3 ms·
> Its most recent Companies House filing shows the company as making a pre-tax loss of £28.5m last year, but the firm also paid its 362 UK staff a total of £35.
by maccard 11y ago
> Its most recent Companies House filing shows the company as making a pre-tax loss of £28.5m last year, but the firm also paid its 362 UK staff a total of £35.4m in share bonuses.
So £35m was distributed as income towards the employees. This means the employees are paid extra, have more money to contribute and spend locally, and have paid the correct income taxes on the bonuses. How is this a bad thing?
- dazc 11y agoHow is this a bad thing? Because the amount of corporation tax paid makes a better headline?
- crdoconnor 11y agoAh, trickle down economics!
- DanBC 11y agoFacebook reaps the rewards of the UK infrastructure. Facebook should behave as a responsible citizen and help fund that infrastructure. If they don't want to behave like responsible citizens they can fuck off.
- baddox 11y agoAs the parent commenter said, they are helping fund infrastructure by paying their employees a lot of money, a portion of which is taxed.
- retube 11y agoYeah but bonuses will be taxed at 50%. Corp tax is 22% so it's better they pay their staff more and report less profit.
- DanBC 11y agoI need to apologise to Facebook then. Sorry, Facebook. EDIT: This looks like snark, but it's not. If I'm wrong I'm sorry.
- maccard 11y ago> Facebook reaps the rewards of the UK infrastructure. Facebook should behave as a responsible citizen and help fund that infrastructure. Paying their employees an extra £96,000 (on average) per head isn't them being responsible? The money is being paid to UK employees who will (in theory) spend it in the UK. I'd have a problem if they did what Apple are doing in the US - sitting on wads of cash because it's too expensive to bring it back into the states, but this is a win for everyone. The money is redistributed back to the employees, and taxed appropriately, how is that a problem?
- throwaway2048 11y agoits only responsible in the sense that they have to pay the caliber of tallent they want to attract that much. Its not like facebook is paying them more out of the goodness of their own hearts. Also you can make the arguement that its the employees themselves paying these taxes, not facebook.
- vidarh 11y agoPeople are assuming that the numbers reported are the result of using loopholes and that the reported loss does not accurately reflect how much money they make in the UK.. The reason the share bonuses are of some interest is that it seems odd to most people if they give away share bonuses worth 35.4m if they are genuinely losing that much money on the UK market. Yes, it's possible, but the seemingly more likely explanation is that Facebook like most other large international companies are routing their revenue from the UK market through a more tax efficient separate corporate structure.
- youngtaff 11y agoCan't comment on the FB case but most share schemes are structured so the employee pays the minimum (if any) tax on the shares - typically by holding them for a number of years