4 ms·
A better question is why do we even have 'High Frequency Traders'? Wouldn't the market be better served by a window structure with a scale on a more human time
by mjevans 11y ago
A better question is why do we even have 'High Frequency Traders'?
Wouldn't the market be better served by a window structure with a scale on a more human timespan? Say a 5 min process in which:
* for 4 min orders are taken in confidential secret.
* there is a 1 min blackout window in which no orders are taken, and in which any results of settling the outcome of orders is not published.
* At the end of that period the new results are published. (It doesn't matter who reacts first, it's who reacts best.)
The profit between what sellers are asking for and what the buyers are willing to pay still needs to be accounted for. This could be the market's operating fee (the cost of the sale's commission), it could be attributed to the government as a form of sales tax, it could be returned in some way to the parties involved (buyers pay less, sellers earn more), other, or some combination of the above.
- jrockway 11y agoThe price of equities is not known. The market is how that price is calculated. You could slow down the process, but that adds risk (that one party is getting the wrong price). The market makers would say, I'll sell you one 1 share for $1, 10 shares for $1.20, 100 shares for $2, 1000 shares for $10. So then someone who wants to buy 1000 shares for $1 a share will buy only 1 share at $1. Then in the quiet period, the market makers will adjust their prices. 1 share for $1.01, etc. Then you'll sell another share for $1.01. Then you'll wait 5 minutes, and the market makers will adjust their price. The market is going to work the same way at 5 minute delay as it works at nanosecond delay, but just be slower. The market makers won't be getting you a better price, and your large transaction won't not affect the share price.
- tomp 11y agoWould you, as an investor, rather trade on exchange A, where there is a given spread and market depth, so you know approximately what price your order will execute at in the next few seconds, or at exchange B, where the most recent price and depth is up to 5 minutes old, and where your orders will be executed at an unknown price sometime in the next 5 minutes?
- Alupis 11y ago> A better question is why do we even have 'High Frequency Traders'? High Frequency Traders (HFT) do a lot of positive things for a market - mainly providing liquidity where they might otherwise not be. They also act as a sort-of balancing force for undervalued or overvalued stocks (in the volume the HFT's trade with over time), "normalizing" the VWAP and TWAP (among other health indicators) for a given ticker. In other words, markets want (and benefit from) HFT's.