9 ms·
Obama Encryption Policy Rejects Laws Mandating Backdoors
- cryoshon 11y agoDeceptive title, unintentionally. FTA: "Instead, the Post reports, the “administration will continue trying to persuade companies that have moved to encrypt their customers’ data to create a way for the government to still peer into people’s data when needed for criminal or terrorism investigations.” While eschewing attempts to legislatively mandate that tech companies build backdoors into their services, the president is continuing the status quo – that is, informally pressuring companies to give the government access to unencrypted data." Status quo is that the government doesn't respect the privacy of its citizens.
- mtgx 11y agoHN title should have a "- For Now" at the end.
- simonh 11y agoAgreed, but it's still a massive improvement over mandating that all encryption used by citizens be thoroughly crippled. The status quo should be that the degree to which Government can intrude into citizens privacy is limited by law and subject to open public debate. We're not quite there yet, either in the US or here in the UK, but dropping the idea of crippled encryption is at least a step back from the brink even if it's not enough steps back for my liking. It's at least an implicit acknowledgement that the EFF/privacy hippies aren't completely wrong.
- BackWhackBeaner 11y agoErgo, why projects that provide encryption tools are so important.
- wfo 11y agoI think threatening to ban all secure communication in a psychotic unrealistic policy position and having important "serious" people like the director of the FBI push for it isn't really intended to get it codified into law, rather to elicit responses like yours -- it's designed to massively push the Overton window against privacy so that we can feel okay about how bad things currently are -- at least the insane unrealistic threats that were thrown around weren't followed through.
- simonh 11y agoNo, unfotrunately I think our 'security' establishment really are so divorced from reality that they think crippling encryption is a good idea. It would be nice to think that they're actualy technically competent and it's all a ploy, but the truth is depressingly mundane. They handed the Chinese government and other authoritarian states cover for demanding back doors in encrypted products on a platter, and sold out our privacy, without any clue how utterly stupid and self defeating an idea it is.
- acaloiar 11y agoMy thoughts mirror @wfo's, but more simplistically. It is a negotiation tactic. When seller A wants to sell something for $20, it is initially offered for $30. When buyer B's $25 counter offer is accepted, B is pleased with the result because they've purchased the item under asking price, while A is pleased for having sold at a premium.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoOn the other hand, as long as backdoors remain out of legislation, those companies are still free to say "no".
- cryoshon 11y agoMany won't say no, because the advantage of having a government willing to look out for their bottom line is far too large to ignore for the sake of a few users.
- unfamiliar 11y agoI agree. If companies aren't compelled by law to collaborate with the government, this will incentivise the government to find other ways to persuade them.
- ajross 11y agoMany (most) don't encrypt anything anyway and will just comply with warrants and requests. That's not really the point. The point here is that where we have device and service providers like Apple and Google and whoever-just-bought-LastPass where we do trust them to encrypt our info, the government won't be making rules that compel them to undo that work. If you didn't trust Google and Apple to begin with, the government compulsion would be meaningless anyway.
- quaunaut 11y agoWe've agreed as a country that the ability to get a warrant in the case of probable cause is a good thing. How is this not just maintaining that? I find it hilarious how often privacy advocates manage to forget that we've had this conversation before, and while the government can and has overstepped in many ways, lets not throw out the ability to investigate at all along the way.
- drcube 11y agoBecause breaking encryption breaks it for everyone. If the cops can get your data, so can a hacker. There is simply no way to compromise. You either are encrypted, in which case nobody but you can decrypt your data, or you're not encrypted at all. Remember the "TSA locks" we're all required to use on our luggage at the airport? Nobody but the government was supposed to be able to unlock them. But now anyone who wants to ruffle through your luggage can get universal keys for all TSA locks. What happens when that same scenario plays out with your bank account, your company emails, or any online store you've made purchases from?
- quaunaut 11y agoI'm not arguing to break encryption. And neither is the white house. They want ways around this stuff- ways that don't break encryption, but if the information is available, then the ability to get to it if necessary. Backdoors don't work because yeah, it breaks the whole system. But not everything is encrypted with these companies, that's just plain.
- Zombieball 11y agoPerhaps I am not versed well enough in the subject, but I have a hard time envisioning any kind of system that allows government officials to get around the encryption and peer into the contents but not hackers. There will always be some sort of secret only the government has access to, and once that secret is leaked it's game over.
- 11y ago
- mkobit 11y agoThe article title doesn't seem as deceptive as this post title: > Partial Victory: Obama Encryption Policy Rejects Laws Mandating Backdoors, But Leaves the Door Open for Informal Deals Compared to: > Obama Encryption Policy Rejects Laws Mandating Backdoors It also doesn't sound like a full on rejection, as new information might cause him to change his stance: > “will not —for now—call for legislation requiring companies to decode messages for law enforcement.”
- sdenton4 11y agoIt's probably a bad idea to pass policy against passing future policy... That applies both to 'informal deals' and leaving the door open for future legislation. Really the only reason to pass policy against policy in this case is to score political points with the Hacker News interest group, which is a pretty niche constituency...
- Laaw 11y agoI don't understand why respect would be part of this, or loyalty, patriotism, or whatever. Do you really think the best strategy to defend against an adversary is to shame them into behaving? This is about what's cryptographically possible and what isn't. I don't frankly care if anyone respects my privacy, what I want is the ability to shut adversaries out, period, using math. This decision means companies can say 'no'. That's a win, because it lets the math be possible in the first place.
- cryoshon 11y agoWell, being realistic, we have three avenues out of our totalitarian mess we find ourselves deeply in: 1. Political (use money, shame, votes, and threats, praying that these things still work to effect change) 2. Technological (use encryption, praying technological solutions are implemented evenly and properly and that there are no back doors) 3. Violence 1 and 2 are the workable strategies, and they only work when practiced together. Currently we are seeing the government's #1 try to trample on #2, frequently using #3. If we can whittle a bit more respect for #2 using #1, it'll make the rest of the journey back to liberal democracy easier. Political changes happen through shifted mindsets.
- Laaw 11y agoI don't think shame is an effective tactic, because it has no real "stick" component. People will always do what they can. The only way to stop someone from doing something is to make them unable to do it. That's not solved through shame or appeal to emotion, because the people doing the bad things aren't going to express emotions. Keep trying to shame them, and you'll simply fail. We need to build something they can't break.
- SteveLAnderson 11y agoUmm, I hate to be too nit picky, but the headline isn't deceptive. "Obama Encryption Policy Rejects Laws Mandating Backdoors" The Obama administration is rejecting mandated backdoors. That's what the headline says and it's completely correct. The rest of your comment is correct; they aren't rejecting backdoors, just rejecting making them mandatory.
- james4k 11y agoI am surprised the petition has yet to reach 100k signatures. Is it optimistic to think that most of the tech community at least should recognize the significance of this? Even if you doubt its effect on real policy.
- mordocai 11y agoI think most people are just too lazy/paranoid to sign petitions. Tech or not.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoPetitions don't do anything. I donate to the EFF and Demand Progress instead.
- mordocai 11y agoTrue, I donate to the EFF though not Demand Progress(yet)
- jstx 11y agoI'm not. Who has time to fully comprehend (and act upon) this? Especially when we're already working >50h a week to maintain household status quo. It's hard to focus on the state of society's infrastructure when I'm spending every waking moment working to maintain my own. Yes, I know what is at stake, but one avenue is a long burn and the other is a short fuse. I'll tackle the more pressing issue first. Disclosure: I work in the netsec industry and only signed this because HN brought it to my attention in the rare spare moments between my daily tasks. To use an analogy, I feel like I can't worry about putting out the forest fire if my house is already on fire in the midst of it. At the same time, I'm throwing money at someone that says they'll help me free up more time to do the forest fire fighting. We'll see if I've made a grave mistake in how I prioritize things.
- hcon 11y agoThis is my reaction whenever I hear someone suggest that "we should be rioting in the streets." I have daily personal struggles and work that I'm trying to pin down every day with all my energy. And my remaining time/energy go into finding a mate if I even have any at all.
- late2part 11y agoThe Obama administration has continued flawed policies in many areas, especially those infringing on the 4th Amendment.
- TallGuyShort 11y agoThe other day I heard someone say (and I'm not exaggerating or excluding key context here), "I think Obama is similar to Hitler. He's changing our Constitution and taking away our freedoms." I couldn't begin to list the things Obama said Bush had overreached on and would end, that he later renewed in one form or another.
- derefr 11y agoA lot of these policies continue because they're considered optimal/necessary by the layer of thinktanks and technocrats that feed Washington its data. I doubt any administration could change them, no matter what was said on their campaign trail.
- late2part 11y agoThe president can change many things. They choose not to because there is a cost. Of course, checks and balances with legislators and the courts, but the executive branch has tremendous leeway in executive policy and action. Obama could order the NSA to stop tapping domestic fiber and they would. He chooses not to because he doesn't want the Washinton insiders to attack him. This is our country, not the career politicians. It's not a cliche, it's true. Those of us who are voting citizens should realize that politics need not be a Hegelian compromise, elect people that affect positive change, and punish and vote out those that don't.
- mhurron 11y agoGovernment basically exists to maintain the status quo. Anyone who might really change anything really won't get far enough in order to. Meet the new boss, same as the old boss.
- late2part 11y ago
- outside1234 11y agoWhy does the Apple one get special kudos? They just say they "don't allow government access to their SERVERS" - they never say anything about the data.
- a3n 11y ago> the administration will continue trying to persuade companies that have moved to encrypt their customers’ data to create a way for the government to still peer into people’s data If you are one of these companies that are informally cooperating with the government on this, please state so publicly, in the signup process and by message to current users, so that we can avoid using your services now, or at least when it's discovered later if you weren't honest about it up front.
- declan 11y agoWell put. We tried to take a very privacy-protective stand when building Recent News (https://recent.io https://recent.io) because of the amount of personalization we do. This warrant canary is part of our privacy policy: As of [date], we have not received any legal process or demand from any federal, state, or local government that includes a gag order. We have received no National Security Letters, civil subpoenas, search warrants, Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act orders, grand jury subpoenas, or any other form of compulsory process accompanied by a gag order. As of [date], we have received no legal orders requiring us to monitor users' future activities or to modify our service. If we do receive any form of compulsory process from any government entity, we will do our best to ensure that our users' legal rights and privacy rights under the Fourth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution are protected. That includes challenging overly broad orders in court. It is still valid, I'm happy to say, for [date] values of today.
- polymatter 11y agoIANAL, but the judge may order you to keep the warrant canary or find you in contempt. Law is based on intent and if your intent in removing that clause is in broadcasting you are under gag order, when the gag order restricts you from doing exactly that, you may find that will be taken as a breach. This should not be taken as legal advice, YMMV, yadda yadda.
- declan 11y agoThis is mostly good news. A few thoughts: * The FBI-NSA-etc. axis already tried to ban nonescrowed crypto. This was in 1997, when far fewer products relied on it, far fewer people used the Internet, and far fewer groups mobilized to oppose it. If even that effort failed, this one was likely to fail as well. * Excerpt from that 1997 proposal, which was actually approved(!) by a House of Representatives committee: "It shall be unlawful for any person to manufacture for distribution, distribute, or import encryption products intended for sale or use in the United States, unless that product..." http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/cpquery/T?&report=hr108p4&dbname=105& http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/cpquery/T?&report=hr108p4&dbna... * I disclosed in 2012 that the FBI had drafted a proposed law to require backdoors; that legislation was never introduced, even as a placeholder. My 2012 article: http://www.cnet.com/news/fbi-we-need-wiretap-ready-web-sites-now/ http://www.cnet.com/news/fbi-we-need-wiretap-ready-web-sites... Of course the FBI's bill could be kept in reserve to become Patriot Act 2.0, just like the FBI-NSA-etc. axis had EPPSCA in reserve, which morphed into Patriot Act 1.0 a month after the 9/11 attacks, as I wrote about here: http://www.cnet.com/news/how-bin-laden-and-911-attacks-shaped-electronic-privacy/ http://www.cnet.com/news/how-bin-laden-and-911-attacks-shape... * If the legislative approach is now off the table, as the WashPost piece indicates, look for the FBI-NSA-etc. axis to try more creative approaches. "Oh, you want that $2 billion government contract? You want your new device to be FIPS 140-2 certified? How about that merger or FTC antitrust review? Environmental reviews? Trade? Taxes? It sure would be a shame if things didn't go your way. Maybe you can help us and we'll help you..." This is why it's worth supporting groups like EFF (I donated last year and need to again before the end of this year). They provide a moral argument that counters that of the Washington establishment--and also provides guidance for tech firms when they're faced with challenges like those above.
- a3n 11y ago"Persuade." How can we know that NSL's aren't being used right now to "persuade" or coerce companies to cooperate? Who needs legislation when you effectively don't have to reveal anything?
- pasbesoin 11y agoMeta: We might have more respect -- in limited measure -- for the government's position if they actually cleaned up their own malfeasance, instead of persistently, predictably trying to bury it. You want transparency? Lead by example.