6 ms·
~50% of undergrads at Stanford are female. ~30% of new Stanford computer science majors are female.
by rahimnathwani 11y ago
~50% of undergrads at Stanford are female. ~30% of new Stanford computer science majors are female.
- ngoel36 11y agoOk, so women still choose CS at a smaller proportion than men do...that's alright for now. What's awesome is that women are now choosing CS more than any other major, and Stanford is providing them an environment where it's cool to do so. That's incredible.
- Asbostos 11y agoIs that really awesome, or is is bad news for say engineering or physics which could be losing those same women and are traditionally even more male dominated than computer science is? If those subjects are losing as many women, then this is actually bad news for gender same-number-ness.
- richmarr 11y agoGood question. There's been a significant change (at least from my perspective) in the awareness of inequitable treatment of women in tech in the last few years, and I'd like to think that's one of the contributing factors to this change. If true, that means that the previous levels of entry into other subjects were (in part) due to students rejection of CS. If CS loses its repulsion factor then that brings everyone's metrics back to neutral and will make other problems clearer. Much as I hate to wheel out the trite "everything is a market" trope, the more subjects like physics will have to work to improve the treatment of women in science (although my perception is that it's not as bad as tech)... and maybe (one day) the way science is run to make it a more appealing career. I was a physics undergrad and chose to ditch science as a career at my first opportunity. A majority of the people who stayed on to do an MSc or PhD did so only because it would buy them a well payed role at a bank, or PWC, or Anderson (sorry, "Accenture"). It's a shitty career, fighting for funding or tenure, full of victorian-era bullshit. The sooner physics (for one) cleans house the better.
- 001sky 11y agoIn all fairness, this is likely a structural data anomaly. ie, it is driven by the number of majors at the school, and their level of abstraction. Here are some historical data points. Notice the arbitary abstraction of, eg Bio Sciences Human Biology 1955 1. History 2. Economics 3. Psychology 4. Political Science 5. Bio Sciences 1965 1. History 2. Political Science 3. English 4. Psychology 5. Economics 1975 1. Psychology 2. Bio Sciences 3. Economics 4. History 5. English 1985 1. Economics 2. Human Biology 3. Bio Sciences 4. Electrical Engr 5. English 1995 1. Bio Sciences 2. Human Biology 3. Economics 4. Psychology 5. English and now we look at 2010 (from quora) Biological Sciences (1.32%) but Human Biology (12.58%) Biology (5.74%) =~20% of Standford majors in 2010 are "biology majors" in plain language usage. Based on data on Bachelor's Degrees conferred in the 2009-2010 school year[1], the top majors are: Human Biology (12.58%) Economics (8.10%) International Relations (6.20%) Biology (5.74%) Computer Science (4.94%) Engineering (4.71%) Psychology (4.54%) Political Science (4.25%) English (3.96%) History (3.62%) Management Science and Engineering (3.39%) Mechanical Engineering (3.10%) Science, Technology, and Society (2.30%) Communication (2.18%) Electrical Engineering (2.07%) Mathematics (2.01%) Earth Systems (1.84%) Physics (1.84%) Sociology (1.49%) Biological Sciences (1.32%)*
- eitally 11y agoI suspect that differentiation would make more sense if they replaced "human biology" with "pre-med". I graduated from UVA In '99 and the biggest majors by far were psychology, sociology, history and economics, possibly in that order, but definitely each having ~500 graduates (out of a class of perhaps 2800-3000). I think the entire engineering school only graduated about 300-400 people each year (at that time). The current enrollment seems to match Stanford's stats, interestingly: http://www.seas.virginia.edu/about/facts/ http://www.seas.virginia.edu/about/facts/
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- adamwk 11y agoThey call it Simpson's Paradox https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simpson%27s_paradox https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simpson%27s_paradox
- colah3 11y agoI don't think this is really a case of Simpson's paradox. What we're seeing is that female students at Stanford are less concentrated on a single major than the male ones. As a result, their top pick isn't as high as the male top pick. I'd guess that the distribution of female majors is higher entropy than the male one. Simpson's paradox would be if there was some second confounding variable that corelated to gender which was causing these results. There might be, but I'm not seeing it.
- natmaster 11y agoI'm genuinely curious why I haven't seen any uproar about the numerous majors where men are in minority.
- reagency 11y agoBecause men haven't found gender related hostility or exclusion from high paying jobs in those majors.
- yareally 11y ago> Because men haven't found gender related hostility or exclusion from high paying jobs in those majors. Men do face discrimination in nursing. However, men are still paid more on average than female nurses[1]. Make of that what you will. The thing I find most striking is that before the 20th century, most nurses were men and in the early days of computing there was a much higher number of women in the field. [1] http://medcitynews.com/2015/03/male-nurses-earn-maybe-gender-discrimination-maybe/ http://medcitynews.com/2015/03/male-nurses-earn-maybe-gender... https://www.reddit.com/r/nursing/comments/1l1k75/any_male_nurses_experience_discrimination/ https://www.reddit.com/r/nursing/comments/1l1k75/any_male_nu... http://www.jacksonvilleu.com/resources/career/men-in-nursing/ http://www.jacksonvilleu.com/resources/career/men-in-nursing... http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21272837 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21272837
- sliverstorm 11y agoSo more than 50% of Stanford undergrads are CS? Shit. Does that not sound like aa glut?
- coyotebush 11y agoNo, those two statistics alone don't say anything about the total number of CS majors. Per the article, CS represents ~20% (of students with declared majors).
- 001sky 11y agoCS is 214 of an estimated 3500 female student body. That still seems exceptionally low. Posted this upthread but in 2010 20% of the student body was in Biology (once topical sub-specialties were aggregated). 20% of ~3500 would be closer to `700, which is 3.3x the number of declared comp sci students. Or maybe my math is wrong? I'm more interested in the actual knowledge being put in and attention being paid out than a critique of the degree naming conventions.
- sliverstorm 11y agoThanks, I got the numbers twisted in my head.
- Jtsummers 11y agoAnd if it were true, it doesn't necessarily mean it's a glut. CS is, to some extent, the new mechanical or electrical engineering. ME and EE are very broad degree programs, with students coming out of the same university with totally different specializations. They may have only taken 50% of their courses in common with each other. CS is (or depending on the school, is going) in that same vein.
- ngoel36 11y agoNo. Very little of a CS degree is "coding" - CS is so much more than that. It's even beyond "engineering". A proper CS degree teaches you how to think, how to solve insanely hard problems, and how to do so with a team of other smart people - often with different personalities. What separates CS from other degrees is that it does filter out those without the horsepower or fortitude on both the quant side (algorithms) and the creative side (systems, architecture). That means, that even if the SV bubble crashes, CS majors are the best equipped to handle whatever career is hot next - any hiring manager at Goldman, McKinsey, or F500 company X will tell you the same.