7 ms·
For decades, government steered millions away from whole milk. Was that wrong?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- zamalek 11y agoAccording to a front page article this week, milk contains a progenitor to NAD. There may be no causation, but it's an intriguing correlation.
- clarkmoody 11y agoFor decades, government ______ only to find out later that it was really bad. The social engineering has got to stop. A free people should not be subject to the latest schemes of self-appointed masterminds. The most evident and dangerous venue for such engineering is the public schools, in which the government subjects our children to every sort of social experiment, and what have we to show for it?
- amalag 11y agoThe US is somewhat unique in that there is a lot less tradition. Many "Old world" countries have millenia of established culture. How to live and eat healthy. Instead the US falls back to experimental science and corporations to define good health.
- enlightenedfool 11y agoI view the "established culture" you mention as science too..based on certain observations. It's not that all traditional methods are inferior or superior. We constantly re-evaluate as we evolve.
- irixusr 11y agoI've just become a father and my kid has very slight jaundice, not enough to have to do anything about it. But it did get me thinking, "how was jaundice dealt with before"? Considering 10% (??) of kids have bad jaundice that's a huge evolutionary pressure to either eliminate it (by favoring kids with larger livers) or somehow deal with it. Well my wife's (who's from a third-world and (formerly) most isolated country in the world) grandma (eldest of 13) explained it to me: She's always taken newborn's and placed them by the window for an hour. That'll do it! Then I read the history of neonatal jaundice care and I was shocked to learn that light therapy for jaundice wasn't discovered until the 50s (when a doctor noticed that newborns under the care of a nurse with particular habits fared better) and widely practiced until the 70s! +1 for folksy medicine!
- enlightenedfool 11y agoWell, I guess government follows the scientific conclusions and recommendations. Some might turn out to be wrong and we unlearn them. Science does make mistakes, but that's the best we've got. We can't leave it to intuitions of the masses.
- bobcostas55 11y ago>I guess government follows the scientific conclusions and recommendations. Come on now.
- clarkmoody 11y agoA naive view, at best. You're forgetting all about politics and special interests. > We can't leave it to intuitions of the masses. Precisely the mindset of the power elite that gets us into so much trouble.
- enlightenedfool 11y agoWell, take vaccinations for example. Would you better leave it to the people to decide? I'm sure half won't take them. EDIT: I do understand the corporate influence, but we could find a way to build unbiased scientific institutions if with collective global will.
- lackbeard 11y agoLetting people choose to not vaccinate their children will self correct. We'll lose herd immunity, a lot of people will die, and then everyone will know how awesome vaccines are, just like they did in the 60s. Then the cycle will begin anew. I lean toward valuing individual rights over all else, but this scenario does present a serious challenge to that worldview. Another contributor to the problem is that people trust science a lot less today than 2 generations ago. They've seen the negative results of a lot of fraud that has been perpetuated under the banner of "science". (E.g. "scientific socialism", the food pyramid, most of psychology, etc...)
- chrisan 11y ago
- jegutman 11y agoFor years the government has been encouraging _____ only for a news article never to be written because it dramatically helped the outcomes of real people. Don't forget that the things that make the news have a huge selection bias.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ceejayoz 11y ago> The most evident and dangerous venue for such engineering is the public schools, in which the government subjects our children to every sort of social experiment, and what have we to show for it? First two to spring to mind: A dramatic drop in violent crime since the 1970s because the "self-appointed masterminds" restricted lead. A dramatic drop in road deaths because the "self-appointed masterminds" required seatbelts, airbags, and crash standards.
- irixusr 11y agoWell the masterminds are still in the red, compared to the deaths from obesity (and drastic cut in quality of life).
- ashark 11y agoI think the key argument in favor of the usefulness of these sorts of policies is that if I had to worry about all this stuff myself it would take a ton of time and I'd almost certainly still do a worse job than government regulators. That regulators make mistakes, even fairly often, doesn't necessarily convince me my life would be better without them.
- clarkmoody 11y agoYou'll need to be more specific as to the causes of the drop in violent crime in the '70s. Your example about automobile safety devices makes the dubious assumption that manufacturers wouldn't include such technologies if not mandated by the state and that consumers wouldn't demand them. You also ignore the ridiculous amount of other required features on modern automobiles that make base models more and more expensive, hurting the lowest income levels.
- smt88 11y ago> A dramatic drop in violent crime since the 1970s because the "self-appointed masterminds" restricted lead There are many possible factors that went into this reduction in crime, but it's not entirely settled. For example, a substantial portion is attributable to a decrease in unwanted pregnancies [1]. 1. http://pricetheory.uchicago.edu/levitt/Papers/LevittUnderstandingWhyCrime2004.pdf http://pricetheory.uchicago.edu/levitt/Papers/LevittUndersta...
- acacia314 11y agoI've switch my family to all whole-milk unhomogenized dairy products (if I can find it). Why should I pay more for less calories and modified fat?
- maxxxxx 11y agoIs that in the US? In CA whole milk is much more expensive.
- bradleyjg 11y agoHomogenization just mixes the fat it into the milk. What do you do with it?
- acacia314 11y agoIt is more than mixing. It is a reduction in the size of the fat molecules which changes the way the fat acts in the mixture. Shaking the milk before drinking is not the same thing.
- vonmoltke 11y agoCreating an emulsion, which is exactly what homogenization is, does not do anything to the molecules. It reduces the size of the clumps of molecules, which simply allows it to exist in a consistent suspension. It has no effects whatsoever on how those compounds behave in the digestive tract.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoMaybe that's taking it too far? Clump size may indeed affect absorption, change the time it takes to travel down the intestine, or even change the speed of chemical reaction with increased surface area.
- niels_olson 11y agoI have examined enough human intestines, macroscopically, microscopically, and biochemically, to feel fairly confident this is not in fact something to worry about.
- ElijahLynn 11y agoDrinking the milk from another species designed to grow that species babies is wrong. Would you even drink human milk designed for human babies as a grown adult?
- howdoipython 11y agoSome people do
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoWell, no food in nature was really designed to grow human adults. We've coopted the reproductive cells of thousands of plants, solely because we were hungry and there were calories there. Not because of design. Nature is not out to help us be healthy, despite all the books written about it. A plant would gladly poison us (many try) if it's seeds would sprout better from our dessicated corpses.
- iamcurious 11y agoI know! and so is eating honey! eating food designed for a baby bee to grow is wrong. /s
- natch 11y agoJust don't give honey to baby people. Totally not what you were saying, I get that, but I think it's always a good public service type message to spread. http://www.benefits-of-honey.com/honey-and-infant.html http://www.benefits-of-honey.com/honey-and-infant.html
- DanBC 11y agoThat link doesn't mention the dental hygiene problems of sugar. So, even when your child is over 12 months it's probably a good idea to minimise the amount of honey they eat.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- 11y ago
- jobu 11y ago"[Whole milk] was banned from school lunch programs." Most schools don't even have 1% milk, but they all have chocolate milk with tons of added sugar. Great healthy choice there.
- sp332 11y agoA Pepsi representative commented that people are so confused about healthy food, they'll avoid orange juice because of the high sugar and avoid diet sodas because they don't trust the artificial sweeteners.
- blt 11y agoGah, school lunches and nutritional recommendations make me so mad. Everyone thought eggs and butter were unhealthy too. 6-11 servings of grain though! The "food pyramid" was beaten into my head repeatedly as a child, with some suspicious board of agriculture sponsored exercises too. Turns out it was total bullshit. We feed our kids the worst garbage, at least we did from 1992-2005. A nation should want its kids to grow up big and strong. But nope, let em eat french fries and pears in heavy syrup.
- Glide 11y agoWell at least they are big now. The strong part? I dunno cut out recess and PE?
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoTimes changed. The Pentagon (who owns school lunch program) set their standards because they rejected too many recruits for malnutrition in WWII, usually insufficient calories/stunted growth. The 50's saw that change with widespread refrigeration and more varied diets. The standards should have changed but once instituted change comes hard. Now the Pentagon responds to obesity by restricting school lunch calories. Misguided in my opinion; school kids are growing fast and need good calories. Restrict calories at lunch, and the kids eat junk after school to make up for it. I would much rather schools provided unrestricted salad bars etc. instead of trying to put all the kids on a diet.
- blt 11y agoIf you want a treat, try taking a sip of half-and-half before you pour it in your coffee...
- mullen 11y agoPut it on your cereal for a real delight.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoBetter: whipped cream on corn flakes!
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoMake your coffee out of half-and-half for the real treat!
- codyb 11y agoI love whole milk. Plain and simple. It's delicious. It's got a ton of good fat and protein in it. My entire family drinks it and always has. We're all of healthy weight (my brother and I are actually pretty skinny, although he has a bit of a gut now that he's 32, I'm still 25 and because of handstands and pull ups you can see my abs a bit). We also eat very healthy in general as a family. Lots of pasta with clam sauce, red sauce, alfredo sauce. Lots of vegetables. Avocados. Clementines. And we all lead healthy lifestyles in regards to exercise. Lots of musical instruments being played, hiking, canoeing, walking, and biking. So, I'm not sure what my comment is here really, but the moral of the story seems to be for me: If you eat healthy foods (and don't eat too many processed items), and if you partake in healthy activities, you'll probably end up pretty healthy. How much of it is genes? I have no idea.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoSometimes genes are a good bit of it. In my family we have ~150lb people who eat endlessly, thousands of calories a day. 6 ft tall, thin as a rail. Many of them. So that's got to be genes.
- dragonwriter 11y agoOr, you know, behavioral things like activity patterns, which can be quite heavily influenced by culture even at the level of a family, without being genetic. Or gut flora, which, though there are good reasons that they can tend to be quite closely similar in families, are environmental rather than genetic. "X seems particularly common in family" does not imply "X is genetic".
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoCool; thanks! Didn't consider all that. For us, activity isn't the factor. We were all pretty sedentary as kids. If gut flora is environmental, then that's a no-go since we span 5 states. So in our case, genes is the winner so far.
- 11y ago
- mywittyname 11y agoThe problem, IMHO, is that dietary science makes recommendations based on gross over-simplifications. Creating guidelines based on such overly simplistic grouping of information leads to sub-optimal results because it glosses over important nuances. The saturated v. unsaturated distinction is one that we are finally realizing is not an important to overall health. However, this has been replaced by another is the trans fat v. cis fat distinction. The government is pushing for the removal of trans fats from foods without consideration to the fact that vaccenic acid is a trans fat that is extremely good for mammals (it's found in high quantities in breast milk, for instance) while elaidic acid is what has been linked to low HDL and heart disease. Of course, the population as a whole is no better. They also cherry-pick things they want to be healthy with little consideration of the science behind it. So I'm not sure this is an issue that needs addressing.