3 ms·
We are only about 4.4 billion years too late. Mars has be bombarded by Earth rocks (ejecta from large meteor events) for billions of years. Some of these rocks
by danieltillett 11y ago
We are only about 4.4 billion years too late. Mars has be bombarded by Earth rocks (ejecta from large meteor events) for billions of years. Some of these rocks were ejected under conditions where bacterial spores inside them can survive the trip to Mars. I fully expect we will find life on Mars that looks just like Earth life.
There is actually a good case to be made that life originated on Mars given that it had liquid water on the surface earlier than the Earth.
- littlewing 11y agoIt's possible. Personally, I've always had a soft spot for the idea that Eden in the Bible was really not on Earth at all, but Mars or some other location in the universe. The flaming sword that "guarded" Eden could have been a rocket/spaceship at the end of Eden in the "east", the direction of the morning Sun, possibly signifying that it was headed closer to our sun, to Earth. That seems to be a stretch you might say, but, similarly, Genesis tells a story of the creation of life which isn't wholly incompatible with our scientific understanding. There were stars, planets, life originating in plants while the earth was covered with clouds, finally the stars, sun and moon appeared through the clouds, then animals in the sea evolved, then birds/dinosaurs, then mammals, and finally a mammal called a human. Even the rib of Adam could be a simple way of telling about the X chromosome, doubled to make the female (double X chromosomes). Sure, you could say people made up these Bible stories if you want. However, in my mind it closely aligns with current knowledge of science and evolution that it would seem to indicate that humans in the past had some way of knowing past history they'd never experienced. Perhaps something, likely an intelligent entity, spread life to Mars as a seed, it thrived, but then Mars became an inhospitable place so it was moved to Earth. Then later it came back to tell the story to a human or perhaps even all humans, and that story was relayed from generation to generation.
- kibibu 11y ago> Sure, you could say people made up these Bible stories if you want Occam's razor would suggest this is the best approach
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- alphapapa 11y agoOccam's Razor is an aphorism; it does not prove anything one way or the other. Dogmatic adherence to it is no different than dogmatic adherence to religion. Besides that, it is debatable how to apply it to the question of origins. To some, it is a simpler explanation that an intelligent entity created the universe and life, rather than to think that it happened randomly. The heavy downvoting of the GP, which was a well-written, thoughtful comment, demonstrates a close-mindedness and refusal to engage with (or even consider) ideas which one disagrees with--a mindset which religious people are typically accused of having. The irony is not lost on all of us.
- kibibu 11y ago> The heavy downvoting of the GP, which was a well-written, thoughtful comment, demonstrates a close-mindedness and refusal to engage with (or even consider) ideas which one disagrees with You could also have a well-written, thoughtful comment about how vaccination is a Government mind-control device - I suspect it would be no more welcome than one suggesting the biblical genesis story contains the truth about chromosomes. Many of us have engaged with these ideas, found them wanting, found their advocates to be essentially unmoved by reason, and now are happy enough filtering them out. (I am also happy enough being filtered out, as it happens)
- alphapapa 11y agoThat's a false analogy. For example, there is plenty of scientific research showing that vaccination is effective in preventing disease, as well as historical data. However, science cannot disprove the existence of God, nor can it disprove the idea that the universe was created by an intelligent entity. You are also generalizing about advocates of religion. Study history and you will find that there are many, many people throughout history who were very reasonable and also believed in God. In fact, such people are found extensively in the history of all kinds of sciences, including the formation of science itself. And besides that, whether people who believe a certain thing are reasonable is immaterial to the question of whether what they believe is true. There are both sane and insane people who believe things which are true, as well as reasonable and unreasonable people, friendly and unfriendly, etc. You are not being reasonable by being so heavily prejudiced against religion. On the contrary, you are actually being unreasonable.
- manojlds 11y agoIsn't there also a theory that life on Earth could have actually come from Mars via similar means.
- danieltillett 11y agoYes that is what I meant by there is a good case that life originated on Mars first. This hypothesis also fits with the C12/C13 enrichment in ancient sedimentary rocks (enrichment in C12/C13 enrichment is a sign of living metabolic systems) almost as soon as water existed on the Earth’s surface - basically life appeared on Earth as soon as it was possible. It could also explain why the last common ancestor of all living cells was so complex - if life originated on Mars and came to Earth later then all the ancestral life would have been left on Mars. Against the hypothesis that life originated on Mars is the fact that Mars is much smaller than the Earth (the surface area of Mars is about the same as Africa). All things being equal if the conditions for life originating were the same on both planets (at the same time) then we might expect life to be more likely to have originated on Earth.
- drewblaisdell 11y ago> Some of these rocks were ejected under conditions where bacterial spores inside them can survive the trip to Mars. I fully expect we will find life on Mars that looks just like Earth life. I hope that, if we do find life on Mars, we are able to discern whether it came from Earth at some point or originated on Mars.
- danieltillett 11y agoThis is actually my biggest worry with the search for life on Mars - if we find life and it is related to life on Earth is it native or is it Earth-life contamination that came with the spaceship? There will be no easy way to tell.
- eveningcoffee 11y agoGenomics. Organisms from current Earth and early Earth should have vastly different genome. It would be more tricky to determine if life originates from Earth or Mars if we make an assumption that early life went through many iterations.
- danieltillett 11y agoIf only it were so simple. The problem is we are not sure of all the genetic diversity of the life we have on Earth, especially the extremophile bacteria and archea [1] that are the most likely to survive the trip to Mars as contaminants. My best guess is we will find organisms related to microbes on Earth. The really interesting thing is we might find organisms that are more distantly related than the our current last common ancestor. This would be amazing as we would then know that life originated on Mars and came to Earth later. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extremophile https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extremophile