3 ms·
Does nobody remember the rebels declaring the airspace off-limits to all aircraft backed-up by the promise to shoot any offending aircraft down? Many are quick
by Alupis 11y ago
Does nobody remember the rebels declaring the airspace off-limits to all aircraft backed-up by the promise to shoot any offending aircraft down?
Many are quick to say the rebels should have known the difference between a military transport and a civilian plane - but shortly before the shootdown, the Ukraine military had been flying similar airplanes as troop transports - and with the unlikeliness of the airline being able to hear and respond to the rebels on radio (listening on different frequencies), it's easy to see how the sequence of events led to the downing of the airline.
We also should remember the rebel leader's announcement on twitter that they had just shot down a military transport - only to redact the comment immediately following the news stories that began to run.
In the end, this is an unfortunate tragedy -- but what sane airline knowingly flies over a self-declared war zone?
[1] http://www.cbsnews.com/news/pro-russian-ukrainian-rebel-leader-claims-shoot-down-of-malaysia-airlines-jet/ http://www.cbsnews.com/news/pro-russian-ukrainian-rebel-lead...
[2] http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/ukraine/10899657/Ukraine-rebels-shoot-down-plane-carrying-49.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/ukraine/108...
- dogma1138 11y agoIt doesn't matter what they've claimed they didn't had the authority to claim that in the 1st place. Now this doesn't say that common sense should not have been used and that the ICAO should not have released a direction to not fly over that area as it was an active war zone but that doesn't makes this any less of a crime. Accidents still happen but shooting down an airliner even in accident (which happened before) is still something that should be investigated, even for something as simple as compensation, and if this was not only in accident but also in either malice or negligence then there are sufficient grounds for criminal proceedings.
- tremon 11y agoNo incidents had occurred at 10km (30,000 ft) cruising altitude. The highest aircraft shot down until then was at 6.3km (below 20,000 ft), which is why the 10km cruising lanes were still deemed safe (a judgement error, according to today's report). The report also notes that in the previous days, over "61 airlines from 32 states" crossed over Ukraine without incident. On the day of the incident, 160 flights were recorded. So apparently, 61 airlines flew over a self-declared war zone. I'm sure some of them must have been considered sane.