3 ms·
I don't buy the argument that automation breaks capitalism. The predominant cost of almost everything is labor. As things become automated, costs go down. Food
by AnthonyMouse 11y ago
I don't buy the argument that automation breaks capitalism. The predominant cost of almost everything is labor. As things become automated, costs go down. Food costs less, housing construction costs less, local production costs less so demand for fuel is reduced, mining and recycling cost less so raw materials cost less, etc.
The reduction in the amount of work available is proportional to the reduction in the cost of everything, so the wages from fewer hours of working buy more stuff. Everything is fine until we literally get to zero, which may not even be possible, and if it is then we're living in Star Trek fantasy land where everything is free and anyone can just press a button to get whatever they want.
The only real trouble is unemployment as a result of demand for labor not matching the skillset of the labor pool, but solving that is hardly rocket science. Large grants for education (and food and housing for students). Send everybody back to school until they're qualified to do the jobs that still exist.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoEven if things in fact balance out in the way you described, the problem is that it takes too long. The market has intertia. Sending everyone to school for retraining could be good idea if not for the fact that those people who have years of training ahead of them need food now. Since they're unemployed, they won't have money to buy it and they will die a horrible death. Unless, of course, you propose for the public to feed them through the process, at which point we've got basic income, so we may as well get rid of the retraining part entirely.
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> Unless, of course, you propose for the public to feed them through the process, at which point we've got basic income, so we may as well get rid of the retraining part entirely. Why are we getting rid of the retraining part? We still need people to be qualified to do those jobs. Obviously we don't need to separately subsidize food and shelter specifically for students if we have a basic income, and a basic income is a Good Idea. But it isn't Not Capitalism. By all accounts it's more aligned with capitalism than the ridiculous system of "subsidies for everything but not if you get a[nother] job" that we have now.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoI agree. I always thought of Basic Income as a first step towards switching away from capitalism, but even a form that would replace current ubercomplicated welfare system while leaving rest of the economy intact would be a really good idea and a step towards a better future.