4 ms·
I tend to agree with Cyph0n that patents can promote innovation. But "prior art" ought to be defined sanely. If something has been well known in India for thous
by mirimir 11y ago
I tend to agree with Cyph0n that patents can promote innovation. But "prior art" ought to be defined sanely. If something has been well known in India for thousands of years, how can some multinational patent it? How can some chemical that occurs in nature be patented? And then there's the whole universe of stuff that's different by one atom over there, and so deemed patentable.
- dougabug 11y agoThe question should not be whether you believe that it is possible for patents to promote innovation. Rather can you prove based on evidence that they clearly and irrefutably, in fact, do so? Do patents ever harm or retard innovation? Is it economically worth the burden of the patent system for the benefit achieved, or are there better alternatives? Moreover, how much theoretical economic payoff justifies surrendering a basic right? Should government be given sweeping power to dictate how we use our minds?
- mirimir 11y agoThose are excellent points. There's no doubt that multinationals have gamed the global patent, copyright and trademark systems. On the other hand, it is plausible that the possibility of limited monopoly would promote innovation. But how would one measure costs vs benefits?
- JulianMorrison 11y agoIt's arguable that limited monopoly promotes the first innovation. But it should be obvious, it prevents all the possible third party innovations that riff off the first. It's easy to miss the dog that didn't bark, or the improvement that couldn't be sold.
- dougabug 11y agoThere's also the question of inequality. Granting monopolies exacerbates inequality, so a hypothetical short term boost to productivity growth might not translate into meaningfully better quality of life for most people. Government engineered barriers to competitive use of specific ideas could undermine the bargaining power of workers, and artificially inflate or support prices of key goods. It seems like an innovation supporting tax would be less restrictive, while still rewarding useful innovations that the market somehow fails to reward.
- mirimir 11y agoIndeed. What comes to mind are farmers who depend on highly tweaked crops to survive, but who are forbidden (or prevented by design) from even saving seeds. Let alone trying to improve the strain.
- mirimir 11y agoThat is an excellent point. The key, then, would be to distinguish and reward such primary innovation. Maybe it's obvious when you see it. Or maybe do some Bates thing with panels of experts.
- mirimir 11y agoSuch as TPP: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10363500 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10363500
- zamalek 11y agoPossibly, patent should have some minimal effort time. After, say, 3 years you have to demonstrably prove that you will take the patent to market. For example, a software product should have some code written that uses the patent, even if incomplete. So long as you do nothing with the patent, anyone can get a royalty free license to it when they challenge you (after the grace period). This would encourage people to take their innovations to market, instead of sitting on them and bunkrupting anyone else who tries to.
- teddyh 11y agoYou can game “taking an innovation to market” any number of ways. Making the product unrealistically expensive. Only manufacturing a very limited number, or even a single, item. Making an item that technically uses the patent but is in a very different sort of field than any product which would be actually useful. Making the actual product practically unusable, or hideously ugly, or horribly uncomfortable. These are all things which normally would be solved by competition in the marketplace, but you don’t have competition, since a patent is a monopoly. So you have to solve all these problems some other way.
- mindcrime 11y agoI tend to agree with Cyph0n that patents can promote innovation. They can also inhibit innovation. Something to consider...
- mirimir 11y agoRight. So maybe the key distinction is that breakthrough patents tend to promote innovation, but follow-on patents tend to inhibit innovation.