11 ms·
Why police could seize a college student's life savings without charging him
- Mithaldu 11y agoI still don't understand why this kind of thing has not yet led to violence. Edit: > Originally, it was designed for situations in which the court would not have jurisdiction over the person, so it's an action on the property itself. Oh, interesting. So it is a bug in the law itself that nobody has any interest in fixing; but people who've already been robbed at gunpoint.
- csense 11y agoBecause the government and businesses have slowly but surely been eroding the role of cash in our lives. Most people use checks or credit cards for big purchases. Most people are paid by check, and the exceptions are usually near minimum wage. Nobody does big transactions in cash anymore -- even if you want to pay tens or hundreds of thousands in cash for a car, a house, or college tuition, if you show up with a briefcase full of cash, then your counterparty will tell you to put it in a bank and come back with a check because they're not set up to handle cash on their end. Government policies are designed to encourage inflation, yet the government stopped printing $500 and larger bills in 1945 and has never continued them. Most of the people who were old enough to remember the Great Depression and hoarded cash throughout their lives because of their experiences are old enough to be dead or in an old folks' home, and their hoards of cash have already been deposited in the banking system by their families. Living through the Depression hasn't been a "mainstream" experience for many decades, and the actions of those who did have been dismissed as "silly, irrational things that old people do." Basically it's become so abnormal to have large amounts of cash that a lot of people agree with the government -- "if you're using a lot of cash, that's so abnormal, you must be involved in something illegal." It's so abnormal it activates our tribal instincts which cause us to de-humanize -- "That's not something that I would do, or anyone I know would do" -- it's much easier to accept the demonization of people who use cash. Of course, this is just how the government and big business wants things to work -- all those bank deposits and credit cards are much easier to track. Think about all the junk mail you get based on your credit rating -- the marketing departments in those companies love the amount of information you're giving away about your finances.
- 1971genocide 11y agoI agree with your conclusion - but your premise of conspiracy is wrong. Using virtual Money is obviously much better than paper money. The difference is should it be centralized or de-centralized and anonymous ? The paradoxical economic problem with decentralized money is that the govt has no control over it. Which means during bad time its going to be very difficult for the govt to enact changes. We learnt it the hard way During the great depression when money was pegged to gold and the govt was unable to use inflation to restart the economy. Its a deep economical problem for which there is no known theoretical solution. Is it possible to have a decentralized monetary system that can also be controlled by a representive govt ?
- DamnYuppie 11y agoUnfortunately it is much easier for governments to confiscate it when it is digital and centralized.
- kaybe 11y agoAnd much easier to collect data on people's money-spending habits.
- jMyles 11y ago> The paradoxical economic problem with decentralized money is that the govt has no control over it. This is a not a paradox nor even a contradiction; indeed to advocates of many decentralized currency solutions, this is the killer feature. > Which means during bad time its going to be very difficult for the govt to enact changes. We learnt it the hard way During the great depression when money was pegged to gold and the govt was unable to use inflation to restart the economy. Of course you realize that this narrative does not enjoy consensus.
- jimrandomh 11y agoThe grandparent poster never used the word conspiracy, nor alleged one.
- selimthegrim 11y ago
- ipsin 11y agoIt this began with a ticket agent (who generally gets a cut) and a "drug-sniffing" dog. Police dogs are magical beasts -- you just point the dog at the thing you want searched and wait for it to "signal" that it's found something. I really wish that the Supreme Court had had the chance to review the accuracy of drug dogs in their case this year (Rodriguez v. US). How many times can a dog signal a false positive before you recognize that the drug dog is trying to please its handler? The police have no incentive to count.
- UnoriginalGuy 11y agoIt wasn't a false positive, he admits himself that he smoked weed on the way to the airport. That's really not the point of the article however.
- ipsin 11y agoMy point is that it can still be a false positive, even though "detecting weed" and "using weed" both occurred. The dog "alerted" for drugs, but the dog can't testify as to why -- because it actually smelled drugs or because it sensed its handler wanted it to. http://www.reviewjournal.com/news/crime-courts/legal-challenge-questions-reliability-police-dogs http://www.reviewjournal.com/news/crime-courts/legal-challen...
- UnoriginalGuy 11y agoSo just to be clear: He said he used drugs, a gate agent smelled drugs, the cops smelled drugs, and you just want to argue that if a dog also smelled drugs that that dog is unreliable even though the arrested party says the dog was correct..? I just don't understand what point you're even trying to make. Just seems like you want to talk/criticise drug-dog evidence even though it has no relation to this case at all. If the guy arrested and whose money was taken says he used drugs right before arriving at the airport I, for one, believe him. He has more to lose by saying that than he does by lying about it.
- 11y ago
- hoffspot 11y agoI'm not saying the police are right, the whole seizure thing is ridiculous, but this story is so shady. You have 11 grand in cash and want to move it from A to B. The obvious and safe way is to deposit it in a bank and get a cashier's check or do an ACH transfer. Who in their right mind would carry it with them or even worse, put it in a checked bag that airlines notoriously lose? The point of the story is valid, but the example is ridiculous. Sounds like someone wanted an untraceable 11 grand. Shady.
- braythwayt 11y agoAnd therein lies the crux of the problem with these things being subject to zero checks or balances and such a low standard of proof. People’s stories sound shady all the time. In Canada, in my lifetime, there have been four different men whom everyone was certain had murdered people, and it turned out that they were innocent. In many cases, people are so sure that shady people are guilty, they make up testimony to make sure the bad guy goes to jail. This is why we need incredibly high standards for convicting someone of a crime. And we still get it wrong. So when someone “seems shady...” I stop far short of assuming that they are shady. And even if they are shady, I stop far short of thinking that the police, with the incredibly asymmetric power relationship, should be at liberty to enrich themselves based on someone seeming to be shady.
- travjones 11y agoWow. Great response man. Thanks.
- afandian 11y agoWho in their right mind would do thing X where thing X is risky because of an out-of-control state agency. Someone who is blissfully unaware of how out of control the state agency is, probably.
- monochromatic 11y agoHe said it was risky because airlines lose bags. He's right--doing that is insane.
- pearjuice 11y agoThe main reason why the War on Drugs is so popular in police departments.
- hmottestad 11y agoNow I'm not sure if Norway has similar laws, but I haven't heard of any. However, watching John Oliver talk about how ridiculous the civil forfeiture laws are in the US just makes me want to laugh so much. I know of all the great things happening in the US, and I'm not calling you a bad country. But it's so hard not to categorise you together with North Korea, China and the United Arab Emirates with how trigger happy your police are, how easy it is for them to steal from the population. How terribly you treat your sick and poor, and how fascinated you seem to be with groping people at the airport.
- nicarus1984 11y agoTo group the US in with the likes of N. Korea and China is dishonest and inaccurate. If the US were run by either of those governments, you would not have Jon Oliver, Washington Post, etc. exposing and criticizing the very issues you mention.
- afandian 11y agoFree speech is one facet of analysis. It's an important one, but doesn't invalidate the others.
- nicarus1984 11y agoNo one is claiming that it invalidates the others.
- albedoa 11y agoYou accused the OP of being "dishonest and inaccurate" because he neglected to mention the differences in freedoms of speech. The parallels he draws are independent of that concern.
- diego 11y agoThat is a non sequitur. He's talking about grouping countries by specific criteria. To make a code parallel, if you ran select from countries group by police_score; and select from countries group by freedom_of_press_index; You'd expect different results. Maybe there would be a correlation, and the US would be an outlier.
- chrisbennet 11y agoAttorney General Eric Holder changed this somewhat in January. It's an improvement but not as much as some people thought according to this Forbes article. http://www.forbes.com/sites/jacobsullum/2015/01/22/despite-holders-forfeiture-reform-cops-still-have-a-license-to-steal/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/jacobsullum/2015/01/22/despite-h...
- 1024core 11y agoThese stories make me very upset. How can we, as a society, let this go on? I wrote my Congresswoman and Senators, asking them about this case. I urge you all to do the same.
- Frondo 11y agoWrite your state representatives. Work to get the law changed in your state. Refer to the laws passed in other states in your letters, etc. It'll be much, much easier than trying to get things done at the federal level.
- LancerSykera 11y agoMinnesota recently fixed this so that a criminal conviction is necessary before forfeiture, and when I texted my state representative about it, he said my state senator already has a bill for it in committee in Pennsylvania. http://www.forbes.com/sites/instituteforjustice/2014/05/07/minnesota-forfeiture-reform/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/instituteforjustice/2014/05/07/m...
- joeax 11y agoNew Mexico too. And Ohio soon. Luckily the dominos are falling. https://reason.com/blog/2015/06/09/this-map-details-whether-asset-forfeitur https://reason.com/blog/2015/06/09/this-map-details-whether-...
- superuser2 11y agoFor those who didn't RTFA, he carried his life savings with him in cash. We've seen several stories like this: person has $xx,xxx in cash on them like that's just a normal thing to do. Bad thing happens. Person is incredulous. No one thinks they have any culpability for opting to carry $10k+ in cash over vastly safer and free alternatives. That doesn't excuse the seizure, but I don't see how it's worth our time to get mad about people experiencing bad outcomes when they take stupid risks. There are many other examples that make a better case against civil asset forfeiture.
- travjones 11y agoYou're correct that it is not wise to carry that much cash. However, we are allowed to do it. We are allowed to carry cash on us. I personally wouldn't do it unless I didn't have any other options, but for someone to have their money taken from them without evidence that it was derived from criminal activity is really messed up. And this isn't the first time that civil forfeiture has been used to deprive law abiding citizens of their property.
- MichaelGG 11y agoHaving cops steal money should not be a risk anyone is taking, let alone a stupid one. If he got mugged, that'd be another thing. Also, free alternatives? Elaborate. And certainly they aren't free from surveillance. We should encourage and treat the carrying of $$$$$ in cash as a normal thing to do.
- superuser2 11y agoChecking accounts. Bitcoin (not free, but close). If it weren't the state, it could just as easily have been an ordinary mugger, or an airline employee theft, or simple airline incompetence. >And certainly they aren't free from surveillance. If you want a financial system free from surveillance then you need to get the public on board with ending taxation (and consequently all public services). Good luck. And, as we saw, moving cash on an airplane is the most heavily surveilled and scrutinized way to do it.
- 11y ago
- eldavido 11y agoCivil asset forfeiture is horrible and we should get rid of it. On a different note, my takeaway from this story: pick your battles. Sure, you can go into an airport with $11k in cash. Maybe you're a Sikh and you want to carry a kirpan [0] into the airport, or you're a high school kid working on a science project and you have a bunch of C-cell batteries taped together with wires hanging out the ends of them (experience talking). You're probably increasing your odds of getting stopped. Sometimes it's worth it, maybe for strong religious beliefs, or you feel strongly about the exercise of your democratic rights. But fighting the collective weight of "normal", shared perception, culture, etc. is costly. You'll be delayed, people will ask lots of annoying questions, in general you'll expend a lot of energy on stuff that is in some sense, entirely avoidable. I felt this way recently when trying to get a loan for a house from Wells Fargo. Quit my W2 a few months ago for a large contract. I couldn't convince the bank my income was solid even though the payment was about 1/8th of my taxable income and I had almost the entire mortgage balance in semi-liquid retirement accounts. Sometimes the message the world sends is, "conform". [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kirpan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kirpan
- ddingus 11y agoI've had similar experiences when taking electronics along on business travel. When it's me and a boring hotel room for the week, why not? Lots of fun, and I enjoy low level programming. Conform is the word of the day for travel. Wish it wasn't. I've since learned to avoid batteries. Most of the other stuff won't be at issue. There is no significant mass, and that means no significant threat. (mostly)
- imaginenore 11y agoCivil asset forfeiture is fine if you're convicted, and the law says it's ok for a given crime. The current situation is ridiculous, and I'm surprised nobody brought a case all the way to The Supreme Court (I mean a case when a person was not charged and/or not found guilty).
- eldavido 11y agoSmall nitpick, the word "civil" is important here. If you're convicted of a crime, there is nothing "civil" about it, you're tried opposing a public official (district attorney -- not a private party) and convicted of a criminal offense. I don't think anyone here is arguing that asset forfeiture isn't appropriate for convicted criminals.
- epicureanideal 11y agoI wrote my rep because of this. If anyone wants to use pieces of this to save time writing their own rep, feel free: http://www.house.gov/representatives/find/ http://www.house.gov/representatives/find/ I'll keep this email brief because either you'll know about the issue already, or you'll want to do your own research (or ask your staff to do so). Most people won't take the time to email you, but this is probably the #1 most important issue for law abiding citizens at this time. Civil forfeiture, which permits cash or property of US citizens to be seized by police without being convicted of a crime, is completely opposed to all the principles of democratic government. If someone is convicted of a crime and the cash or property relates to the crime, sure, take it. But I am reading more and more stories in the news about merely unlucky fellow citizens having their cash stolen from them by the police (I use the word stolen because the seizure is unjust in this case) merely because "carrying a lot of cash is suspicious". You might be interested to read the Peelian Principles of policing a democracy (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peelian_Principles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peelian_Principles) which were created for the Metropolitan Police Force in London in 1829. The same principles would be effective today for maintaining public support for the police. When the people we as citizens entrust to keep order create the impression that they are not trustworthy and are a potential danger to us, this is a serious problem. When citizens see a police car or see a police officer walk by, they should feel safe, not fearful. That is less and less the case. Thank you.
- yason 11y agoWhile the capability of the police to forfeit property is absolutely and completely unfair and, in an (supposedly) equal society, deeply questionable——as opposed to taking the property temporarily unless proven guilty——the unescapably stupid thing to do is to a) transfer money in cash and b) smoking weed while doing that. All kinds of unlucky things could happen with a) such as losing the baggage/wallet/jacket with the money in it or being robbed. But because of b) and in a state where I believe cannabis is illegal, the mere unluckiness can be imagined to be amplified tenfold and one of the results is a catastrophe such as his.
- Roboprog 11y agoI don't know why you were voted down. While this is an incredibly unjust act by the police, it is, also, an incredibly stupid act by the student. Being stupid does not make one deserving of being a victim, but it still does leave one being stupid.
- teddyh 11y agoThere’s a phrase for what you are doing: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victim_blaming https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victim_blaming
- yason 11y agoVictim blaming is an ideal that often forgets to factor in realities. Theoretically, you should be able to walk into a Hell's Angels biker bar at 11pm on a Saturday evening and shout aloud "Only assholes ride a Harley!", then walk out. Theoretically you don't pose a credible threat to anyone and you merely state your opinion. In an ideally perfect world you should have nothing to worry about. But it just might be the most stupid thing you can do in ten seconds. There's a difference between saying the consequences are completely the victim's fault versus thinking that the victim should have a license to do stupid things and yet get away with it against some, if not all, odds. What happened to the guy who got his money confiscated is completely unfair but there was a wide range of choices he could've realistically made to avoid the unfairness from taking place. That's not victim blaming.
- powera 11y agoThe TLDR is "Don't carry thousands of dollars of physical cash unless you want to risk the police [or some criminal] stealing it". Which is an awful thing to say about the police, but is probably reasonable advice to give.
- travisp 11y agoIt's worth noting that civil forfeiture doesn't just apply to cash. It can be (and has been) used against bank accounts or pretty much any property you can own. For example, here's a case where the government tried to seize $115,000 from a couple's bank accounts (without charging them with a crime): http://blogs.wsj.com/law/2015/05/08/after-seizing-couples-bank-accounts-prosecutors-abandon-forfeiture-case/ http://blogs.wsj.com/law/2015/05/08/after-seizing-couples-ba...
- x0ra 11y ago...but the police is less likely to go through all your immaterial belongings for just a smell of weed.
- davismwfl 11y agoIt bugs me reading some of the the comments here blaming the person that did nothing illegal by carrying cash. It doesn't matter if you (or I) feel it is inadvisable to carry cash, it isn't illegal. Smoking pot (illegal in most places) before flying is obviously not the brightest idea given the enhanced level of security at an airport. So I am ok with the "smell" prompting some extra questions (even an agreed to search) but not the seizure of personal property when nothing can tie that property to a crime. Also, don't forget, here in the US many people cannot qualify for a simple checking/savings account at a bank, meaning they use check cashing services to cash their paychecks and only have cash. There is absolutely nothing is illegal about them only having cash. If anything IMO it is immoral that these people are iced out of the banking environment because of past credit mistakes etc. Immigrants and minorities are almost always the worst affected, how is that right? Civil asset forfeiture is horrid and needs to be done away with permanently and nationally. If you want to take someones property prove it was involved in a crime and directly contributed to or tied to the criminal act. If the property is properly seized through the courts, the proceeds should first benefit anyone directly afflicted by the criminal act, then secondarily pay for the court and legal fees to reduce taxpayer obligations.
- douche 11y agoI'm really curious, how do you not qualify for a savings account? I've never seen a bank that wouldn't take money, especially when they can charge account maintenance fees.
- nathancahill 11y agoWhen you're counting every dollar, why would you want to pay a bank maintenance fees?
- cryoshon 11y agoMany banks require a credit check to open a bank account without meeting a minimum balance... no way of getting credit in the first place if you're that poor.
- hectormalot 11y ago
- gizi 11y agoIt is a double problem. A rule that allows the police to seize your cash for the most flimsy of reasons only works if people are not aware of the fact that this could happen. Therefore, the next step is to outlaw discussions of the type that we are having now. Next, hosting a site that allows this kind of discussions must also be banned. Merely describing what exactly is banned, discloses the wrong kind of information, and must therefore also be banned. It is not enough to impose obnoxious rules. It will also be needed to control all information about them. The solution is to make rules a secret. That is how you get things like the FISA courts, the secret courts granting the NSA the right to do whatever they like, while anybody involved becomes subject to a gag order. Shut up, or else!
- hackatroll 11y agoI don't know why someone would take the chance caring that much money on them. Couldn’t he have gotten a check and cashed it once he got home or a bank account?
- rdancer 11y agoHe won't make the same mistake again, that's for sure.
- blazespin 11y agoAnonymous cash, like bitcoins, is a dangerous thing and facilitates illegal activities. The government should subsidize accounts and account fees for poor people.
- teddyh 11y ago…says “blazespin”, making an anonymous comment.
- ScottBurson 11y agoIf you agree that the civil asset forfeiture laws need to be reformed, please consider donating to http://endforfeiture.com/ http://endforfeiture.com/ . I just did.
- seansmccullough 11y agoI think the two takeaways here are: 1. Civil forfeiture laws need to go away. They are completely unfair, and a major conflict of interest for the police. 2. Don't carry $11k to the airport, just to avoid this issue.
- InfiniteEntropy 11y agoWelcome to America. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3kEpZWGgJks https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3kEpZWGgJks
- cmurf 11y agoSometimes, we are just evil vindictive assholes for no good goddamn reason. And it's shit.