental 11y agoSomewhat ironic and paradoxical http://imgur.com/Z2BIMcw http://imgur.com/Z2BIMcw
- oconnore 11y agoYou can install an annoyance list that blocks those.
- mfoy_ 11y agoIsn't it more likely that they just load the ads over those "we noticed you're using an ad blocker..." placeholders, so if you block the ads you see the ad blocker message?
- oconnore 11y agoI don't know what you mean by more likely. The rule is "theatlantic.com##.blocker-message > .blackbox + .disable" from "Adblock Warning Removal List". It's a default list in uBlock Origin.
- digibo 11y agoI guess it's a list that blocks similar things that are "under" ads and only show when you block ads. Soon, sites will just start adding more stuff to be revealed once you block those. It's an endless pit and no one has a solution.
- jakeogh 11y agoDisable JS. I mapped it to a hotkey when I "need" it (using surf/webkit). Makes the web great again.
- Nadya 11y ago>It's an endless pit and no one has a solution. This needs a little bit of tweaking on a per-site basis, but works really well at blocking most things. */ Hide most everything that isn't the content. /* :not(.main-content) { display: none !important; } .main-content > * { display: block !important; } Combined with bookmarklets to disable CSS and strip images: http://pastebin.com/etLwqx5A http://pastebin.com/etLwqx5A I can read content more or less marketing/fluff free. I then add several styles to make things a bit more legible (font size, a specific font I prefer, body width 85%, line height, and less-contrasting colors). When I have some spare time on a future weekend I plan to find a way to combine all of them into a single Firefox add-on or a one-click-to-do-everything bookmarklet.
- nathancahill 11y agoIsn't this basically Readability mode in Safari?
- Nadya 11y agoDoesn't work on WSJ and similar sites that require a Google UTF to read. I also have a bit more authority and control over things than the limited options of Readability. (Readability was built into Safari 5 but is a standalone bookmarklet/add-on as well. Was actually a big inspiration for me fixing things how I want them.)
- sp332 11y agoBetter: loaded over HTTPS with mixed content disabled https://imgur.com/DWaNlul https://imgur.com/DWaNlul It doesn't load anything over HTTP, and looks just fine in Reader mode.
- ljk 11y agoAnd all the tracking cookies - http://s13.postimg.org/64047bamv/track.png http://s13.postimg.org/64047bamv/track.png
- task_queue 11y agoThere are better options than to use Ghostery for the same reasons you don't want a private company having a say in your privacy ;)
- razster 11y agoDon't forget Privacy Badger
- mfoy_ 11y agoThink of how many apps you've installed which request permission to a whole laundry list of phone functions. "Oh, it's reasonable that this app wants access to my text messages, that way when it sends me a confirmation code it can automatically read it." "Oh, it's reasonable that this app wants access to my mic, maybe it will implement voice chat in a coming update." "Oh, it's reasonable that this app wants access to my call history and whatnot, that way it can mute itself or pause itself when I get a phone call." ... oh, I guess it's reasonable that if I text, or talk with my phone nearby, about walnuts I'll start seeing targeted ads for walnuts.
- 0xffff2 11y agoReally? There's no way I would install any of those theoretical apps. Hell, I probably wouldn't install any app that requires mic permissions period.
- onedev 11y agoThat's the problem though. It's not about you. It's about the average user who doesn't understand all the implications of actions he/she is asked to take or permissions he/she is asked to give to a third party. It's not about "us" the HN readers. It's about everyone else, and that's what's scary. Just because I'm a really good driver doesn't mean I won't get into a car crash.
- mercora 11y agoOne feature i really like about cyanogenmod is the ability to revoke most privacy related permissions or deploy a dialog when accessed, asking for permission on a case by case basis. I think it should have been that way from the beginning forcing app developers to handle cases where some permissions aren't granted. It makes for much better visibility when some data is used and to some degree for what.
- stvswn 11y agoThe next version of Android ("M") does this.
- Simulacra 11y agoParanoia can be healthy sometimes
- privong 11y ago“Sometimes paranoia's just having all the facts.” – William S. Burroughs
- qwertyFish 11y agoThis was not the seniment the community expressed yesterday to me...
- throwaway459730 11y agoI remember your post. I don't think you have any mental health issues, I mean long-standing ones. Your comments recently as well as your original post is in some ways quite cogent. But as I replied to you in that thread (I don't remember my throwaway pwd), the Reddit CO2 poisoning guy also sounded quite fine. He wrote in quite a similar style as you, in the sense that there are no stylistic clues, it sounded well-reasoned. But you gave HN a lot of information other than the hacking facts - specifically, your exact adderal dosage, and also feeling ill physically. I initialled replied by asking about who would have a motive to send you that email - but after I saw the linked Reddit article about the CO2 poisoning guy, I decided that it's probably more important for you to lower your adderall usage and make sure you're not physically ill. I mean what are the downsides to not taking so much adderal? None. People specifically pointed out the effects that you describe matching the adderall dosage, and also I think what you said about your family being concerned is a BIG clue. After all, I doubt the author's family (of the Atlantic article in this thread) is concerned about him for writing it (as a point of comparison). So what I mean is that just because you believe you're being hacked doesn't mean you would tell your whole family - their conern doesn't come from the facts, it comes from your behavior. So that to me also said that it is likely that you should get the primary things that might be causing this into check. All that said, I found the facts you reported to be completely plausible. But, like, so what? The matrix of reward/loss for you looks like this: There are two questions: are you temporarily ill, and are you being hacked. You now have two choices: explore your possible illness or ignore it. Here is the reward table: Expl = explore possibility of illness Being hacked? No Yes Ill? No [ Expl.: -30 Ignore: 0 ] [Expl: -30 Ignore: 0] Yes [ Expl.: -30 Ignore: -10000 ] [Expl: -30 Ignore: -10000] If the above boxes are taken in this order: 1 2 3 4 1: You're not being hacked and not ill. Simply mistaken. In this case, exploring illness will take you time and trouble, denoted by -30. If you ignore the possibility of illness (and the possibility of being hacked) you suffer no consequences. 2: In this case you ARE being hacked, and not ill. You're correct about feeling like you're being hacked. In this case, exploring illness possibility takes you the same -30. But if you ignore the possibility of illness, you suffer no negative consequences, EVEN THOUGH you're actively being hacked. 3: This is what happened to C02 guy. He has permanent brain damage now. He was NOT "being hacked" but was very seriously ill. In your story, this is a possibility since you reported physical illness, since your family was worried (even though if you wre genuinely being hacked you would have no reason to share with them, since it would be obvoius to you that it would sound paranoid), and you were taking huge adderal dosage. In addition, you could have some genuine issue like CO2 poisoning - for example is there a fireplace in the place you moved to? Is it ventilated. This is just one possibility, there are many other illnesses you could have contracted in the recent past, or external causes of your feeling. 4: The situation is EXACTLY THE SAME if you actually are under surveillance. if you ignore and don't treat your illness, you are under the exact same risks, even if at the same time your surveillance or being hacked is real. You gain nothing from not exploring the possibility of illness. Why do I put -10,000 into the illness box? Because this is what Co2 guy reports (after reddit successfully diagnosed him and his Co2 meter was off the charts): "Likely permanent damage. I can't work. I get confused watching movies. I can't remember anything. I confuse my reflection for a different person." [1] If he hadn't told reddit, today he would very likely be dead. What happenes if you're being hacked? Nothing. So given the barest glance at the matrix above, it should seem completely obvious that you MUST explore health-related possibilities while completely ignoring the possibility that you're being hacked. You get no benefit from deciding this now, rather than after you're feeling normal. I very strongly advise you to follow up as everyone suggested! [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/legaladvice/comments/3iycro/fl_i_am_being_harassed_by_an_leo_agency_please/cup3gyf?context=3 https://www.reddit.com/r/legaladvice/comments/3iycro/fl_i_am...
- GigabyteCoin 11y ago>I’d driven to meet a friend at an art gallery in Hollywood, my first visit to a gallery in years. The next morning, in my inbox, several spam e-mails urged me to invest in art. That was an easy one to figure out: I’d typed the name of the gallery into Google Maps. I don't see how the author makes the connection here. How does searching for an art gallery on Google Maps translate into spam emails? Is he accusing Google of selling your email address and search information to spammers?
- elorant 11y agoFurthermore, spam is rarely targeted. If it was, spammers wouldn't need to send hundreds of millions of e-mails. And I doubt it works that fast. You visit some suspicious site one day and the very next you're bombarded with "several spam emails". Lastly, I don't see how legitimate art businesses would tolerate spam. I'm an amateur art collector visiting dozens of art sites for years and I've never received spam. The guy is obviously talking out of his ass. Which is a shame because he's trying to make a good point.
- unshift 11y agoSuccessful spammers are absolutely targeting their emails. It's similar to when you search for something on Amazon and then see ads for it on Facebook -- the goal is to put an ad in your inbox (essentially for free) instead of paying for ad impressions.
- elorant 11y agoThat’s programmatic advertising. It’s a different beast while very relevant to the context of being continually monitored/profiled. If there's such a thing as targeted spam I've yet to witness it.
- 9248 11y agoWhat if he's using an Android phone? Most third party apps on the Google Play store have access to both your location and accounts. I even remember seeing back in the day questions with valid answers on stackoverflow about how to get the email associated with a device without requesting the accounts permission, but some other close ones. I also made the mistake of using a personal account with my first Android phone. I had zero spam on that account. 2 months later I was getting about 10 emails a day. (not targeted though since I didn't live in an very active area)
- zbyte64 11y agoThe part about voluntarily giving up confessions reminds me of something similar during the Vietnam war. People would be grouped together and would need to "confess" the allures of capitalism. You could only graduate from the program once you procured enough drama to guarantee you were a comrade.
- MagnumOpus 11y agoThe Viet Cong learned from the one true master - these torture/coercion methods are copied from Mao's "struggle sessions" where any successful farmers/craftsmen and university graduates were publicly tortured in front of the proletariat until they admitted to any and all crimes (and in a few million cases they were killed anyway, pour encourager les autres).
- dfc 11y agoWhat does "procured enough drama" mean?
- hyperion2010 11y agoQu'on me donne six lignes écrites de la main du plus honnête homme, j'y trouverai de quoi le faire pendre. --Cardinal Richelieu
- esnard 11y agoEnglish translation for people who don't understand French: "If you give me six lines written by the hand of the most honest of men, I will find something in them which will hang him."
- TeMPOraL 11y agoWhich suggests that it's not the surveillance that's the problem, it's that if the decisionmaker is an idiot, there's nothing that can save you (yes, killing people because of politics is total, counterproductive idiocy, even if it doesn't seem as it from within the system). EDIT: seriously. This quote most definitely doesn't mean people should stop writing out of fear of execution.
- maxerickson 11y agoIt's frustrating how many people are preparing to carefully live in hell, rather than working to head the whole thing off.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoI don't know. I'm still not convinced that what most here would consider "heading the whole thing off" would really result in a better world. If, on the other hand, instead of playing around with surveillance we embraced the lack of (expectation of) privacy altogether, went with in full-steam, we could probably get used to it and move forward as a society, reaping the benefits of society-level data analysis. I'm not sure about this, but I haven't heard that many serious arguments against to offset the potential benefits. I think we either have to go all-in or all-out; hesitation and aiming for middle ground will give too much power to wrong actors while leaving the society powerless.
- xkiwi 11y agoIt is scary for me to know: #Majority of people post photo of friends on Facebook without understand facial recognition always scans. #Prefer convenient over privacy, such as Toll Tag on cars. #Follow trends.
- FrankenPC 11y agoWhat scares me is how few people take passwords, anti-virus/anti-malware, clean browsing habits, etc. seriously. Without better end-node security, individuals and the entire internet are always at risk. (I'm primarily looking at you Windows...). In other words, IMO big government and corporate overreach are minor problems compared to the active-assault going on to dominate the non-technical end-user computers.
- orf 11y agoWhat scares me more is what little difference strong passwords, 'anti-virus' and clean browsing makes.
- FrankenPC 11y agoI'm thinking about running Wireshark on my machine to analyze the packets to see what is going on. Or, putting a non-switch ethernet hub between my wifi router and my modem to tap in with Wireshark to see if anything else looks fishy. You're right. We should all be paranoid.
- linkregister 11y agoDo you think that paying in cash at the toll booth is any more private? A photo of your license plate is taken at cash toll booths (Northeastern corridor E-ZPass and California Fastrak). If someone keeps their Twitter handle disambiguated from their personal life, is there a reason why they can't #followallthehashtags?
- xkiwi 11y agoIt is more than that. most traffic condition on map rely on Toll Tag to measure travel time and speed between points, on normal highway. Unless you have a detachable tag, otherwise your tag ID will appear on every single major interception, with time, speed between blocks. Most of Tag will ship to your house, and/or auto fill by credit card once the balance is low. People probably imagine they will be erased after few years, but $sudo happeneds. http://www.dailykos.com/story/2015/08/17/1412811/-AT-T-and-NSA-besties-since-1985-in-warrantless-surveillance http://www.dailykos.com/story/2015/08/17/1412811/-AT-T-and-N...
- powera 11y agoActually, this guy is paranoid and crazy. It doesn't mean he isn't right, but by any definition he is both paranoid and crazy.
- task_queue 11y agoActually, you are mixing a medical diagnosis with defamatory language and you are not Walter Kirn's doctor. By any definition, this makes you a shithead with an opinion.
- powera 11y agoClaiming that a flat tire is because you emailed about visiting a datacenter, and that there are invisible black helicopters guarding the datacenter, and spending an entire crazed weekend looking for exactly what you want to see and then deciding that everything you see fits exactly what you were looking for is basically the definition of crazy. He might not be crazy, but what he's describing himself as doing definitely is.
- robotkilla 11y agoFrom google: > Crazy: 1) mentally deranged, especially as manifested in a wild or aggressive way. Extremely annoyed or angry. Foolish. 2)extremely enthusiastic 3) (of an angle) appearing absurdly out of place or in an unlikely position I have to agree that he does not fit the definition of crazy at least by the text of his article.
- dang 11y ago> this makes you a shithead This breaks the HN guidelines. We ban accounts that do this. Please post civilly and substantively, or not at all. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- cubano 11y agoReminds me of poster I saw in dude's house way way back in my stoner days... "I know I'm paranoid, but am I paranoid enough?"
- Nadya 11y agoI like that quote... thanks for sharing. I've also followed that vein of thought since the Snowden leaks. I was aware of government surveillance before the Snowden leaks. I was always considered a "crazy conspiracy theorist". I didn't have concrete proof, but strong evidence. Looking back, I find it was odd that I was really dismissive of the FBI Spy Planes [0] that I had occasionally heard about. They seemed inefficient and far-fetched and I considered those people to be crazy conspiracy theorists. Woops. After the Snowden leaks, I stopped being so dismissive of conspiracy theorists. I don't necessarily take them very seriously or believe them - but I don't treat them like they are claiming leprechauns exist. Unless there's a more reasonable or scientific explanation available, such as with "chemtrails". I'm still readily dismissive of that theory... just normal contrails. [0] http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2015/06/02/fbi-surveillance-flights_n_7490396.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2015/06/02/fbi-surveillance-fl...
- shogun21 11y agoPeople are afraid of what they don't understand. If you just thought of the cloud as a server somewhere instead of a mysterious "ghostly entity", you'd know it's really not as smart as you think it is.
- msutherl 11y agoI still don't quite comprehend why people feel personally bothered by such things. Yes, it is better for society to have safeguards in place to prevent certain kinds of surveillance as a check on governmental and corporate power – and we need to fight for this – but some data about you stored on some servers, a targeted advertisement? What exactly is the immediate personal threat?
- mercora 11y agoIn my opinion just knowing that your activities are monitored alters your behavior. Which for me is enough to be seriously concerned...
- msutherl 11y agoI think "seriously concerned" is different from "personally bothered". Concern has to do with the situation as a whole and what you might do about it, not i.e. feelings of personal violation, no?
- justcommenting 11y agohttps://twitter.com/Snowden/status/653705501381947393 https://twitter.com/Snowden/status/653705501381947393
- msutherl 11y agoI have no idea whether this statement is true! Can you provide some justification?
- PavlovsCat 11y agoIf the data exists, there is a way to get it, theoretically. We're so far from a provably "secure" anything, that is, a complete chain, that until we have that, why risk it? "Some servers" can be collated before you can say "fascist takeover". And while this might seem like fear mongering, considering that the "benefit" is advertising, well, I personally think even a slim risk for a grave occurance outweighs that, and that advertisement in the way it's employed most of the time is a problem we should solve, not "improve". Talking about free markets with one side of the mouth, while constantly seeking to badger and influence people is the same abomination as it was when it was invented, no matter how used to it people get. Though personally, I'm for a social solution: total boycott of those who advertise that way, turning ad-block off to make black lists for shopping. I know it's a pipe dream, but it's mine.
- thaumaturgy 11y agoParanoia is a specific thing. It requires irrational, unjustifiable fears and a sense of blame or persecution. You're not "paranoid" if you've changed your behavior in the wake of the Snowden documents or if you're cautious regarding the amount of information you share with third party services and devices. I'm not being pedantic, I've seen a lot of arguments recently from actual paranoid conspiracy theorists that feel smug in the wake of Snowden. I'd hate to see people start to confuse real paranoia with informed caution.
- damosneeze 11y agoGood point. But the author probably didn't choose the title. I hear they rarely do at large publications.
- dfc 11y agoGood point but...? I don't understand the point of your comment. If the editors at the large publication chose the title does that assuage some of GP's concern that people will "start to confuse real paranoia with informed caution"? If the editors did chose the title AND the author used the term paranoia five times in the article how does that change GP's concern that people will start to confuse real paranoia with informed caution?
- Retric 11y agoDegree matters, if you make minor changes post Snowden then that's fine. If Snowden is the trigger that causes you to start using tinfoil to block the T-ray's then that's not ok.
- derf_ 11y agoDon't be ridiculous. Tin-foil hats amplify exactly the frequencies used by the US government and large multinationals for GPS and mobile phone tracking: https://web.archive.org/web/20100708230258/http://people.csail.mit.edu/rahimi/helmet/ https://web.archive.org/web/20100708230258/http://people.csa...
- graycat 11y agoIn your Web browser, be careful what cookies you are willing to accept.
- mattmanser 11y agoIf you are a sci-fi fan, an interesting new trilogy to read is the Imperial Radch trilogy by Anne Leckie starting with Ancillary Justice. One of the interesting themes is that everyone is surveilled totally and intimately down to even their feelings, but it's not the point of the book and the protagonist treats it as totally normal and it's never really discussed nor is there any suggestion it would be better if that wasn't the case. I really enjoyed the trilogy but as someone who's pro-privacy it was a strange read.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoIn Jacek Dukaj's "Black Oceans", the portrayed world also has surveillance everywhere that is treated as normal. Moreover, it serves an important social function there - it facilitates insurance claims. If anything happens and it was registered on cameras, victims are determined and reimbursed properly. Conversely, you can opt out of the surveillance and e.g. have a camera-free zone in your home or conduct your meetings in such - but by doing so, you forefit the right to get insurance if anything happens to you while you're outside monitoring range.
- euske 11y agoParanoid or not, we should develop a healthy skepticism about this in the society. A scary thing to me is that most people don't know about the true capability of information linking/correlating from multiple sources. It's not intuitive for us that you can get seemingly innocuous data and combine them to magically tell one's behavior. These kinds of threats should be systematically studied and made consciously known to the public.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- geggam 11y agoAmazes me that anyone familiar with data online thinks there aren't ways to track and store everyone's internet usage.
- TeMPOraL 11y ago> Had merely typing seduction into a search engine marked me as a rascal? Or was the formula more sophisticated? Could it be that my online choices in recent weeks—the travel guide to Berlin that I’d perused, the Porsche convertible I’d priced, the old girlfriend to whom I’d sent a virtual birthday card—indicated longings and frustrations that I was too deep in denial to acknowledge? While a lot of those examples are true instances of tracking and inference, in some cases I think author is imagining things. People have a scary capability to see patterns and intelligent agents where none exists. It's incredibly easy to cause this. I'm running a simple IRC bot that "pretends to be human" by means of hand-tailored regular expressions matching input and some witty responses. I can't count the times I tricked people into believing they were talking to human. It's like, write out some simple regexes and you're 90% way to passing a Turing test. People prime and then fool themselves. So yeah, I'm betting those results in the part I quoted were caused just by "seduction techniques" search. And if he clicked on that Ashley Madison banner, he basically sealed his fate.
- nommm-nommm 11y agoThe classic story is how Target figures out when women are pregnant by their buying habits. I honestly don't know how true it is but it gets repeated quite often. Sounds fishy to me. http://www.forbes.com/sites/kashmirhill/2012/02/16/how-target-figured-out-a-teen-girl-was-pregnant-before-her-father-did/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/kashmirhill/2012/02/16/how-targe...
- TeMPOraL 11y agoThat actually sounds perfectly realistic to me. Those are results you expect to have if you did your job right (knowing the girl was pregnant, not pissing off her father in the process).
- nommm-nommm 11y agoThe fishy part is where the dad goes to Target and demands and apology. I also was unaware that Target sent out targeted coupons.
- cardamomo 11y agoI really enjoyed reading this piece, not only for its discussion of privacy, but also for its poetic and reflective language. There's something more than technical about today's surveillance problem, and the author approaches this issue from a philosophical and, at times, almost spiritual angle. These are the kinds of discussions we need to have more often: not only what's going on and what it means in practical terms, but also how today's surveillance explosion changes who we are and how we relate to ourselves.
- em3rgent0rdr 11y ago20+ trackers blocked by Privacy Badger while reading this article.