2 ms·
If you just want a position that gives the people around them those two benefits—without assuming where the position would sit on the org chart—then you will no
by derefr 11y ago
If you just want a position that gives the people around them those two benefits—without assuming where the position would sit on the org chart—then you will notice there exist a lot of other, similar jobs, that do not also possess the assumption of "supervising" and "being responsible for" the output of the people around them.
For example, what you're describing fits closely to the idea of a shared administrative assistant. Or a talent agent. Or a sports coach (or "team manager", which is a misnomer.) Or a diplomatic envoy.
None of these people are the boss of the people they work with; they assist the people they work with in getting things done. They do not hire or fire the people they work with; they are not blamed for the incompetence of the people they work with; and they have no incentive to play politics with the lives of the people they work with for the sake of a promotion. Their job is purely to help their team work, and to deflect things that prevent work.
Personally, I think we could use way more of these types of "pure interfacer" people in companies; and, in so having them, the need for "managers" would decline sharply. There'd still be some managers—people whose job is to take ultimate responsibility for the output of a group, and who are thus incentivized to direct and reorganize that group. But, with the jobs of keeping the team protected and glued-together taken care of, the active role of "manager" would be reduced enough that they could either be scaled across greater numbers of people, or could be a "manager" for their own group as an accessory role to their regular job.
- sokoloff 11y agoSend your shared administrative assistant (or talent agent, or sports coach) in to argue for a technical point with another team's manager. Or send them in to the CIO to argue for budget or to have a features vs schedule/technical debt discussion. A few rounds of that and you may very well wish for a technical manager back.
- copsarebastards 11y agoDysfunction on other teams doesn't mean we need managers, it means we need to fix the dysfunction.