3 ms·
A couple of quibbles with the article: >While progress is swift, no one has any realistic estimate of how long it will take to arrive at brain-size connectomes
by tim333 11y ago
A couple of quibbles with the article:
>While progress is swift, no one has any realistic estimate of how long it will take to arrive at brain-size connectomes. (My wild guess: centuries.)
It's not so hard to estimate. Just extrapolate progress on scanning, computing etc. About 2050 plus or minus a couple of decades. We had a 20um scan in 2013 and you'd probably want to get that down to 20nm for a connectome so if you assume resolution doubling every couple of years that would be about 2035.
(2013 scan: http://io9.com/see-the-first-ultra-high-resolution-3d-scan-of-the-ent-514395280 http://io9.com/see-the-first-ultra-high-resolution-3d-scan-o...
Images showing neural connections: http://book.bionumbers.org/how-big-is-a-synapse/ http://book.bionumbers.org/how-big-is-a-synapse/)
Of course as the article points out a connectome misses a lot of chemical detail.
>It will almost certainly be a very long time before we can hope to preserve a brain in sufficient detail and for sufficient time that some civilization much farther in the future, perhaps thousands or even millions of years from now, might have the technological capacity to “upload” and recreate that individual’s mind.
Or quite possibly we can do it just now for $30k or so by sticking the body in liquid nitrogen. (http://www.cryonics.org/membership/ http://www.cryonics.org/membership/ ). Maybe that won't work but maybe it will.
- epistasis 11y agoA couple of quibbles with this: microscopy technology doesn't advance that quickly, certainly not doubling every few years. A new, entirely different technology is far more likely than creeping improvements, as in semiconductors. However, these are far harder to predict.
- tim333 11y agoI was thinking about the details. We have good enough microscopes already resolution wise but to cut up a brain fine enough and picture it with existing electron microscopes would take ages, probably centuries with current tech so it needs a speed improvement more than anything. Also a 20nm scan could produce an awful lot of data ~ a billion TB which could be an issue even allowing for Moores law. Still there's quite a lot of research money going it to this stuff.