3 ms·
Right. The usual counter is the following: "This was predicted every time we had technological upheavals, and it never happened. Therefore it won't happen thi
by mpweiher 11y ago
Right. The usual counter is the following: "This was predicted every time we had technological upheavals, and it never happened. Therefore it won't happen this time either."
Although there is some truth to this, the past tends to be only a limited predictor for the future ("It's tough to make predictions, especially about the future." -- Yogi Berra ), and of course logically this stance cannot be supported.
Also, there is some grounds to believe that this time actually is different: whereas production and consumption used to expand to soak up new found productivity, we're reaching both resource limits in terms of what can be produced, and at least in the west saturation in terms of consumption. We already consume way more than we really want/need, and more and more people are realizing that their stuff is not liberating them, but rather taking them hostage.
Furthermore, there also is evidence that this is already happening. Blue collar wages are stagnating or in decline, same though to a lesser extent for the middle class. Debt has soared as people try to maintain their standard of living.
Robots have the capacity to help us bring about the 15 hour work week Keynes predicted, or maybe even the 4 hour work week, but we probably will have to restructure our wealth distribution mechanisms somewhat to achieve it.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Right. The usual counter is the following: "This was predicted every time we had technological upheavals, and it never happened. Therefore it won't happen this time either." Which is, of course, false in its premise -- it happened with the technological developments which were happening alongside the development of the economic system which would become dominant in the developed world of the time, which would later be named "capitalism" by its critics, and was mitigated to a certain degree (but not, by any stretch of the imagination, solved) when capitalism was largely replaced in the developed world with modern "mixed economies" which limit the capitalist property system through the adoption of redistributive and socialized regulatory mechanisms while retaining the capitalist arrangement in outline (in the developed world, this approach has prevailed, for now, over both retaining -- or reverting to -- capitalism without compromising its structure and abandoning its property structure outright.)
- addicted 11y ago"Although there is some truth to this, the past tends to be only a limited predictor for the future" A great example of this is Malthus. His predictions were absolutely correct based on the history of the world until that point. The reason he was so wrong was because the world changed so dramatically.