43 ms·
The report did not go into finding out who did it. Both sides own BUKs. It is very difficult to find the truth because all sides are pumping out propaganda. Ev
by sschueller 11y ago
The report did not go into finding out who did it. Both sides own BUKs. It is very difficult to find the truth because all sides are pumping out propaganda. Even the United States is manipulating what we hear for their own political and economic gains.
Here an subtle but strong example : http://www.sott.net/article/302911-Sott-Exclusive-Full-unedited-text-of-Vladimir-Putins-interview-with-Charlie-Rose-What-CBS-left-out http://www.sott.net/article/302911-Sott-Exclusive-Full-unedi...
- tptacek 11y agoDid both sides have the ability to position a BUK launcher so that it was capable of hitting an airliner at 33kft at that precise location, 50 miles towards Russia east of rebel-controlled Donetsk? How seriously are we meant to take this particular controversy?
- zilean 11y agoThere were plenty of state controlled land east/south of Donetsk. You can check map here http://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-27308526 http://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-27308526
- tptacek 11y agoThe maps you're linking to further implicate the rebels (see again the video reconstruction, which illustrates the trajectory the missile took from its launch site, which is not the same as the crash site, placing the missile launch even further from areas of Ukrainian control and even closer to Russia.) Further, to even entertain this question, you have to believe that Ukraine positioned BUK launchers in the most heavily contested part of the country, in areas which were apparently held by rebels just weeks earlier. This does not look like a serious controversy. The rebels shot the plane down.
- istvan__ 11y agoThey had few seconds to shoot it down. They had to coordinate very well to achieve this.
- hackerboos 11y agoI've just been ignoring news out of Ukraine as there's nobody who I trust reporting on the issues. Does anybody have an objective news sources regarding Ukraine? Even the link above looks like Russian propaganda.
- unfasten 11y agoHave you looked at the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe? They have a few groups in Ukraine and post updates online, though I don't know how much it would be like a news organization's reporting. I was checking it some last year but haven't really looked since. Worth a look. http://www.osce.org/ukraine-smm http://www.osce.org/ukraine-smm OSCE Special Monitoring Mission to Ukraine. Here's the SMM's mandate: The monitors are mandated to contribute to reducing tensions and to help foster peace, stability and security. The Mission engages with authorities at all levels, as well as civil society, ethnic and religious groups and local communities to facilitate dialogue on the ground. The Mission will gather information and report on the security situation, establish and report facts in response to specific incidents, including those concerning alleged violations of fundamental OSCE principles. http://www.osce.org/om http://www.osce.org/om OSCE Observer Mission at the Russian Checkpoints Gukovo and Donetsk http://www.osce.org/ukraine http://www.osce.org/ukraine OSCE Project Co-ordinator in Ukraine And here are the daily updates from the Special Monitoring Mission: http://www.osce.org/ukraine-smm/daily-updates http://www.osce.org/ukraine-smm/daily-updates http://www.osce.org/who http://www.osce.org/who And to help you judge the OCSE for yourself, here's their about page. (There are 57 particpating states, including Russia, USA and Ukraine)
- thedevil 11y agoWe'll never know 100% but Ukraine controlled the air so only the rebels had motive to shoot down planes, and had bragged about it on social media. It's possible that Ukrainian forces or someone else had a conspiracy to frame the rebels (if you have a good conspiracy theory, Russian propaganda would love to hear it). But this is very unlikely as it's a high-risk, low pay-off strategy and even Russian leaders are usually not that evil or stupid.
- tptacek 11y agoThey'd need more than the will to frame the separatists; they'd also have to get a big lumbering BUK launcher right into the middle of a separatist stronghold, sandwiched between Donetsk and Russia, crew it, set it up, launch the missile, and then get the thing out undetected.
- powertower 11y ago> We'll never know 100% but Ukraine controlled the air so only the rebels had motive to shoot down planes, and had bragged about it on social media. At the time, Kiev was complaining that Russia was sending out spy planes into its territory. Knowing the state of the Ukrainian military, to me it's much more likely that they mistaken the plane for something it was not and shot it down.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- kushti 11y agoIt seems "specialists" taught by media know all about the incindent and love to share their "knowledge" in comments.
- alkonaut 11y ago> Both sides own BUKs. Only the Russian side has these BUKs. One of the key findings is which specific warhead version was used. The report doesn't spell out who did it, it does however conclude that a BUK missile from the Russian military shot down the plane. That BUK may have been stolen or on holiday in eastern Ukraine.
- jakobdabo 11y agoAccording to Russian media it's quite the opposite. They say Russia doesn't use the 9M38 missiles any more, Ukraine does.
- tptacek 11y agoThey are full of it. There are pictures of Putin at Russian military bases standing in front of 9M38M1 missiles!
- jakobdabo 11y agoObviously, I don't know who shot the missile. But when trying to use logic here, I don't see why would Russia shoot the plane. They had nothing to gain. Ukraine? I don't know, I refuse to believe they would deliberately kill hundreds for some advantage. My bet is on the rebels who did it mistakenly. The question is whose BUK they used. One provided by Russia or one taken from an abandoned Ukrainian base.
- tptacek 11y agoI don't know how to respond to this comment. Your earlier comment parroted a line that is apparently popular in the Russian media, that Russia no longer uses the 9M38M1 SAM. But that missile is distinctive, and can been seen in recent photographs at Russian military installations. I didn't say that Russia shot down MH17. I said that if they're claiming not to use that missile, they're lying. Why? What a weird thing to lie about, that's so easily falsifiable.
- aeris 11y ago> It is very difficult to find the truth Well, not for me. I was monitoring the war at that time and I saw a report by Lifenews (pro-Kremlin media) that the rebels shot down Ukrainian AN-26. It wasn't actually that shocking since it wasn't the first time it happened. But then the word about the Boeing came down and, oh my, I've never seen people erase their tweets and videos so fast. But it's the internet, not goverment controlled media, can't really erase everything. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NsmVZmSBaEg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NsmVZmSBaEg