4 ms·
What are they selling, exactly? Why does this need to be a framework, with js and all that? I'm not asking cynically, and following it up with "oh, they should
by scrollaway 11y ago
What are they selling, exactly? Why does this need to be a framework, with js and all that?
I'm not asking cynically, and following it up with "oh, they should just do x instead".... I legitimately do not understand what's going on here. What's the added functionality? I read the article twice, I don't get it. I'm going through the spec, I don't get it. I looked at the article source, I really don't get it, it's just html and common sense.
- ducuboy 11y agoA platform for sharing ad revenue. They deliver all the amp-ads via that single piece of js, and will share some of the revenue with the publishers. It's not a bad idea after all, if only they had presented it for what it is: a Google fork of the Web. The "performance story" is just the bullshit.
- pjc50 11y agoIf they're putting ads in custom tags that makes it extremely easy to block them. I think it's nothing so sinister as a "fork of the web", but a badly thought out approach of going back to faster loading web1.0 by recognizing that quite a lot of JS adds no value to the end user.
- ducuboy 11y agoMy point is that this project is not about providing value to the user. Google could have done that more easily. It may not be so sinister because it's a badly thought out approach indeed. Although they got quite a few big partners already, this undertake requires rewriting the whole Web which is too much to ask even if you are Google.
- pookeh 11y agoIt also becomes extremely easy for browser vendors to not allow blocking them.
- pjc50 11y agoThe closed source ones, perhaps.
- cramforce 11y agoMany ad networks are supported already, all will be. There is no rev share at all.
- ducuboy 11y agoOf course this can't be DoubleClick only. But please tell us more about the business model, I see you're a Google employee.
- cramforce 11y agoBusiness model is the same as any other content website. Monetization through ads, paywalls, etc. Same as before, just with happier users including myself. Happy users are good for business in the long term.
- cramforce 11y agoYou might get it :) There isn't that much to it. AMP is as much about technology as finally getttig that tech adopted. Since AMP is built on web tech there is nothing in it that you cannot chose to do yourself The problem we are solving is that many sites don't.
- rasz_pl 11y agoYou have an uncanny ability to write a lot of words that collectively mean nothing. Are you saying its WeB-Scale? Did you wear a hipster had while posting this?
- dang 11y agoPersonal attacks are not allowed on Hacker News.
- scrollaway 11y agoSo what's with the approach then? Why would websites choose to use AMP (whatever "using AMP" means), when they don't apply common sense in the first place? Forgive the skepticism but this screams XKCD927.
- cramforce 11y agoOne of the things that AMP allows is to know that is it save to prerender a page. Documents can be instructed by a viewer to e.g. only load resources visible above the fold and absolutely no external JS. With general web content prerendering is pretty dangerous and you certainly cannot do it with say more than 1 doc at a time because it may use arbitrary bandwidth and CPU. That allows for instant feeling loading of pages (because they are already loaded when the user clicks) which in turn makes users happy :) While all web pages can be fast, AMP allows proving that they are which makes such a feature possible. A referrer like Twitter or Pinterest or Google could e.g. indicate: Clicks on these links will be super fast (because they are AMP docs). If users click them more (because they like fast) there is a strong incentive for everyone to be fast – and then we all win. I don't think XKCD927 applies, because we only combine existing standards and restrict ourselves voluntarily to a subset of those. Its still just HTML, CSS, JS. Browsers do not need to change. 't