3 ms·
I don't think the heading is misleading or editorialized, just abbreviated. DNA is just a chemical. The headline is referring (in an abbreviated way) to the pro
by skybrian 11y ago
I don't think the heading is misleading or editorialized, just abbreviated. DNA is just a chemical. The headline is referring (in an abbreviated way) to the process of DNA testing. Analyzing the results is part of the process. If the analysis is wrong, the results are wrong.
- striking 11y agoIn my view, it implies that DNA as evidence is entirely not useful, and as DNA doesn't change, DNA will never be useful as evidence. However, since DNA analysis techniques are mutable, it is possible for DNA analysis to be useful, as long as it is used correctly. I believe there is a difference.
- sampo 11y agoMaybe "math is fallible" would have been a better title. Not because math itself is fallible, but because they used math wrong.
- pjtr 11y agoHow about "labs are fallible"? I think the point is, while forensic "science" are still using lie detectors and other very questionable techniques that just can not work reliably, it's a bit strange to paint DNA itself as fallible. DNA can work, if the lab is competent. Lie detectors and other voodoo can not.