4 ms·
No-one expects companies to pay the full whack of tax. But Facebook is taking the piss. They need to be a bit careful, because they risk causing much tighter
by DanBC 11y ago
No-one expects companies to pay the full whack of tax. But Facebook is taking the piss. They need to be a bit careful, because they risk causing much tighter tax regulation in EU.
Citizens don't see this behaviour and think "well done, got one over on the government". Most citizens are infuriated by this scumbag behaviour.
And before anyone says "they're just obeying the law" -- we don't know that. They're clearly not evading tax, just aggressively avoiding it, but some tax avoidance schemes haven't been tested in courts yet.
- tragic 11y ago> They need to be a bit careful, because they risk causing much tighter tax regulation in EU. Don't think they've got much to worry about as long as Juncker's in charge of the commission at least. There will be huffing and puffing, but no blowing the house down.
- exDM69 11y agoSome background: Jean-Claude Juncker, the current President of the European Commission has served as the prime minister and financial minister of Luxembourg. During his regime, they effectively turned Luxembourg into a tax haven for international corporations, allowing them to transfer "license fees" of trademarks, copyrights and other immaterial rights with effectively a flat fee (ie. no taxes paid, just a one time not-a-bribe fee paid to the tax authorities of Luxembourg). The primary export product of Luxembourg is banking and financial services. They also have some steel production and industry, but effectively without their shenanigans on tax evasion, the country would be bankrupt. A lot of this has recently come into daylight in the LuxLeaks [0] scandal. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luxembourg_Leaks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luxembourg_Leaks
- kauffj 11y agoI'm a citizen and I think that. Perhaps you describe most citizens, but certainly not all.
- kybernetyk 11y agoI run my own business here in Germany and I'm all for getting every penny out of every tax loophole possible. But then in my peer group I'm the only one who thinks that way. Most people would rather want everyone else to be as highly taxed as themselves than lower taxes overall it seems.
- grp 11y agoTax as money needs to move otherwise it has no value. If you want to pay the least possible taxes, don't be surprised if your government will do its best to not support you, to not help you, to not listen to you... "The less you pay, the less you'll get paid. The more you pay, the more you'll get paid."
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- bonaldi 11y ago> When people say they want higher taxes, they are almost always talking about higher taxes for everybody else than themselves. No, they generally mean for everybody, in a fairly distributed way. Of course nobody is going to pay extra if they think that thereby they're subsidising a rich person who knowingly underpays.
- div 11y agoI think there's a lot more grey here than you're making out. I'm all for minimising taxes within the legal framework, but that does not mean I agree with all the legal details. In this particular case, there is something wrong with how large multinationals are able to avoid paying any taxes at all, it's a major problem in my country, Belgium, as well. I don't agree with your last statement that people would rather want everyone else to be equally highly taxed than lower taxes overall. I think people just want their tax legislation to be _fair_, and while that is definitely a fungible concept, these large multinationals are crossing the line for the majority of people.
- TomGullen 11y ago
- jkahn 11y agoThey need to be a bit careful, because they risk causing much tighter tax regulation in EU. I think this is going to happen anyway, as it's not just Facebook. Governments see it as a reduction in tax, and it's politically safe for a Government to do without getting voted out.
- squiggy22 11y ago'some tax avoidance schemes haven't been tested in courts yet' Probably because the law isn't either fit for purpose, or clear enough for someone to litigate. As far as I'm concerned, if they (are obeying the law) and getting away with it, then articles like these only expose that the government are the incompetent ones.
- DanBC 11y ago> Probably because the law isn't either fit for purpose, or clear enough for someone to litigate. No UK tax authorities use courts as a measure of last resort. They persuade companies to pay unpaid taxes. See, eg, Vodafone who came to a deal. These bills were billions of pounds. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/economics/9330102/HMRC-cleared-of-sweetheart-tax-deals-for-business.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/economics/9330102/HMRC-cl... Although see also this: http://www.theguardian.com/money/2011/dec/06/hmrc-tax-deal-vodafone http://www.theguardian.com/money/2011/dec/06/hmrc-tax-deal-v... etc. It's very expensive to sue these massive companies. It's probably a good thing that deals are made to reclaim some of the tax.
- chrisseaton 11y ago> some tax avoidance schemes haven't been tested in courts yet This is saying that they're guilty until proven in compliance. I'm sure you do lots of things every day that haven't been tested in court yet.
- paulojreis 11y ago> No-one expects companies to pay the full whack of tax. I do.
- rconti 11y agoIt depends on what is meant by "the full whack of tax". If your tax bracket is 30%, nobody expects you to pay 30% of your income in taxes. No, that's the top marginal rate, and you have deductions, and so on. This could charitably be put in the same realm -- they're getting all of their loopholes that they're dubiously entitled to. It's sort of like if a speeding ticket costs $200. But you know you can get away with speeding most of the time. If suddenly we had a perfectly-enforced system where you paid $200 every time you exceeded the speed limit, it wouldn't seem 'fair' even though it is, strictly speaking, 'fair'. However, to cost the average person the same amount, the amount per offense should really go down if enforcement is perfect. In the same way, the US corporate tax rate is insanely high, but the actual amount major corporations pay is insanely low.
- amirmc 11y ago> "No-one expects companies to pay the full whack of tax." Why? I don't understand why this is considered acceptable. I'm expected to pay the full whack of tax (income, VAT, etc), but somehow it's taken as given that corporations will pay 'less than they're supposed to'. How can we fix anything if this is the prevailing attitude?
- Cakez0r 11y agoIn this case, Facebook did pay the full whack of tax. The article implies they avoided paying corporation tax by paying out large bonuses, causing them to have been operating at a loss (on paper). If that is the case, then I don't think that's such a bad thing. All of their employees will still pay tax on their bonuses, so it's not like the tax payer is being completely robbed. At least their workers are getting a cut of the profit, rather than having it all go to Facebook's coffers and the government (in the form of corporation tax).
- RegW 11y ago> Why? ... because we don't call out those that do, praise them and give them our custom.
- mootothemax 11y ago>But Facebook is taking the piss. Exactly, they take it from "mild annoyance about the state of the world" through to full-on rage. I'd like to know whether - annoyingly - even if they knowingly bought about huge tax reform, whether the short terms gains of doing this now would still make it worthwhile. Sadly, I can't see any way that it's not worth abusing whenever possible.