5 ms·
Last week I sat in a meeting with representatives from half a dozen startups attempting GenIV fission reactors, along with a public utility that's investing in
by DennisP 11y ago
Last week I sat in a meeting with representatives from half a dozen startups attempting GenIV fission reactors, along with a public utility that's investing in that type of work.
They said their main problem was the NRC. It has regulations designed for large light-water reactors. If you're attempting, say, a small modular molten-salt reactor, you have to pay several hundred million dollars up front for an extensive, detailed design and regulations to fit. Then the NRC makes one binary decision: if you're lucky they approve you, in which case all you have so far is a piece of paper that allows you to build something. If you're unlucky they deny and leave you with nothing.
Not surprisingly, it's hard to find investors in this environment. They said if we at least had a phased approach, so they can get some assurance for investors, it'd be an improvement. Even better would be a more flexible regime similar to Canada's.
- musesum 11y agoBill Gates is investing in LFTR, as per http://www.the-weinberg-foundation.org/2013/07/23/bill-gates-nuclear-company-explores-molten-salt-reactors-thorium/ http://www.the-weinberg-foundation.org/2013/07/23/bill-gates... They are tweaking the process. I wonder if that has anything to do with the NRC?
- toomuchtodo 11y agoI admit I'm someone who has asked the NRC to come up with shutdown plans for every existing commercial reactor, considering most are already unable to compete on cost with renewables. Disgustingly enough, the US taxpayer is going to be on the hook for cleanup costs for each and every one of these sites.
- DennisP 11y agoI think you'd be happy with the cleanup procedures for some of these newer reactors. For example, ThorCon and Terrestrial Energy use sealed units they can just ship back to the factory after a few years for decommissioning.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoCan those new reactors compete (on a per kwh basis) against solar and wind? Which are already at ~3.5 cents/kwh?
- DennisP 11y agoThere's a good chance it'd be cheaper than coal. Which is a better comparison, since they'd be dispatchable power. For wind and solar to be dispatchable they need to add overproduction and storage, which increases their cost significantly. In any case, if wind and solar outcompete nuclear on a level playing field, fine. The nuclear startups just want the opportunity to try.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoAs long as nuclear is willing to pay for their own insurance (and not backstopped by the federal government: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price%E2%80%93Anderson_Nuclear_Industries_Indemnity_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price%E2%80%93Anderson_Nuclear...) and pay for their waste disposal, may the best tech win.
- DennisP 11y agoGiven the inherent safety and drastically lower waste production of these reactors, I doubt that'll be a problem. Given your dedication to eliminating subsidies, I'm sure you'll be happy to remove those enjoyed by wind and solar while we're at it. Or maybe both of us should quit bickering, support each other's favorite technologies, and remember that it's fossil fuels destroying the climate, while benefiting from far larger subsidies than either nuclear or renewables have ever seen.
- pdkl95 11y agoFine, then why isn't coal being held to the same standard, which is what you're de facto choosing if you don't want nuclear power. The coal industry has an incredible amount of negative externalities, with the costs and damage largely ignored for most of their life. Fly as spills[1] are incredibly damaging, yet the coal industry still gets to store their waste in open air ponds that occasionally spill in to major rivers. Even in the areas where solar can be used, are you going make sure that industry pays (at least party in advance, for the same insurance) for not only their manufacturing costs, but also the cleanup and disposal of all those PV cells that necessarily would be distributed over a wide area? Are you also going make sure the wind and/or solar industry takes responsibility for all of the batteries t hat would be necessary to use their schemes? When you're talking keeping a national grid active on variable sources of power like wind or solar, those battery costs will easily surpass the generation costs. Since we are talking about cheap batteries that can supply decent amounts of current, that means lead acid[2]. Do you really want to distribute that much lead? Did you include the costs of the insurance to clean that up, too, including enforcement to make sure the lead doesn't simply end up in the landfill (or worse)? The only expensive part about nuclear is the initial development cost. Running the plant isn't particularly expensive, and the fuel and waste costs are practically nothing and those costs are isolated to only a few locations. Everybody else tends to get away with socializing their long-term cleanup and disaster costs. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kingston_Fossil_Plant_coal_fly_ash_slurry_spill https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kingston_Fossil_Plant_coal_fly... [2] future technologies could change that, but until we can buy it commercially its just vaporware and wishful thinking
- _delirium 11y agoPossibly a naive question: If Canada has a more flexible regulatory regime, couldn't one solution be to just base the nuclear R&D startups in Canada?
- DennisP 11y agoThere's a lot of capital and expertise in the U.S. Most of the companies hope they can stay here. But Terrestrial Energy is Canadian, and Terrapower is a U.S. company that just signed a deal to build their prototype in China, which is aggressively developing advanced nuclear.
- rgbrenner 11y agoWhy do you think Canada hasn't built a nuclear power reactor in 30 years? [0] If Canada's system is better, then there must be another problem here that's shared with the US and Canada. Since neither is actively expanding nuclear power. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_Canada#Current_power_reactors https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_Canada#Curren...
- DennisP 11y agoTerrestrial Energy is developing a molten salt reactor in Canada. Meanwhile Terrapower is building their prototype in China, which is developing half a dozen advanced reactor types and currently building a couple dozen conventional reactors.
- rgbrenner 11y agoHmm... one project that's currently in the conceptual design phase, and won't start preparing blueprints until late 2016 (if everything goes as planned). One exception is hardly a vibrant industry that the US needs to copy.
- api_or_ipa 11y agoCanada also has almost no coal fired plants in most of its provinces. Hydro is king here with >75% of the country being served. There's no pressing need to invest heavily in nuclear reactors at the moment in Canada.
- caf 11y agoAll this tells us is that large scale power generation, and in particular nuclear generation, is a highly capital-intensive business that probably makes it unsuitable for a startup to tackle.
- DennisP 11y agoTo the extent that the capital expense is a function of inefficient regulation, I'm not convinced we should just accept it as a natural law. Many of these reactors are small-scale designs, well within the range of funded startups. In fact, YCombinator invested in a nuclear fission startup: http://blog.samaltman.com/energy http://blog.samaltman.com/energy