4 ms·
Do persecuted non-nerds have the right to (in any way) cordon off computer science as a refuge free from nerdiness? Because that's what articles like these seem
by makomk 11y ago
Do persecuted non-nerds have the right to (in any way) cordon off computer science as a refuge free from nerdiness? Because that's what articles like these seem to be suggesting we'd need to do, by saying that nerd social cues like Star Wars and geeky T-shirts are excluding women.
- tptacek 11y agoI think that's an overwrought reading of the article, for two reasons: first, the article isn't prescriptive about Star Wars, and second, it's reporting simple facts; whether you feel comfortable about it or not, nerd culture's coupling with software development does alienate potential entrants to the field. But let's not bother deploying dueling readings from the article, and instead see how much you and I actually disagree: I do not in fact think it's reasonable to suggest that individual software developers should avoid nerd signifiers to avoid alienating people. I feel safe presuming we agree about that. Do you feel like it's reasonable for companies to avoid aggressive identification with nerd culture? To not ask candidates what their favorite Star Wars movie is, or to try to balance out outings and fringe benefits so they only appeal to sci-fi fandom?
- blackguardx 11y agoDo companies do that? I've never experienced any embrace of "nerd culture" at any place I've worked.
- tptacek 11y agoSure! Here's an example I'll ruefully draw from the last company I helped manage: all-hands offsites at local breweries.
- rewqfdsa 11y agoI don't understand the connection between beer and nerd culture --- or masculine culture, actually, since plenty of women I know love beer.
- tptacek 11y agoI wasn't trying to be gender-specific with my example, just showing how something you can do as a manager to build culture can exclude and alienate people. (Though: I do think beer drinking trends masculine.)
- rewqfdsa 11y agoRight: nobody bonds over building shareholder value. They bond over shared interests. But there are no _universal_ interests, so team-building is a quandary. I think the best you can do is rotate events and make sure most people are interested most of the time. Maybe after the beer offsite, you can visit a winery, or a famous local coffee house, and then a museum.
- test1235 11y agoI think the closest universal interest for me has been music. I don't really drink and I don't really talking to drinkers when I'm sober but I always love going out to gigs with pretty much anyone. It's not exactly the most interactive activity when you can't talk for 80% of the time, but it's still enjoyable and sociable.
- ams6110 11y agoIt's really hard to win at this. Whatever you do as a culture or team building exercise is going to either offend or just be uncomfortable to some subset of employees, unless it's so bland as to be boring for everyone.
- JesperRavn 11y agoIt seems like a borderline example. I feel that the "brogrammer" stereotype was invented up mainly because the nerd stereotype was too sympathetic. I'm genuinely curious if there are examples of the kind of stereotypes in the article being promoted right now by tech companies. As an aside, these sorts of critiques of mainstream/White culture are somewhat contradictory in that they criticize any specific cultural identity as being exclusive and insular, and yet whenever this is lacking, they point to how boring mainstream/White culture is. Even lack of crime can be turned into evidence of boringness. For example, for every article on the negative effect of nerd culture on diversity, there is an article complaining about the decline of nerd culture and the rise of corporatism. The latter tend to be highly revisionist and pretend that the tech industry was founded by LSD taking hippies who coded inside isolation tanks. But the contradiction is still stark.
- blackguardx 11y agoI'm a hardware engineer. Most hardware companies are too tight fisted to have offsites (making physical things is expensive). The few that I've been on have been very tame because the last thing management wants is an offended employee. Having an offsite at a brewery is kinda shitty because not everyone likes to drink. Did anyone try to suggest another venue?
- tptacek 11y agoYes, or at least, the concern was raised (among the small minority of people who weren't excited about going to Three Floyds). It's not, like, a management decision I'm super duper proud of.
- lightcatcher 11y agoPalantir is named after an item in Lord of the Rings. From what I've heard from friends working there, they have an internal conference called HobbitCon, meetings rooms named after LotR, and refer to their office as "the shire".