7 ms·
So an app which was correctly identifying parking tickets which were improperly issued, automating the completely legal dispute process, and making it easier fo
by Spivak 11y ago
So an app which was correctly identifying parking tickets which were improperly issued, automating the completely legal dispute process, and making it easier for people to pay their fines was blocked because...?
I really want to believe that there's another side to this that's more substantial than, "we're too lazy to issue citations correctly, we're banking on the average person not knowing that their ticket was improperly issued, and we're counting on people forgetting to pay to rack up those sweet, sweet late fees" but I can't think of anything. Can someone possibly shed some light on these cities' reasonings?
- eridius 11y agoProbably more along the lines of "we can't afford to lose this revenue, especially due to technicalities over the issuance of an otherwise-legitimate ticket".
- girvo 11y agoOur legal system and bureaucracies are built on technicalities. Do you think they wouldn't use a technicality to nail you to the wall for something? I've got little sympathy for an entity getting upset at it's own rules being used against it.
- branchan 11y agoJust like a speeding ticket, even if the cop wrote your name wrong, it doesn't mean that you are going to get away with it.
- dougmccune 11y agoMy wife has used Fixed in SF a couple times, so my data is purely anecdotal. By in my view Fixed deserves to be banned. In the two cases we used Fixed (both of which were valid tickets btw) they sent the exact same form letter disputing the ticket, even though the two tickets had nothing in common. From what I could tell the business model seemed to be 1) send entirely generic form letter at very little cost to dispute every single ticket, regardless of merit 2) assume that you can overwhelm the system and they'll just give up on some percentage of the tickets 3) profit. It didn't seem like anyone at Fixed was reviewing tickets or coming up with legit justifications for disputing the tickets. If you parked for 3 days in a handicapped space that blocked a hospital emergency room they would send in the same form letter to dispute the ticket. If Fixed was successful then by definition every ticket issued would result in a dispute. That's simply untenable for a city to deal with. To me it felt entirely like a "this is why we can't have nice things" scenario. Give legit people a way to dispute tickets and up springs a startup that takes advantage of the limitations of the system and fucks it up for everyone.
- forrestthewoods 11y agoExcellent! The system is obviously broken. And it's not self-correcting. So we must exploit the brokenness to force it to heal.
- mikeash 11y ago> If Fixed was successful then by definition every ticket issued would result in a dispute. That's simply untenable for a city to deal with. Heaven forfend the citizenry have the right to defend themselves before being punished by the state.
- jacobolus 11y agoThis is why I think cities should get out of the business of providing free street parking. Take away the street parking, remove parking requirements from residential/commercial development requirements, and let the price of land and market demand dictate how many parking lots get built and parking fees. Otherwise entitled drivers refuse to accept that city parking space is an inherently limited resource that must be shared, and protest any regulation as if unlimited free parking is some kind of basic human right.
- mikeash 11y agoWhen you take a step back and think about it, it is really weird how many public roads are built two lanes wider than they would otherwise need to be, simply so that people can park their cars on public land.
- Shivetya 11y agofor the most part I would have thought the idea was mostly to keep delivery and passenger services out of the traffic lanes
- mikeash 11y agoI'm sure this varies from one locale to another, but in my experience in various parts of the US, virtually all urban roads with extra width have it just for parking. Much of the time the parking is so full that there's no room for delivery vehicles and passenger dropoff/pickup to use anything but the travel lanes, and even when there is room they often can't be bothered. There are places where space is carved out just for loading and not parking, but it's not the common thing, especially in residential areas.
- 0xcde4c3db 11y agoA ticket is a legal document. Unless the pipeline involves sufficient human review, it's not that much of a stretch to construe the vendor as practicing law without a license.
- a3n 11y agoThink of parking and speed trap tickets as tax collection, and it becomes clear.