6 ms·
What makes a great teacher?
- patio11 17y agoTeach for America recruits smart, young graduates and aggressively researches and optimizes what works so that they can teach kids better. They're covered extensively in the article and they're one of my favorite organizations. If you follow American education, this should be absolutely no surprise for you: the unions hate Teach for America. P.S. Next, Mr. Taylor announces it’s time for Multiplication Bingo.
- andrewvc 17y agoThis jives with some of the studies mentioned in the excellent book "How We Decide". Basically, if you want to get good at something, relentlessly question your methods, benchmark yourself, and try to get better. I become a teacher of sorts about a year ago. I teach my boss's kid how to code on the weekends, he's learning Javascript at the moment. I've had to majorly re-adjust my teaching strategy about 4 times over the last year. When I started I was doing a terrible job, and now I know I'm doing a much better job (though I still have a long way to go). Whenever I teach it takes quite a bit of brainpower on my end as I try and get inside of my student's head, so I can see what's working and what isn't. I can only imagine how hard teaching is when you don't have the luxury of focusing on just one student, but rather 5 classes of 30. In my memories of high school and college (high school in particular) so many of my teachers seemed detached, uninterested, and even bored with a lesson plan that they'd probably taught year in year out. I wonder how these people can be fixed? Can they just copy off teachers who actually try, or are they doomed to mediocrity? Can one be genuinely self-critical if one isn't motivated? My intuition tells me the answer, sadly is no.
- wisty 17y agoHow often do good coders read other people's code (in code reviews, or in their free time)? How often do teachers "sit in" on other teachers lessons?
- philk 17y agoOne of the most promising things in that article is how the government is using federal money to get legislative changes through that enable the performance of teachers to be measured, and, potentially fire low performers. Obviously the unions aren't happy about it, but really, the teachers unions seem to think that school is run for the benefit of their members rather than students. If we could break them it'd be a great day for kids and a great day for America.
- andrew1 17y agoI'm no great fan of unions in general but teaching unions do provide important advice, support and representation to teachers. There have been enough cases of teachers being wrongly sacked over false claims by children of abuse etc. that I can understand teachers wanting to belong to an organisation which will help defend them if they're ever in that situation. You could argue that that could happen in any profession - I could be wrongly accused of stealing from the office I work in - but child abuse is a more sensitive issue than most and schools can feel pressured to appear to be 'protecting children' and perhaps more cynically to not want to take the risk of a repeat incident bringing more bad publicity.
- philk 17y agoIt's a fair point but unfortunately the unions have greatly overstepped defending teachers against wrongful allegations and moved into advancing teachers rights at the expense of students. The following article: http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-teachers3-2009may03,0,5765040,full.story http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-teachers3-2009may03,... contains a few examples of just how hard it can be to fire a bad teacher, including one who mocked a student's suicide attempt to the rest of the class yet was reinstated in his job. Additionally, a bad teacher will potentially damage the futures of hundreds of students throughout their career; because of the high cost I'd say that erring on the side of dismissal is worth the risk.
- roc 17y agoAs with most every human organizational construct: They were created for good reason and have done good things, but are inevitably perverted over time.
- andreyf 17y agoI wonder what limitations there are to using standardized testing for evaluating "progress"? From personal experience, many of my friends who score very well on standardized tests aren't necessarily "smart" in the sense Feynman was "smart" - that is, capable of creating and sharpening their models of the world. What's ironic is that while Teach for America acknowledges that it's extremely difficult to measure what makes a "good teacher", in that same sense of a person who continuously creates and sharpens their models of the world, they seem to assume it's trivial to measure a "good student", even though the two are fundamentally the same.
- patio11 17y agoI wonder what limitations there are to using standardized testing for evaluating "progress"? Any heuristic you care to use is significantly better than the traditional metric for school quality, which is spending per pupil. (This metric was selected because optimizing for it optimizes for the outcomes teachers unions desire. American public school exist to employ union teachers and sometimes cause education as an industrial biproduct.) This puts me in mind of the metric my day job used to track productivity for several decades: hours worked by the engineering staff. That one had perverse consequences, too. (Having a bad quarter? Need a good statistic to report to the head office? Start a deathmarch!)
- wisty 17y agoGoodheart's Law (not to be confused with Godwin or Murphy's Laws): "any observed statistical regularity will tend to collapse once pressure is placed upon it for control purposes". Randall Munroe (xkcd) has make a similar observation.
- RyanMcGreal 17y agoAs soon as you start measuring something and attaching organizational outcomes to the results, you encourage gaming.
- 17y ago
- RyanMcGreal 17y ago> Great teachers, he concluded, constantly reevaluate what they are doing. [...] But when Farr took his findings to teachers, they wanted more. "They’d say, 'Yeah, yeah. Give me the concrete actions. What does this mean for a lesson plan?'" Way to miss the point. :/
- edw519 17y agoNext, Mr. Taylor announces it’s time for Multiplication Bingo. As Mr. Taylor reads off a problem ("20 divided by 5"), the kids scour their boards, chips in hand, looking for 4's. One girl is literally shaking with excitement. Another has her hands clasped in a prayer position. I find myself wanting to play. You know you're in a good classroom if you have to stop yourself from raising your hand. Patrick (http://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=patio11 http://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=patio11), this one paragraph helped me understand why your business is so important more than all the discussion about it here on hn over the years. You may want to pursue using it in your marketing efforts. Your business is a perfect example of what Guy Kawasaki calls, "Make Meaning". One more way for you to inspire the rest of us. Respect.
- boredguy8 17y agoHe's also a pretty cool cat. Not like I'm making a fan club or anything, but yeah.
- boredguy8 17y agoOK, having read the whole article, it seems like energetic people who buy in to what they're doing are more likely to be successful than people who despair at their ability to control their outcome. People highly energetic about where they're going are more likely to work harder at it, so that's not all that surprising. And there have been enough links on here about 'grit' to make that consequence not surprising at all. The interesting question to me would be to see longitudinal results from random teachers in general. I remember in high school having a PHENOMENAL teacher who was in his 3rd year of teaching. I went back to visit him recently (he'd have been teaching 10 more years now), and he was very, very despondent. I wonder how his 'class performance' during those first 3 years compares to his class performance during his last 3. "Great teachers...were also perpetually looking for ways to improve their effectiveness. For example, when Farr called up teachers who were making remarkable gains and asked to visit their classrooms, he noticed he’d get a similar response from all of them: 'They’d say, "You’re welcome to come, but I have to warn you—I am in the middle of just blowing up my classroom structure and changing my reading workshop because I think it’s not working as well as it could." When you hear that over and over, and you don’t hear that from other teachers, you start to form a hypothesis.' Great teachers, he concluded, constantly reevaluate what they are doing." Sounds like software development, too.