4 ms·
Just a point about "taking pictures without my permission" In public spaces there are few restrictions against this (ex. military zones). In private spaces th
by mc32 11y ago
Just a point about "taking pictures without my permission"
In public spaces there are few restrictions against this (ex. military zones). In private spaces this can be regulated by the organizer, I believe, but that prohibition must be posted. This is how the "street photography" gender of photography can exist.
Now, to be fair, there are regulations against commercial use of photos from "street photography" without permission. There you can sue for compensation if your likeness was used to advertise and sell (selling a book with street photographs does not require permission, as that is not "commercial use", that's to say, it's "art")
It becomes an issue if the photographer videographer follows you and thus engages in harassment (in some jurisdictions).
Remember that videographer who taunted people at an outdoor restaurant. They had little recourse against him.
- justin66 11y agoI don't think the author was implying that taking one's picture without permission in a public space is illegal, merely that it's rude or weird. Which it often is.
- dllthomas 11y agoSomething doesn't have to be illegal to be rude. As to norms, there is a big difference between someone appearing in a crowd shot or background, and someone being the sole focus of the picture.
- mc32 11y agoThe courts say otherwise see sole focus picture in case of Nussenzweig v. DiCorcia[1]. If it were not possible, we would not have "street photography" we would not have Robert Frank, Cartier-Bresson, Winogrand, Meier or Arbus. Picture in question[2] We also would not have documentary photography. Certainly it can feel rude to us, but the law allows it and moreover the feeling of rudeness comes more from believing we "own" our likelinesses in public spaces, which we do not. So, yes, I could feel intruded upon by a documentary or street photographer, no question, but at the same time, they have the right to take my picture, no question. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nussenzweig_v._DiCorcia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nussenzweig_v._DiCorcia [2]https://wmuphoto.wordpress.com/2014/02/07/nussenzweig-v-dicorcia/ https://wmuphoto.wordpress.com/2014/02/07/nussenzweig-v-dico... If you disagree with the position, post a link to law which states otherwise. There is lots of case law asserting the right of photographers to take pictures unimpeded in public spaces.
- dllthomas 11y agoI don't see your citations speaking to rudeness. Moreover, even if they did it is not generally the place of the courts to dictate what is and is not rude. I very much agree that this kind of photography is not illegal. In no way does that mean it is not rude. C.f. I can hurl a long stream of insults at you. Rude? Unquestionably. Legal? Also unquestionably. On those grounds you could rightly complain, choose not to associate with me, choose to avoid places I might go, tell others you find me to be a rude person. You could not enlist the government to fine or imprison me. What was being discussed here, before you brought legality into the picture, was actions like those on the former list.
- mc32 11y agoRudeness is one of those things that's very unique to the individual claimant and I think for art and expression in general, we tend to give the artist (in this case the photographer) lots of leeway. I'm sure lots of religious people would think my thoughts on religion are quite rude, but that does not and should not deter my art or anyone else's art depicting religion unfavorably. Basically, I don't want photography thrown under the bus on this one.
- tptacek 11y agoNobody is throwing photography under the bus. Please stop using a thread about sexual harassment as a coatrack to hang your concerns about photography on.
- mc32 11y agoI think people have misconceptions about photography. I.e. the photographer needs permission --they don't. If you want to go against sexual harassment do so, I have no objection. I do object to people thinking that photography is automatic harassment. It's not.
- bigiain 11y agoHow did we get from "unsolicited selfies with, or down-blouse shots of women at tech conferences" to "art"? The problem we're talking about is creeps, not photographers, no matter what the creeps claimed motivation is - it's blindingly obvious to almost everybody that there is a difference (and posts like yours are really hard not to read as defending/justifying creep's behaviour).