4 ms·
"So? Who has the right to tell those people they shouldn't be discussing?" Who is? Not expending resources to actively provide a forum is in no sense "telling
by jerf 11y ago
"So? Who has the right to tell those people they shouldn't be discussing?"
Who is?
Not expending resources to actively provide a forum is in no sense "telling people they shouldn't be discussing a thing". That's an absurd standard.
"Few real-world stuff works like tech-stuff works."
Nope, that's oversimplifying what I said to the point that it's simply not what I said. What I said is that there is nothing I know that works at CNN scale and produces anything remotely sensible. It won't produce a "community", it won't produce a "conversation", it won't produce "democratic debate", it won't change anybody's mind about anything, it's just too darned big to produce anything other than a tumult.
"Besides, I've had wonderful conversations on Slashdot, and Reddit and other places, even places like 9gag."
What does that have to do with anything? They're not CNN. They're external fora. If you're happy with those, you shouldn't have said anything at all; they exist, they will continue to exist, nobody is talking about shutting them down. What's your problem then? The whole point of this conversation is CNN and NYT and Wired (eventually) shutting down comment sections, not anybody else. What do you think you're defending, exactly?
With all due respect, you seem to be so sure you already know what other people are going to say, you don't bother actually reading what they do say. For someone advocating the importance of user comments, that's sort of ironic.
- coldtea 11y ago>Not expending resources to actively provide a forum is in no sense "telling people they shouldn't be discussing a thing". That's an absurd standard. It's not the same as commanding them not to discuss in general anywhere, but IT IS shuting them up from discussion in your (the site owner's I mean) premises. Essentially the message is "I don't like how you are discussing, and I'm stopping you from discussing here anymore". The thing is that that's (a news site comment section) is the only place that all readers of it can discuss it as a community -- the only place that's not disjointed (each own's blog, some social news link site, etc) and the place that guarantess more than any other that readers of the same news piece have a chance to see those comments, and that the writer and outlet will see them too (and publicly). >What does that have to do with anything? They're not CNN. They're external fora. If you're happy with those, you shouldn't have said anything at all; they exist, they will continue to exist, nobody is talking about shutting them down. You missed the point. I didn't say Reddit was closing its forum like CNN. I gave it as an example of a place that's often considered very bad for its comment threads, to say that even there one can have great discussions. My comment meant: "You think the CNN forums are bad? Hey, people knock down Reddit even more, but you can have great discussions there". >What's your problem then? The whole point of this conversation is CNN and NYT and Wired (eventually) shutting down comment sections, not anybody else. What do you think you're defending, exactly? I'm defending NOT closing active comment sections in general, from any site that has them. I'm defending having comment sections in news sites. Why? Because I think discussion on the news, and directly on their source, is important. In fact it was hailed as a big revolution when this web came out -- that readers have a voice to respond to journalists and not just curated "letters to the editor" and disjointed replies from their own website/blog. >With all due respect, you seem to be so sure you already know what other people are going to say, you don't bother actually reading what they do say. Why does it have to get to name-calling? Did I say anything ad-hominem? .
- trowawee 11y ago>It's not the same as commanding them not to discuss in general anywhere, but IT IS shuting them up from discussion in your (the site owner's I mean) premises. Essentially the message is "I don't like how you are discussing, and I'm stopping you from discussing here anymore". The thing is that that's (a news site comment section) is the only place that all readers of it can discuss it as a community -- the only place that's not disjointed (each own's blog, some social news link site, etc) and the place that guarantess more than any other that readers of the same news piece have a chance to see those comments, and that the writer and outlet will see them too (and publicly). Yeah, but they don't owe anyone that. You're positing some duty to provide space for conversation, apparently based on the fact that some sites have provided that space in the past. That's essentially an appeal to tradition while ignoring the actual reality of comments on the internet, which is that A) they almost never contribute meaningfully to a site, B) the only way we've found to create meaningful comment sections is through labor-intensive human moderation that most sites don't want to pay for (and have no duty to pay for), and C) in place of meaningful discussion, most un- or lightly-moderated comment sections are full of terrible people saying terrible things. I'm going to repeat something I said downthread, but no one is preventing anyone from having a voice online. They're just saying that they don't have to publish your voice if they don't want to. You're arguing that the NYT/CNN/$FILL_IN_ORG have some moral duty to provide a space for people to have conversations on their site, about their content, without putting any limits on what is said. You're not describing it that way, because once you confront the reality of that, it becomes ridiculous. Comments, in that sense, aren't "a letter to the editor", they're "I get to tell the editor to publish something and he can't decline." And yeah, having to go read it on your own blog might make the reading experience "disjointed" (whatever that means - clicking a pingback link is about as low-friction as I can imagine in terms of finding pieces responding to the original, especially placed in any kind of historical context), but that's your problem, not the person or organization publishing something. They don't owe you engagement; if you want to engage, make your own site and build your own audience. You don't just get to piggyback on someone else's success to broadcast your thoughts because you want to.