4 ms·
Seems like an eminently sensible outcome. The fact is, regardless of context, a word that has a derogatory or inflammatory meaning in a separate context will al
by onion2k 11y ago
Seems like an eminently sensible outcome. The fact is, regardless of context, a word that has a derogatory or inflammatory meaning in a separate context will always be questioned. It doesn't matter if you find it acceptable; this is about respecting other people's boundaries.
Substitute "bro" for any word that you would find inappropriate and the problem becomes obvious.
- r0naa 11y agoDo you realize that your reasoning can be extended ad nauseam to everything, all the time? So much that you will find yourself spending more time on finding a name that actually building anything. Should Coq - the proof assistant - be renamed to something else, because it is pronounced like "cock"? Yes? Even though it is a project of the INRIA (One of France's Computer Science research institute) and means "rooster" in French. This overly fixated attitude toward "respecting other people's boundaries" is very much begging for mockery. Perhaps as much as it is intellectually dishonest because it leaves so many questions, and unknowns unanswered. How do you know what are the others' personal boundaries? Is there group whose boundaries does not matter> Does this rule extend to any creative work? Should existing projects be renamed? Are boundaries dynamics? Can someone be offended by this rule? Or are there rules about things that you can be offended about, or not? There are so many issues with this paradigm of thinking. Let me suggest an alternative: common sense.
- tenaciousDaniel 11y agoAnd one comment even pointed out perfectly good reasons not to consider br - "'br' is already an abbreviation for Brazil and is the HTML tag for linebreak".
- strangecasts 11y agoThe same comment suggested "bti" as a sensible alternative, though.
- strangecasts 11y agoDo you realize that your reasoning can be extended ad nauseam to everything, all the time? I really wouldn't defend intellectual honesty with a slippery-slope argument.
- omginternets 11y agoI don't think it was intended as a slippery-slope argument, but rather as a demonstration that the proposed method was inherently indiscriminate. In other words, it amounts to "stop doing things I don't like", and doesn't take into account the reasonableness (or lack thereof) of the person taking offense.
- 13thLetter 11y agoBut what if I find "br" inappropriate?
- slipperydan 11y agoYeah, like what if it was racist? From Urban Dictionary: "ii)Br: A dumbass online gamer who also hails from Brazil but is ignorant of rules and disrespectful of fellow gamers. Uses his or her lack of knowledge of the English language to try and get away with breaking rules" Hmm.
- omginternets 11y ago>this is about respecting other people's boundaries. This is about those boundaries being completely unreasonable. We're talking about the homonym of a gendered noun -- not even the (otherwise neutral) noun itself! >Substitute "bro" for any word that you would find inappropriate and the problem becomes obvious. Replace any loving, sensible statement with "black people should be lynched" and the problem becomes obvious. Give me a break.