3 ms·
Surprisingly, there are very few studies on the actual effectiveness of bicycle helmets. Lots of times, articles will just say "X% of people that are injured ar
by paulddraper 11y ago
Surprisingly, there are very few studies on the actual effectiveness of bicycle helmets. Lots of times, articles will just say "X% of people that are injured aren't wearing a helmet". Which of course is next to worthless.
- roel_v 11y agoAnd most studies that have been done, are done by people from the medical field, who are at best only qualified to comment on a slight portion of the issue. Their conclusion is always 'if you fall sideways on a curb without a helmet, you'll be dead' (duh), but then the dangerous part is where they conclude 'so we need to wear helmets always, and make them compulsory'.
- Pxtl 11y agoThat argument could apply to pedestrians as well. We don't make Grandma wear a helmet the day she's issued a walker.
- DannoHung 11y agoThere are plenty of studies, the problem with them is that there are arguments made constantly that despite the efficacy of helmets in reducing the severity of head trauma, something about the helmets somehow makes them more dangerous. I think my favorite stupid argument though is that it increases the size of the rider's head, which increases the likelihood of ground collision in an accident. As though it's so easy to stop yourself from falling as long as there aren't two inches of material strapped on your noggin. The basic fact is that if you do have a head injury on a bike, a helmet is likely to reduce the severity of it. Everything else is an unquantifiable argument about human behavior.
- snogglethorpe 11y agoThe main thing is that it's not just a medical issue, so citing medical studies isn't sufficient. Even if wearing a helmet decreases your injuries 100% of the time (and there are a few counterexamples to that), if a helmet law causes more deaths overall, it's still a bad law. The main negative effect of helmet laws that I've seen cited is that they reduce the popularity of cycling as a transportation mode, and that can have extremely negative effects on public health (due to increased driving, reduced physical activity, and indirectly as a general damper on pro-cycling sentiment and infrastructure changes). [I think Australia's helmet law is one of the main examples people talk about.]
- prawn 11y agoYes, also that more cyclists means a greater awareness of them amongst drivers, which improves safety. Making helmets non-compulsory can make riding safer in that way, encouraging more people to ride.
- snogglethorpe 11y agoYup. "Safety in numbers" is definitely an important factor. In the end, it's far more important (in terms of safety, as well as for other social goals that cycling promotes) to get people on bikes than it is to micromanage the way they do it. It's worth nothing that helmet usage is extremely low in pretty much all the great cycling nations (Netherlands, Denmark, Japan, etc), all of which have cycling mode-share orders of magnitude greater than any place in the U.S. [In Japan it is becoming increasingly common to see very young kids wearing bicycle helmets, especially when they're seated on their parent's bike, but they seem to stop wearing them sometime in their grade-school years.]
- Frqy3 11y agoAnother interesting thing to study would be whether cyclists change their riding behaviour when required to wear a helmet. Similar to the effect on driving behaviour of mandatory wearing of car seatbelts.
- snogglethorpe 11y agoThis is indeed one of the main reasons that modern cycling advocates generally consider helmet laws a bad thing. Helmet laws make the general public less likely to cycle, and as many would then drive instead, thus have an overall negative effect on public health.