4 ms·
That is per block yes? And each block has upto 01Mb of transactions?
by lifeisstillgood 11y ago
That is per block yes? And each block has upto 01Mb of transactions?
- eru 11y agoPeople are increasing the transaction limit.
- pjc50 11y agoI hear this is encoutering resistance as it reduces the likelihood of people giving non-trivial fees to miners?
- bduerst 11y agoThis has been talked about for over a year now and the miners have made it pretty clear they're not going to adopt it, especially given that these failing "stress tests" generate more profit for them. Even XT adoption is abysmal.
- aianus 11y ago> miners have made it pretty clear they're not going to adopt it Source? Commercial miners make the vast majority of their money on the block reward which has nothing to do with the size of the block. If anything, they'll make more money with less variance with a larger block (since small miners with worse connectivity will have a higher orphan rate). The only people I've seen opposing a block size increase are idealists who are afraid of further centralization of mining power as hobbyist/small miners will have a more difficult time participating (you'll need faster internet and larger hard drives). My money is on a block size increase in the next 1-2 years.
- eru 11y agoHow much money, and what odds are you offering?
- aianus 11y agoI'd put $100 on it but I'm not sure what the prevailing odds are or where we might place the bet. Are there any legitimate prediction markets still operating where we might be able to do this? I googled around a little for it and stumbled across Augur (http://www.augur.net/ http://www.augur.net/) but it seems too alpha for such a long term bet right now.
- bduerst 11y agoThe miners shot down the four proposals to increase block size, even the tiny 2MB increase. Increased competition to get in on the smaller blocks leads to larger transaction fees. Miners benefit from people competing to have their transactions hashed in the next block. If the userbase scales, the competition goes up and transaction fees go higher. If everyone could get their transactions through on a larger block, they're going to pay almost no fee and miner's make less.
- fryguy 11y agoIt's 25 BTC + miner fees per block. According to the website linked, it's about 20-30 BTC per block, so at $250 USD/BTC, that's ~$12,000 USD per block of electricity.
- pjc50 11y agoAs fryguy says, that's $7 per transaction, $12,000 per block. Amusingly as bitcoin gets more successful and the price rises, the system gets less efficient to compensate.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- aminok 11y agoThat is not how it works. The system gets more efficient as transaction volume increases. The only reason the cost of running the network relative to the number of transactions currently comes out to $7 per tx is that much of the revenue miners earn is from the block subsidy of 25 BTC per 10 minutes. The subsidy is a constant, and therefore as tx volume increases, the total cost of running the network relative to the number of txs decreases.
- bduerst 11y agoNo, that's not how it works. Transaction volume doesn't increase with efficiency. Blocksize is capped at 1MB, and any new efficiency goes into the hashing algorithms, not the size. The Bitcoin network has always only been able to handle 1 MB of transactions every 10 minutes (~7 tx/s) and always will at this rate.
- aminok 11y agoNo, it is not. Efficiency increases with transaction volume. That transaction volume is currently capped at 1 MB is a separate issue from whether efficiency improves with transaction volume. It's possible there is a misunderstanding here with me interpreting "gets more successful" as seeing its transaction volume increase, and you interpreting it to mean something else.
- bduerst 11y agoYou can't fit more transactions into 1,048,576 bytes with more efficiency. It's pretty clear.