3 ms·
Sort of and sort of not right? So VW came right out and said "The difference is caused by defeat device code programmed into the computer." Great simple answer.
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
Sort of and sort of not right? So VW came right out and said "The difference is caused by defeat device code programmed into the computer." Great simple answer. None of these people have offered up a theory of why things are different. It could be defeat devices, or it could be something else, they just don't know.
So step two of this process is figure out all the ways in which actual driving differs from lab testing. And when you've eliminated all other explanations, start looking for defeat devices or their equivalents.
I'm guessing one or more of these companies will end up admitting, after looking into it, that their car control software runs differently if it detects the car is being tested.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoMaybe we have a different idea about what a 'defeat device' is. Its a physical piece of hardware. Not some code. So to find out if these other cars have it, you stick your head under that car and look.
- function_seven 11y agoThe term "defeat device" refers to any mechanism, physical or otherwise, designed to defeat emmissions controls. It's not literally a standalone gadget. I assume the term is a holdover from the 1970s. A defeat device is an AECD “that reduces the effectiveness of the emission control system under conditions which may reasonably be expected to be encountered in normal vehicle operation and use. Motor vehicles equipped with defeat devices cannot be certified.” And the AECD is defined as any element of design which senses temperature, vehicle speed, engine RPM, transmission gear, manifold vacuum or any other parameter for the purpose of activating, modulating, delaying or deactivating the operation of any part of the emission control system. http://www.autocar.co.uk/car-news/industry/vw-emissions-scandal-how-volkswagens-defeat-device-works http://www.autocar.co.uk/car-news/industry/vw-emissions-scan...
- vesrah 11y agoWhat physical defeat device is VW using? (There isn't one)
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoTwo temperature-sensing devices, according to the report.
- vesrah 11y agoLink to said report? Temperature sensors (EGT) are a normal part of cars.
- wlievens 11y agoThat's an extremely narrow and frankly useless definition...
- baobabaobab 11y agoAt least in my corner of the industry (commercial) , we've been asking for better test cycles because we don't want to wind up in a situation where we are chasing fuel economy on the test cycle at the expense of fuel economy in the real world. The regulators want to keep the same test cycles so they can measure how emissions and fuel economy are changing over time. Internally, we have much better test cycles correlated to real world routes that we use to validate fuel economy simulations.
- bsdetector 11y agoI don't understand why regulators don't just do additional, more representative tests so they can track long-term trends and also have a better test? How much time/resources do the tests actually take?
- myhf 11y agoA more representative test (like running a car on a treadmill) requires a dedicated testing facility that nobody wants to pay for or wait in line to use.
- sitharus 11y agoThe article suggests on average real-world emissions are 2-5x more than in the lab except for a 20x outlier. VW was 40 times more than in the lab. I don't think most of these cars are hiding anything, it's just an example of how easy it is to optimise for a fixed test.
- LoSboccacc 11y agoexactly, beside, a disconnect between test regime and real world results is expected. what VW did was not just optimize for the test, but cheat the test, which is: those cars in the article are able to pass the tested restriction in the test regime, while disabling the cheating code wv engines were found not to be able to match test restriction even under test regime. no one here was busted for real world emission. that's kind of understood already by regulators which built the test assuming the result would trickle down in real world usage even if not 1:1
- InclinedPlane 11y agoIt's not as though there haven't been issues with gaming these tests to a degree for a long time. Almost certainly this has been an issue of walking backwards into a big mistake little by little, which is the typical process of making big mistakes. You start by figuring out how to game the system right at "the line" as much as you can, then the day comes where you decide to be more explicit about it and build it into the software. You probably decide that you just want to play around at the edges, with incremental differences between "cheat mode" and real driving in the same realm as the bit by bit gaming they've been doing already. But once the system exists the natural process of optimization would push it to the limit of what was capable, and it turned out that was a lot. But by then you're committed, and it would take a lot of fortitude to walk back from such a mistake. I'm sure the same sorts of dynamics have played out in many other auto makers, though it's notable that some, with a more developed sense of ethics seemingly, have not gone down that road.