4 ms·
I think dealing with trolls is easier when you have a community of expats and [something]-philes as your audience. They tend to be more tightly knit, smallish
by mc32 11y ago
I think dealing with trolls is easier when you have a community of expats and [something]-philes as your audience. They tend to be more tightly knit, smallish community with waves of users as people cycle in and out of the country. Because of that the somewhat heavy handed moderation at japantoday was okay. It was more a place for expats to have more or less agreeable opinions about things.
In those cases the volume was rather low and expats were just glad to have a forum so they were more forgiving. It wasn't as if they had an alternative source for copy-pasta news translated to English. So they were a more or less captive audience, regardless.
At a site like CNN, etc. The volume is too large and the kind of moderation people would put up with would be different. So their decision is different.
[edit] you'd need more than one person going thru the firehose at CNN and you'd have a backlash if the pruning displease any of the constituents.
- coldtea 11y ago>At a site like CNN, etc. The volume is too large and the kind of moderation people would put up with would be different. So maybe they could NOT moderate there? How about totally free speech? (which shouldn't need a qualifier such as "totally" in the first place) People enjoy writing in the comments, including those involved in flame wars (especially those: else they wouldn't participate message after message).
- jerf 11y ago"How about totally free speech?" But we've seen the result of that. It's not some sort of blindingly beautiful laboratory of democracy, it's a whole bunch of barely-literate people chanting slogans at each other between the trolls. There's a fundamental structural problem here. Imagine a full stadium of people all trying to talk to each other about the same thing, on the same topic, through the same pipe. What do you expect to happen? No real-world conversations work like that. The Internet can scale conversations up to real-world-absurd sizes, like the one we're having here, but there's still limits, and sites like CNN blast right through them. Not through any fault of their own, they're just too large to host any sort of reasonable conversation. To have reasonable conversations, you need something else, some sort of segmentation, by interests, by personalities, by who happened to show up at some obscure website, something to make it not just a few thousand people trying to shout into the same tin can. This has little-to-nothing to do with "free speech" or ideological issues of any kind... it's an engineering problem. I'd call it social engineering, but that has the entirely wrong connotation for this problem. But it's still some sort of community engineering problem more than anything else. I've had the hobby of watching those sorts of things for about 15 years now and I've never seen even a hint of technology that a site as large as CNN could use to have some sort of robust, interesting debate. The incentives are all wrong, for all the participants, including CNN. Even the best tech I've seen breaks down at what is easily one order of magnitude below what CNN gets, if not two.
- coldtea 11y ago>But we've seen the result of that. It's not some sort of blindingly beautiful laboratory of democracy, it's a whole bunch of barely-literate people chanting slogans at each other between the trolls. So? Who has the right to tell those people they shouldn't be discussing? And with what moral authority? (apart from the sheer power of "I'm the owner of this site, and I will close the forum down"). >There's a fundamental structural problem here. Imagine a full stadium of people all trying to talk to each other about the same thing, on the same topic, through the same pipe. What do you expect to happen? No real-world conversations work like that. Few real-world stuff works like tech-stuff works. That's kind of the point. You don't have to engage with everybody in the same pipe anyway -- you can just focus on the comments you find interesting. Besides, I've had wonderful conversations on Slashdot, and Reddit and other places, even places like 9gag. As for the crap, well I can ignore trolls and bypass opinions I consider uninformed or bad. I can also (if I'm bored and want to pass the time) engage with them. And that's important too. Not hiding unpopular opinions and people we consider "uninformed" under the carpet and pretending they don't exist, because those are parts of life too. Dealing with these is still better than living in an echo chamber.
- jerf 11y ago"So? Who has the right to tell those people they shouldn't be discussing?" Who is? Not expending resources to actively provide a forum is in no sense "telling people they shouldn't be discussing a thing". That's an absurd standard. "Few real-world stuff works like tech-stuff works." Nope, that's oversimplifying what I said to the point that it's simply not what I said. What I said is that there is nothing I know that works at CNN scale and produces anything remotely sensible. It won't produce a "community", it won't produce a "conversation", it won't produce "democratic debate", it won't change anybody's mind about anything, it's just too darned big to produce anything other than a tumult. "Besides, I've had wonderful conversations on Slashdot, and Reddit and other places, even places like 9gag." What does that have to do with anything? They're not CNN. They're external fora. If you're happy with those, you shouldn't have said anything at all; they exist, they will continue to exist, nobody is talking about shutting them down. What's your problem then? The whole point of this conversation is CNN and NYT and Wired (eventually) shutting down comment sections, not anybody else. What do you think you're defending, exactly? With all due respect, you seem to be so sure you already know what other people are going to say, you don't bother actually reading what they do say. For someone advocating the importance of user comments, that's sort of ironic.
- leoedin 11y agoAllowing totally unmoderated comments could lead to the worst aspects of the interent - bullying, harrassment, doxing - as well as open the organisation hosting the comments to legal issues. Free speech may be protected (in the US anyway - most western countries don't have anything like the free speech protection laws that you do, and that's not always a bad thing), but that doesn't give anyone the right to post their speech anywhere. People may enjoy participating in flame wars, but they don't bring much value to the reader. Judging by the number of upvotes, comments tend to be read by far more people than participate. Often insightful and well thought out comments are a pleasure to read. Flame wars? Less so. Maybe I'm coming from a very different point of view though. By far my favourite discussion websites are the ones with agressive moderation policies and a financial barrier to entry. That seems to do wonders to encourage thoughtful and interesting comments.
- coldtea 11y ago>Allowing totally unmoderated comments could lead to the worst aspects of the interent - bullying, harrassment, doxing - as well as open the organisation hosting the comments to legal issues. Or it would lead to people learning to finally handle those things. The problem with bullying in real life is the physical threat. You can't ignore that guy at the bar or the school bully. On the internet you very much can. >People may enjoy participating in flame wars, but they don't bring much value to the reader. Those people participating are also readers. As for readers not interested in that, they can skip the comment section (in most websites those are hidden behind a button or in the bottom of the page, after ads, etc). >By far my favourite discussion websites are the ones with agressive moderation policies and a financial barrier to entry. That seems to do wonders to encourage thoughtful and interesting comments. I like to talk with people that think in a different way than me, including people from other cultures, political affiliations, etc. So something like that would not work at all, it will be a self-selected echo chamber for the most part. For some things thats OK (e.g. HN is a tech-focused site, so you want to keep discussion to those areas). But for general news stories (something like Medium or CNN), no.
- trowawee 11y ago>The problem with bullying in real life is the physical threat. You can't ignore that guy at the bar or the school bully. On the internet you very much can. Unless they send a SWAT team to your house that shoots you, or publish your information all over the web so that your creepy stalker ex can find where you live now and people can steal your identity and ruin your credit, or tell lies about you to your work and get you fired, or overwhelm you with thousands of hateful messages threatening personal harm to you, or do any of the other thousand things that people do, constantly, to other people on the internet that cause them harm in real life. Seriously, we're on a site that has news in the name. You read tech news and have been on the internet for a while, right? How is this still a confusing phenomenon?
- mc32 11y agoTo me there is a difference between a "platform" like twitter, reddit, where I think it behooves them and it's essential to society that they allow free speech in their forums. Or, to be specific, allow communities to establish their own speech policies. On these forums commenters are essentially the producers and the operators harvest the commenters' input. News organizations and other outlets of information where the production is inhouse, or at least, the content is more resource intensive, I think don't have the same obligation. One of their needs is to keep their news and their bias and story (sorry, narrative) prominent, which is their prerogative. I can see them however having "approved" or heavily moderated comments, but, again, at their volume, it might not make economic sense, unless they ship that function off to the Philippines or mechanical turk, but then they have to lay their biases bare in outlining their guidelines.