4 ms·
I think it's great physicians are able to better diagnose disease and are able to see it when it manifests itself in populations where observation was missed or
by mc32 11y ago
I think it's great physicians are able to better diagnose disease and are able to see it when it manifests itself in populations where observation was missed or ignored for different reasons (bias, exposure, expectations, etc).
There needs to be better understanding so that boys don't get over diagnosed and women don't get underdiagnosed.
I find it unfortunate the author found it necessary to mention "white boys" throughout the article. What about ADHD in populations where there are few whites, say Asia, Africa, what has been observed there?
Do we need to inject everything with race and gender? I know it's important to lessen the effect of race and gender on things, but this over emphasis on race and gender on everything seems frivolous. Here I don't think it adds to the discussion.
- prawn 11y agoI find it unfortunate the author found it necessary to mention "white boys" throughout the article. I counted "white" once in the article, and repeated in the abstract/intro. The author was quoting someone who was interviewed.
- tsotha 11y agoIn general I agree, but in the case of a medical problem it's probably relevant. She's trying to point out not all subpopulations have been studied extensively.
- panglott 11y ago> What about ADHD in populations where there are few whites, say Asia, Africa, what has been observed there? This is a great question. ADHD diagnosis rates vary pretty significantly between the US and Europe (due to diagnostic and cultural differences), and Japan would be a great datapoint. It seems like ADHD prevalence is relatively understudied in Japan, different symptomatic behaviors are viewed as troubling, and there is a much more dim view of stimulant medication. But we don't need to inject race and gender into everything. It already came that way ;)